Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

It militarizes all of society

Sullivan 18, associate professor in the Department of Public Policy and the Curriculum in Peace, War, and Defense at the University of North Carolina (Patricia, et al, “Arming the Peace: Foreign Security Assistance and Human Rights Conditions in Post-Conflict Countries,” Defence and Peace Economics, doi:10.1080/10242694.2018.1558388)//BB

The second link between security assistance and human rights violations arises out of the ability of the regime to distribute military training, weapons, equipment, and funding as private goods. In states in which civilian control of the military is not solidly institutionalized, support from the military is always essential to regime survival – and the military has incentives to resist any loss of authority or autonomy. Foreign military aid and arms transfers can be used to buy the allegiance of a military elite, ensuring their loyalty in the face of challenges from the wider citizenry (Savage and Caverley 2017, Biddle 2017, Biddle, Macdonald, and Baker 2018). This aid reinforces the privileged position of the military, empowering it relative to other state institutions and giving it an incentive to work with the ruling regime to repress liberalization efforts that are likely to redistribute power and resources away from the military (Savage 2017, Call 2002b). In many war-torn countries, the military exercises control over internal security and is responsible for significant violations of human rights. In these countries, major reforms that would improve human rights conditions after conflict termination are only possible if the military is significantly weakened and their role in internal security is curtailed and brought under civilian control (Call 2002b). But an empowered military is likely to strongly resist any additional accountability, loss of autonomy, or restriction of its internal security role. Donors, for their part, may even encourage the armed forces to retain their role in providing internal security to suppress threats to the donor’s own business or geostrategic interests (e.g. communist insurgents during the Cold War, drug traffickers or terrorist groups more recently) (McClintock 1992, Huggins 1998). As Biddle (2017) warns, security assistance provided to the armed forces in authoritarian countries can encourage transformation of the national military into an abusive praetorian guard – loyal to the regime or a particular sector of the population, rather than an apolitical defender of the state. If foreign security assistance reduces a government’s incentives for investing in public goods, lowers the marginal cost of repression, and strengthens the security sector relative to other government institutions, we should see increased violations of human rights when post-conflict countries receive military aid. The receipt of lethal aid from foreign governments is neither a necessary, nor a sufficient, mechanism for turning post-conflict countries into repressive states. However, all else being equal, the provision of lethal aid will increase the likelihood of a package of policies and choices that will result in human rights violations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.