Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Bottom Up Feminist Peace Strategies are inconsistent with Top-Down Approaches to Security

Väyrynen, 2019 (Tarja Väyrynen is a professor of Peace and Conflict Research and a director of Tampere Peace Research Institute (TAPRI). Her research interests include conflict resolution and peacebuilding, feminist theory and post-colonial theory. “Mundane peace and the politics of vulnerability: a nonsolid feminist research agenda,” Peacebuilding, 7:2, 146-159, spp)

Subaltern views of peace are important for local turn scholarship since subaltern actors possess everyday agency in either promoting peace or resisting top-down neoliberal peacebuilding attempts. The everyday is fundamental for this branch of thinking, as the ‘pursuit of everyday tasks may allow individuals and communities in villages, valleys and city neighborhoods to develop common bonds with members of other ethnic or religious groups, to demystify “the other” and to reconstruct contextual legitimacy’.16 Given the agency that the subaltern exercises, the local turn responds by focusing on everyday life and the forms of transversal solidarity and grassroots mobilisation that enable peacebuilding. In other words, the assumption is that a vibrant civil society and an everyday solidarity cutting across ethnic and religious affiliations is the guarantee of peace. The local turn argues that the promoters of liberal peace fail to recognise this type of agency and solidarity in their focus on elite-lead and top-down approaches to peacebuilding and thereby miss the opportunity for sustainable and local peace.17 Although the local turn functions as an important critique of neoliberal governance and peace, for my research agenda, where the aim is to capture the corporeality and eventness of mundane peace, the discussion and understanding of the everyday offered by local turn scholarship is limited. The everyday implies for me more than the resilience and resistant potential of the ‘local’ and of ‘ordinary people’ in the face of neo-liberal peacebuilding, as it is largely understood within local turn scholarship. From my perspective, the local turn’s interest in the everyday is too narrow, as it has not been translated into a sustained consideration of the productiveness of mundane practices. Where I most radically depart company from local turn scholarship is in its tendency to define the everyday with reference to the subaltern’s spatiality – namely, through the spatial location where the subaltern is assumed to reside and through the forms of everyday life that are thought to characterise her.18 In the local turn, the subaltern and her everyday life are projected to be somewhere ‘out there’: in a distant location of violent political conflict or far-away post-conflict zone. This is, in my view, a traditional Orientalist projection, in which the spatially projected ‘local’ world and its everyday are conceived of as radically different from our own.19 In this projection, the local and the subaltern are constructed as distant ‘others’, whose emancipatory potential the Western and male local turn scholar is concerned with. This is a reminder of the colonial condition, in which white men seek to save ‘brown women from brown men’.20 To avoid this, it is important to recognise that the everyday and the ordinary are constituted through enactments – that is, they are corporeal rather than spatial and not necessarily the ‘subaltern’ in the Orientalist sense, with its implication of non-Western populations. The focus on embodied enactments enables us to retain the local whilst distancing ourselves from the spatial hegemony of the distant ‘other’. Feminist peace and conflict studies As noted earlier, feminist theorising has a strong commitment to corporeality and the everyday (in a non-territorial sense) and therefore functions as a starting point for my agenda. Furthermore, this corpus of thinking establishes a strong connection between corporeal ontology and peace epistemology. Radical feminist scholarship is instrumental, in my view, when investigating the body, the ordinary and the everyday.21 There are multiple ontologies in feminist peace theory, but the concern for marginalization and the understanding of the corporeal and relational nature of human existence are the key contributions that enable a new take on the corporeality of peace.22

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.