Only our deconstructive critique can broaden the scope of analysis sufficiently to support activism outside the narrow confines of liberal reform projects
Haritaworn, Kuntsman, and Posocco 14 (Jin Haritaworn is Assistant Professor of Gender, Race and Environment at York University in Toronto. Adi Kuntsman is Simon Research Fellow at the University of Manchester. Adi’s research interests include queer politics in Israel-Palestine; war and violence in digital media; and affect and emotions. Silvia Posocco is Lecturer, Department of Psychosocial Studies, Birkbeck College, University of London. Introduction: Queer Necropolitics. Pp19-21)
Through the concept-metaphor of queer necropolitics, the contributors to this book broaden our perception of life, death, violence and survival by attending to different sites, such as the borderzone, the warzone, the prison and the gentrifying area. These Mbembian ‘topographies of cruelty’ are by no means an exclusive map of necropolitical spatialities. More work is needed in order to make sense of the queer vitalities that have proliferated across various sites – including institutions of punishment alongside institutions of ‘care’, such as schools, psychiatric units and youth work, as well as the informal spaces and connectivities – the queer ‘scene’, the queer ‘neighbourhood’, the globalizing LGBT movement – that increasingly follow similar punitive and pathologizing logics. While queer necropolitics is not the only tool through which such work is possible, we have offered it up as an insurgent vocabulary that can help us make sense of the many forms of death that accompany and condition queer claims to life, visibility and protection. Its attraction lies precisely in its ability to capture seemingly unrelated phenomena simultaneously, and to bring back into a shared plane of intelligibility struggles that we are often told are mutually exclusive. It may help us, for example, to understand figures such as the ‘welfare queen’ (Cohen 1997; Roberts 1997), the ‘monster-terrorist-fag’ (Puar and Rai 2002), the ‘drunk Indian’ (Razack 2012), the ‘black rioter’ (Breggin 1995) and the ‘hateful Muslim youth’ (Haritaworn 2013), as related not only to one another but also to the figure of the ‘queer lover’, whose ascendancy from degeneracy occurs in shared environments shaped by the same murderous processes. What would it mean to enter into kinship with these pathologized figures? How might we – from our various positionalities – explore gender and sexuality beyond these necropolitical moulds? One way to think crucially and responsibly about queer politics in these times is to refuse the call to become what we call ‘happy queers’ (or, indeed, nostalgic queers) whose recruitment for sexual celebration serves to euphemize and accelerate the death of Others – who for some of us indeed include our own. Instead, we must attend to the forces that prepare queer and indeed non-queer bodies for premature death (see also Cohen 2011). Yet our motivation must be to go much further, to foster the survival of those who were ‘meant to perish’ but are not disposable, to repeat Che Gossett’s moving words (2011: n.p.). What would a politics, queer or otherwise, that is serious about such a resistant and allied task look like? How can we engage in unalienated politics, where safer spaces are not won by reproducing cannibalistic, criminalizing and pathologizing regimes or by inserting ourselves into militarizing and security logics, and where the violence of the most powerful (such as the racist and neo/colonial state, the market, the prison and the hospital) is scandalized at least as loudly as the acts of those thus subjugated? We see the necropolitical as one in a range of possible tools to explore the possibilities of such a politics, since it helps us make sense of the symbiotic copresence of life and death, manifested ever more clearly in the cleavages between rich and poor, citizens and non-citizens (and those who can be stripped of citizenship at any moment); the culturally, morally, economically valuable and the pathological; queer subjects invited into life and queerly abjected populations marked for death. Yet this book is in conversation not just with those interested in testing the promises and limits of a specifically necropolitical framework, but also with other trajectories of decolonizing gender and sexuality. More generally, it responds to the new hunger for queerly theorizing about structural violence and injustice, from tightening borders, mass incarceration, and the wars without end, to the everyday, banal workings of the market. On an activist level, this is reflected in the growth of feminist, queer and trans movements that radically refigure that which counts as a ‘queer and trans issue’, by moving away from narrow liberal and identitarian notions of protection, tolerance, victimhood and visibility and towards careful mappings of the bigger picture (Bassichis, Lee and Spade 2011). We are especially encouraged to witness, through international collaborations such as this, the growth of a radical queer and trans activism which, stepping into the footsteps of a re-radicalized anti-racist feminism, seeks to fight oppression in all its intersections and manifestations, including the normalized, the banal, and the systemic (Decolonize Queer 2011; Gender Just 2011; Incite! – Critical Resistance 2001; Incite! 2006; Khalass We’re Vex 2013; SUSPECT 2010; Sylvia Rivera Law Project et al. 2009). If this has so far largely remained parochial to the North American context, we hope that projects such as Queer Necropolitics will help us catch up with the moves of capital and ideology, so that resistant knowledges, too, may begin to cross borders and ‘unmap’ (Razack 2002) the geopolitics of violence, abandonment, and death. We hope that this book will be a stepping stone for forging a transnational lens that is adequate to this task.