Chivalric IR makes competitive militarism inevitable – they cannot reduce the probability of great power war within their framework
Sjoberg, 2010. (Laura, Assistant Professor of Political Science at U Florida, PhD in IR and Gender Studies and a law degree specializing in IR. “Gendering Power Transition Theory,” in Gender and International Security edited by Sjoberg, p. 93-95 - spp)
International system patriarchy, great state equality, and the risk of war: PTT has found empirical support for the prediction that war is more likely surrounding a power transition between two great states, and most likely when their capabilities are equally distributed. 110 A feminist approach suggests that states' resistance to equality comes from the patriarchal nature of the international system. In such a forum, the dominant masculinity wins by exposing the latent femininity in subordinate masculinities. In a system that values superiority and patriarchy, or a "war system," 111 violence is the norm and not the exception. The argument that international system patriarchy is a permissive and instigative cause of great power war is difficult to test because the international system has always been patriarchal. The hypothesis predicts the same result as power transition analysis. Still, the two theories' predictions can be distinguished in times when the challenger does not start a war with the hegemon. The feminist hypothesis places primary emphasis on states' jockeying for position in a hierarchical system. Since jockeying for position can occur without military conflict, the feminist hypothesis expects gendered competition between great powers even when they do not go to war. 112 The Cold War gives a good example of the distinction made above. It has been said that PTT could not predict the occurrence of the Cold War.113 PTT would have expected the Soviet Union, approaching equality with the US in the 1950s or 1960s, to start a war in order to reorganize the international system in its interests. The feminist reformulation (R3) suggests that the US and the Soviet Union would compete for the coveted position of apparent (masculine) dominance regardless of the organization of the international system or whether a war occurs. Anecdotal evidence for such a supposition can be found in Carol Cohn’s reports that a “well-known academic security adviser was quoted as saying that ‘under Jimmy Carter the United States is spreading its legs for the Soviet Union’” or in John F. Kennedy’s campaigns for office “promising to halt America’s decline into flabbiness and impotence against the threat of a ‘ruthless’ and expanding Soviet empire.” Cynthia Enloe links this competition not to immediate dissatisfaction with the international system, but instead to “the inherent nature of states… [and] the masculine character of the state elite” competing in a patriarchal international system. Additional evidence that the feminist explanations are more likely comes from how great states come into conflict when they do. The PTT scenario is one where the challenger’s dissatisfaction come from the international system being shaped by the hegemon against the interest of the challenger. The challenger, then, starts a conflict rationally in order to reshape the international system. A war caused by challenger dissatisfaction, then, should be anticipated, started rationally, and fought for goals stated in terms of advancement of national interests in the international system. The scenario that (R3) suggests, however, pictures very different genesis of conflict. The conflict brought about by position-jockeying in a patriarchal system could begin with a series of mistakes of miscommunications. It could be triggered by some insult to the nation’s status, capabilities, or masculinity. An example of such a scenario can be found in the genesis of World War I, which has been described as an accidental war which resulted from competitive national pride and (individual and state) jockeying for position in a hierarchy defined by hegemonic masculinity. Feminist scholars have also noted the relationship between the competition in the Spanish-American War and “US and European male codes of honour” including state “competitiveness, independence, and persistence.” These examples suggest the plausibility of the feminist supposition that the patriarchal atmosphere of the international system could have something to do with why states fight wars when the reach relative power parity. If (R3) is correct, then it is possible to envision great state equality without war in a non-patriarchal international system. In a system that values care and empathy, actors would be interested in the collective security of the world’s citizens. Such a system would prioritize understanding, communication, and community. A feminist perspective might imagine challenging great powers to engage in empathetic cooperation, and suggest that major powers take unilateral steps to transgress the cycle of violence in international politics. Each power would engage in purposive compromise of values and interests in order to create peace between them. In PTT's scenario of potential conflict between the US and China, then, the US should not fear a dissatisfied China or attempt co-option. Instead, it should attempt to understand the interests, values, and needs of those challengers. If challengers took a similar approach, they would not have to choose between unattainable satisfaction and perpetual dissatisfaction. Along these lines, feminists suggest that the US should include China in deliberative dialogues, treat the Chinese government and people with empathy and understanding, and show China and other potential challengers by example that the strong can defy international system patriarchy unilaterally and stop the cycle of violence. Feminists have argued that inclusive understanding is key to peaceful coexistence. Spike Peterson clarifies that "feminists argue that the domination of women, nature, and all who are constructed as 'other' is not a matter of 'essential,' atemporal qualities but of socially constructed, historically contingent." 122 In other words, the voices of marginalization could serve as a bridge between hostile and masculinized states. In these terms, a dialogue which promoted understanding between the US and China (and their differentiated citizens) would go a long way towards decreasing the potential for conflict between the two great states.