Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The inward confrontation of vulnerability is essential to cut off the violent outward expression of chivalric masculinity

Zolkos, 2011 (Magdalena Zolkos, Research Fellow in Political Theory in the Centre for Citizenship and Public Policy at the University of Western Sydney, “Can there be Costless War? Violent Exposures and (In)Vulnerable Selves in Benjamin Percy’s ‘Refresh, Refresh’” Critical Horizons 12.2 2011 251-269 (mjb).

For Butler, operative in post-9/11 American war is the “denial of vulnerability”, which is being institutionalized in various “fantasies of mastery”.18 In turn, Jabri writes about the distinctively late-modern elimination of the demand for self-sacrifice in warfare as an “aspiration for war in the absence of injury to the self”, so that “the infliction of injury [on the other] may take place in the near absence of harm to those perpetrating the act”, also known as “risk-transfer warfare”, or, in different political discourses, “humanitarian warfare”.19 The problematic of war has been closely linked with questions of political violence. Elaine Scarry has famously argued that war bridges two domains of human experience: the domain of contest and the domain of harm-doing to the bodies and properties of others.20 Jabri has argued for an understanding of war as “injurious”, both in corporeal and societal terms.21 For Jabri, the violence of war cannot be seen as consisting of “extra-social elements”, but, on the contrary, as “located in a society”, a “product of that society”, and a significant factor in the “formation and transformation of that society”. War is thus “constitutively social” and its violence is manifest in areas of public and private life that far exceed the military domains, including “the everyday, […] the routine, [and] the mundane order of things”. The violence of war, therefore, is political not only in (a) being motivated by politically contingent aims of invasion, conquest, and expansion, and (b) in its dependence on the development of different techniques and strategies of “injurious impingement”,22 but also (c) in so far as it preys on the social and psycho-somatic vulnerability of human body. In its emphasis on the intersubjective dimension of violence, the feminist critique of war has recognized that the subject herself/himself becomes affected and permeated, or, to but in Butler’s terms, that the subject comes “undone”, by/in the violent act against the other. Drawing on the critical theorizing of war in the writings of Butler and Jabri, I turn to the unsettling literary depictions of violence by Benjamin Percy in his collection Refresh, Refresh (and in particular to the opening story under the same title). I trace how the allegedly “removed”, “sterile” or “costless” acts of injury in war that are undertaken away from home and in the name of the protection of home, return and haunt the subject at home. As a contribution to the critique of war violence, my reading points at the auto-immunitary logic, which has been at work in the costless war fantasy, specifically, but not exclusively, in the context of America’s invasion on Iraq. Within the parameters of the auto-immunitary logic, the US government, which seeks to pre-empt and eradicate specific modality of (“terrorist”) violence through invasive military action, paradoxically, regenerates violence through radicalization and militarization of those whom it targets. I argue that auto-immunity operated also in Percy’s story (though in less causally obvious or direct way) insofar as America’s war engenders violence also among those whom it claims to protect, and whose identification and loyalty it demands. In “Refresh, Refresh” it is a generation of young male adolescents who have been “abandoned” by their working-class fathers in the military. They are “abandoned” not only in the sense that they live without parental supervision and with the unfulfilled acute desire for the father’s presence, but also in the sense of being the “invisible subjects” (until the moment when they are recognized as ready for military conscription) – in other words, they are “larval subjects”,23 unfolding from their juvenile and incubated forms into a state of “readiness”. At the background of the critical discussions that point out how the figure of the Iraqi, Afghani or the Arab Other becomes subject to de-humanizing tactics, my reading might appear not only provisional, but also precarious, as it risks re-investing in the category of the already all-too-visible American subject. The intention is not to distract from the cataclysmic consequences of the US post-9/11 wars for the Iraqi and Afghani people. The aim is not to re-invest in the privileged subjective categories, but to re-figure the (alleged) subjects of invulnerable politics, which moves away from the fantasies of mastery and towards ethical consideration of war violence through the prism of relational and inter-subjective vulnerability. From the perspective of Levinasian ethics of alterity, Dave Lightener’s face interpellates the Tumalo boys both to violence and to non-violence. It at once invokes the “temptation to kill and an interdiction against killing”, locating Josh and Gordon in that “mixed and conflicted position of a subject who is injured, rageful, disposed to violent retribution”.44 Butler, drawing on Levinas, locates the emergence of subjectivity in the tension between the “fear of undergoing violence and the fear of inflicting violence”.45 Importantly, the tension of that position is not located in the subject since she/ he [they]cannot, in both chronological and constitutive sense, pre-exist that primary tension of being both the agent and an object of violence. Rather, it is located in that prior inability to “move away and break from” (the address of) the Other, which operates in the text of “Refresh, Refresh” as the shameful affect that renders the subject “naked” (uncovered, unguarded, vulnerable) in the face of the Other. In the