Structural patriarchy is a form of necropolitical management which is genocidal of queer, feminine, and minority bodies
Lamble 13 (Dr. Sara –Senior Lecturer in Law at University of London at Birkbeck, 8-4-13, “Queer Necropolitics and the Expanding Carceral State: Interrogating Sexual Investments in Punishment”, https://www.academia.edu/4438801/Queer_Necropolitics_and_the_Expanding_Carceral_State_Interrogating_Sexual_Investments_in_Punishment)
Necropolitics of Imprisonment Each of the above examples involves the direct or indirect mobilisation of discursive, financial or labour-related resources towards state practices of imprisonment and punishment. Given the ongoing colonial legacies of the carceral state, the disproportionate number of people of colour in prison and the widespread abuses within carceral institutions, these queer investments in punishment are, by their very nature, investments in state racism and violence. In this way, such investments are symptomatic of what Jasbir Puar, drawing from Achilles Mbembe’s work, describes as queer necropolitics. Necropolitics can be understood as technologies of power that (re)produce social relations of living and dying, such that some populations are ushered into the worlds of life and vitality, while others are funnelled into what Mbembe calls death-worlds—worlds of slow living death, and dead living (Mbembe 2003). Death here includes literal physical death, but also social, political and civil death—the social relations of death, decay and dying that emerge from prolonged exposure to violence, neglect, deprivation and suffering. Offering a corrective to Michel Foucault’s work on biopolitics, Mbembe puts forward the notion of necropolitics and necropower to account for the various ways in which, in our contemporary world, weapons are deployed in the interest of the maximum destruction of persons and the creation of death-worlds, new and unique forms of social existence in which vast populations are subjected to conditions of life conferring up on them the status of living dead (2003, p. 40). In other words, while biopolitical powers work to manage, order and foster life for citizens worthy of protection, such powers work in tandem with necropolitical powers that produce death for those destined to abandonment, violence and neglect. Taking up this concept within contemporary queer politics, Puar draws attention to the ways in which the folding into life of some queers is predicated on the folding out of life of others (Puar 2007, p. 36). On one level, as Braidotti (2007) notes, ‘Bio-power and necro-politics are two sides of the same coin’; the relationship between the governance of life and death cannot be separated. Indeed, Foucault notes the inherent tension within the classical theory of sovereignty in the right of power over life and death. Because the sovereign has no capacity to create life, the ‘right of life and death is always exercised in an unbalanced way: the balance is always tipped in favour of death’ (Foucault 1976/2003, p. 240). Hence the ‘very essence of the right of life and death is actually the right to kill; it is at the moment when the sovereign can kill that he exercises his right over life’ (Foucault 1976/2003, p. 240). Yet the emergence of biopower, argues Foucault, marks a shift in this balance, from the right to take life or let live, to the power to make live and let die. Biopower intervenes in the conditions of life at the level of populations to improve, prolong, extend living; it is a technique of governance aimed at maximising, optimising and fostering life.25 Yet the tension between the exercise of power over life and death remains. For if biopower seeks to maximise life, what justifies its continued exercise of death? It is here, Foucault argues, that racism intervenes, as ‘the precondition that makes killing acceptable’ (1976/2003, p. 256). For the imperative to kill is acceptable only if it results not in a victory over political adversaries, but in the elimination of the biological threat to and the improvement of the species or race…Once the State functions in biopower mode, racism alone can justify the murderous function of the State (Foucault 1976/2003, p. 256). Racism is therefore not an aberration within the exercise of biopower, but a key premise in determining which populations will be made to live and left to die. Taking this analysis further, Mbembe asks whether biopolitics can fully account for specific conditions, processes and techniques in which contemporary forms of life are subjugated by the power of death: Is the notion of biopower sufficient to account for the contemporary ways in which the political, under the guise of war, of resistance, or of the fight against terror, makes the murder of the enemy its primary and absolute objective?… What place is given to life, death and the human body (in particular the wounded or slain body)? How are they inscribed in the order of power?’ (Mbembe 2003, p. 12). Mapping out the ways in which the politics of death are central to contemporary modes of governance and warfare, Mbembe suggests the creation of deathwords is not merely a by-product of biopower, but a primary aim of its counterpart, necropower. Indeed, the administering of life is increasingly contingent upon, and supplemented by, new forms of sovereign power that are deployed in the administration of mass death and destruction.While Mbembe’s analysis focuses primarily on situations of military occupation, colonialism and war, the modern prison arguably constitutes another key instantiation of necropower. For the prison is a site that produces the conditions of living death; it is a place where bodies are subject to regimes of slow death and dying. Not only are deprivation, abuse and neglect regular features of incarceration but the monotonous regime of caged life—the experience of ‘doing time’—involves the slow wearing away of human vitality and the reduction of human experience to a bleak existence (Scraton and McQulloch 2009; Taylor 2000). This is especially true within regimes of solitary confinement, particularly in ‘supermax’ or ‘special housing units’ in the USA where prisoners are locked up for 23 hours a day, only permitted an hour of exercise in pens the size of dog cages, subjected to windowless cells and deprived of virtually any human contact—not only for days, but for years—with devastating mental health consequences (Haney 2003). In these ways, the prison serves as a site of mass warehousing of bodies in conditions that often resemble the death-worlds that Mbembe describes. While the modern prison was designed as an institution which aimed in part to train prisoners as productive workers, obedient citizens and docile subjects—a strategy that used disciplinary power in the broader service of biopolitical power (Foucault 1978/1995)—contemporary prisons are little more than mass warehouses for poor, racialised and otherwise disenfranchised populations (Gilmore 2007). As prison populations continue to grow to unprecedented levels, many states are abandoning even the pretence of rehabilitation, by dramatically reducing the hours that prisoners spend out of their cells, slashing funding for educational and other programmes and increasingly leaving prisoners to spend their days in monotonous isolation. These conditions, coupled with overcrowding, lack of adequate medical care and disconnection from family and friends, mean that prisoners experience high risks of self-harm, psychological abuse, trauma and suicide, both during imprisonment and post-release (Collins 2008; Taylor 2000; Kupers 2006). A criminal record also means that employment and housing are difficult to secure postrelease, family and community relationships are difficult to re-establish, and problems of poverty, mental illness and addiction persist—such that the consequences of imprisonment extend well beyond the duration of one’s sentence. The added combination of intensive surveillance and disciplinary probation regimes on the one hand, and limited post-release supports on the other, also mean that a high portion of prisoners experience repeated cycles of capture and release in the ‘revolving door’ of imprisonment. The prison thus plays a significant role in altering the ‘distribution of life chances’ or what Gilmore (2007, p. 247) describes as ‘group differentiated vulnerability to premature death’. In one sense, the after-effects of imprisonment can be understood as unfortunate but inevitable ‘challenges’ that prisoners face in recuperating from their sentences. But on another level, these ‘collateral consequences’ constitute a form of legally sanctioned social abandonment. Because ex-prisoners can be legally discriminated against with respect to housing, employment, education, jury duty, volunteer service and social assistance access, a criminal conviction becomes a ‘negative credential’ that functions as a ‘unique mechanism of state-sponsored stratification’ (Alexander 2010, p. 148). Voting restrictions—including the disenfranchisement of prisoners while serving sentences in Britain, and the permanent disenfranchisement of felons in some US states—marks another mode of exclusion from the polis (Manza and Uggen 2006). But perhaps more importantly, the social stigma and shame of a criminal conviction casts a long shadow on the future prospects of the (ex)prisoner. Marked as permanently failed, perpetually dangerous, and always suspicious, prisoners do not simply serve their time and move on; they pay the debt over and over in the form of stigma, shame and exclusion. A prison sentence thus becomes one of the most powerful ways that working class, black, migrant, disabled and other over-criminalised populations, are legally subjected to social, civil, and political death. To argue that the prison is an institution of necropolitical power and that prisoners are resigned to slow death, is not to deny the resilience and agency of those who survive prison on a daily basis. It is instead to underscore how the conditions of captivity govern life in ways that are akin to slow and prolonged death, thus severely restricting the possibilities for resistance and survival. Ironically, and perhaps most devastatingly, it is through the act of potentially reclaiming death that prisoners exercise a desperate form of agency. As Mbembe argues, in the realms of the living dead, death offers a brutal moment of power. ‘For death is precisely that from and over which I have power. But it is also that space where freedom and negation operate’ (Mbembe 2003, p. 39). Hence it should be no surprise that the hunger strike—the exercise of threat of the living to authorise their own death—persists as a last resort of collective power in prison. As the recent prisoner hunger strikes in California, Italy, England, Palestine, Guantanamo Bay and elsewhere have demonstrated—alongside other less visible forms of collective organising inside—there is persistent resilience among prisoners to resist and survive the brutal conditions of their captivity.26 Arguably, what makes the prison an example of necropolitics, and not just an instance of ruthless state brutality, is that the imposition of death and suffering on some populations is explicitly legitimised and authorised in the name of fostering and protecting the life of others. In other words, the enhancement and protection of life for some is predicated on the violent sequestering of others. There are parallels here to what Nikolas Rose (2000) describes as circuits of security and circuits of insecurity—contemporary forms of governance that work by moving some subjects into modes of security and others into abandonment—as well as to what Judith Butler (2004) describes as the politics of ‘precarious life’ or what Elizabeth Povinelli (2011) refers to ‘economies of abandonment’. Necropolitics, however, draws more explicit attention to the deathly logic of these modes of governance, foregrounding the exercise of sovereign power (both within and beyond the state) to authorise and legitimate the politics of death and killing in the name of vitality and living. Examining these queer investments in punishment and necropolitics, we can identify several recurring patterns.