Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Embrace the 1% risk – vulnerability is an inevitable component of life – securitizing against it doesn’t solve and backfires

Enloe 2004 - Cynthia Enloe, Professor of Women’s Studies at Clark University, The Curious Feminist, 2004, pp. 265-266 (SPP).

CC: But I think the problem is more than the sense of being vulnerable. It is the refusal to acknowledge the inevitability of our vulnerability. After all, vulnerability is a fact of human and political life. The attempt to deny its inevitability is what has led to the development of weapons of mass destruction "as deterrents," to massive investments in "national missile defense" and other baroque weapons technology, while we refuse to make serious investments in dealing with the worldwide HIV epidemic, or starvation, or poverty around the world. It has led to U.S. partnerships with oppressive regimes and multiple military attacks on other nations - Iraq, Iran, North Korea - even as we speak! And all of these, of course, are part of what creates the desperation and anger that are the seeds of terrorism. My fantasy is that if we acknowledged the impossibility of making ourselves invulnerable, of constructing Reagan's Plexiglas shield, we would have to have policies that fostered and strengthened goodwill and interdependence, that invested in making the planet a livable place for people in all countries, that aimed at disarmament instead of weapons "advancement" and proliferation. And my fear is that we won't acknowledge it, because these assumptions about strength and weakness, and vulnerability, are simultaneously engaged at the very personal, identity level but also built right into beliefs about national security and into national security doctrine - as though they reflected "objective reality" and in no way stemmed from deeply felt and held identities. So stopping to try to disentangle emotions and assumptions about violence and its efficacy was the starting place for me. Ultimately, I want to ask what it will take to change the discourse, to alter the meanings of strength and justice in the international political arena.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.