quoted final part of the story it is crucial that Lightener never declares the father dead. Lightener’s only verbalization in that passage is a plea for mercy – an expression of unconditional capitulation vis-à-vis the uncontrolled eruption of violence. The spontaneous act of overpowering and silencing Lightener is the boys’ desperate attempt to stage resistance to the formulaic utterance of condolences, which postulates grief as a patriotic response and seeks to contain and transform it into a platform of further military-masculine mobilization. The shared vulnerabilities that Dave Lightener and Josh embody in that concluding scene mean that, momentarily, they are constituted vis-à-vis one another through, on the one hand, their capacity for violence (the capacity to injure the other) and, on the other hand, also through their susceptibility to violence and the injurious action of the other. The representations of the physical precariousness of the body form in Percy’s story intricate connections with socio-political modes of “injury” – dispossession, exploitation, and privation. While in “Refresh, Refresh” the synergic capacity to inflict harm and to remain susceptible to harm is depicted with a narrative specificity characteristic of literary representations, I suggest that it demonstrates a larger point about human vulnerability and the reciprocal workings of violence. It precisely that “truth” about violence and vulnerability, which is being obliterated in the imageries of the costless war, and in the politics of invulnerability that they animate. The reciprocities and returns of violence leave no one in the story unharmed; neither those exposed to it, nor those complicit with it. In arguing that war violence is irreducible to the situations of the battlefield or to the military domain more generally (be it remote and “virtual” or proximate and “real”), I have sought to use Percy’s striking short-story to illuminate the location of violence at the cross-roads of inter-subjectivity, politics and ethics. Benjamin Percy’s depiction of the “abandoned” Tumalo boys as larval subjects shows how violence permeates across socio-political boundaries and across human bodies, and how it strikes at the heart of what (in the official military discourses) one has sought to protect through war: the peaceful, i.e. non-violent, American home. In contrast, the mastery discourses of the costless war fantasy build on the normative assumption that war violence can be compartmentalized, controlled and unidirectional (always working away from the subject). Perhaps, what is at stake in these repudiations of vulnerability is nothing short of a question of what it means to be human if, within these literary representations and the critical theoretical voices about war, different modes of humanity are so tightly linked to the recognition of the reciprocal workings of violence. It remains to be asked how, within that conjunction of violence and vulnerability, one could think non-violence – not as the demarcation of the domain of invulnerable self, but, rather, as an inquiry into the significance of the singular moment when one refrains from violence. In this alternative imaginary setting, non-violence is not the inactive or passive binary opposite of violence, but an ethical, and possibly political, action. Could sparing Dave Lightener’s life by the Tumalo boys be thought of as an act of non-violence? Perhaps not, since its significance is subsequently obliterated by their submission to the military masculine subject positions, into which they have been interpellated. Their own conscription into the military shares common grammar with their earlier self-injurious and self-destructive actions. However, the narrative also suggests that any act of political non-violence must emerge from within the recognition of vulnerability as affirmation of the violent exposure of the self to the Other. I conclude with a passage quotation from a final story in the collection Refresh, Refresh, “When the Bear Came”, where in my opinion Percy comes closest to imagining such violent encounter between the self and Other.46 My suggestion is that “When the Bear Came” gestures towards the ethics of relational and communicative potentialities that arise from shared vulnerability. Notably, it is a story about an encounter between a human and a non-human Other – a bear whom the narrator (also an adolescent man from Tumalo) obsessively seeks to find, catch and violently pacify. When the encounter finally occurs, and the desire to kill the bear becomes a real possibility, the man facing the bear finds himself affected and “undone” by the encounter, beyond his control and calculation: I was just out of its reach, but not so far that I couldn’t feel the air move, displaced by its claws. It wrestled with the rope a moment, like a dog bothered by a leash, then returned its attention to me. A low growl rumbled from deep its throat. I could feel its eyes, like two heavy weights, on me. It was hungry. And I imagined what its jaws would feel like working around my skull, or through my belly, my flesh sinking into the dark oblivion of its stomach. We stayed like this for a time, looking at each other, each afraid and hateful. Minutes passed and the stars wheeled above us and I slowly brought my shotgun down from my shoulder and held it before me. ‘I should kill you’, I said, a gentle sort of loathing in my voice, ‘You son of a bitch, I should kill you dead’. I could feel the blood pounding through my heart and I could hear the air filling and emptying its lungs. I tried to breathe with the bear and soon our breathing fell into a rhythm where our lungs worked in perfect time with the wind, with the shifting of the branches and shadows. It was as if a rhythm had been beating all along, the rhythm of the land, and finally I had found it, here in the peace of the dark woods, with only one slug and twenty feet of rope between me and absolution.47

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.