The crisis in the imagined security of Western life produces the necessary threat of Yellow Life which transcends time and being. Yellow Life is the racialized disease that White society must become immunized to, even as Yellow life reproduces, expands, spreads and spills past the very cells of the Asian body.
Lester 21, Johns Hopkins University, Political Science, Graduate Student, (Quinn, “Bio-orientialism and the Yellow Peril of Yellow Life” Catalyst: Feminism, Theory, Technoscience ; 7(1), https://catalystjournal.org/index.php/catalyst/article/view/34382/27577) //CHC-DS 🐱👤
In this article, I argue that a process of orientalism constructs “Yellow Life“ as the antinomy and horizon of possibility for Western “life” as an unmarked category representing the white possessive individual as a distinct form of life. This process I term bio-orientalism for its emphasis on tropes and images of biological life to mark Yellow Life as forms of nonhuman life threatening to perpetually engulf, invade, and corrupt the West. Bio-orientalism has its origins in nineteenth-century Yellow Peril discourse, yet reappears whenever there is a crisis in the imagined security of Western life that must conjure the threat of Yellow Life as a causal agent of blame obscuring Western life’s own suicidal addiction to global white supremacy and racial capitalism. Bio-orientalism marks moments of crisis in the formation of Western life, from the twentieth-century rise of Japan, through the mid-century “loss of China” and rupture of decolonizations, to the contemporary resurgence of China threatening America’s superpower and civilizational status (Kim 2004; Prashad 2008). For over a century, Western countries conjured Asia as both the premodern that the West has decisively put behind it and the threatening future of an Asia that overwhelms and renders extinct Western life as we have come to know it. Climate-impacted crises like the COVID-19 pandemic increase the stakes and scope of bio-orientalist representations of Asia that create material consequences for Asian Americans and Asian populations globally.
Bio-orientalism plays a key role in the replication of anti-Asian racism over time and therefore calls attention to Asian American political efforts to deconstruct and fight orientalist stereotypes. While Asian American politics often responds to bio-orientalism by seeking inclusion in the unmarked life of white possessive individualism, I speculate upon an Asian Americanist response that abandons the Human for a diversity of ways of living (and life) otherwise (Lowe 1996; Okihiro 2014). My argument then contributes to putting Asian American studies in conversation with developments in the humanities and STS, particularly in understanding the mutual processes of defining and racializing what counts as life itself (Cardozo and Subramaniam 2013; Lee 2014; Huang 2017; Tran 2018). To make this argument, in this article I first define bio-orientalism through an attention to what makes it different from orientalisms that highlight Asia as a technological threat to the future and show how in early Yellow Peril literature images of biological threat predominate. I then turn to Bryan Thao Worra’s poetry collection Demonstra to highlight a different archive in the history of bio-orientalism and how Worra diagnoses bio-orientalism as the potential for embracing Yellow Life as life lived otherwise (Chuh 2003). Particularly, in contrast to Donna Haraway’s famous figure of the cyborg, I focus on Worra’s figure of the Zombuddha that plays with recent turns to depicting the zombie as a particularly Asian threat, revealing the Zombuddha as a unique entanglement of Caribbean history, Western horror, and Laotian cosmology that begins to map other ways of embracing the otherness of Yellow Life.
Defining Bio-orientalism
Arguing that bio-orientalism produces a distinction between Yellow Life and unmarked life already shows that “life“ itself never exists prior to racialization (Lee 2014; Weheliye 2014; Jackson 2015). Often unmarked life or the Human refers to the white liberal subject and the form of life they embody. Scientific and popular discourses take a very particular kind of situated body—often of the white, male, able, Western subject—and treat it as the universal of subjectivity itself. By “life” I also mean the ontology of life upon which such a subject is based; this is life as bounded to bodies, singular and irreducible, and based on a vision of nature as mechanical or inert and open to the active agency of human action (Bennett 2010). C.B. Macpherson (2010) calls this kind of life the possessive individual, whose “possessive quality is found in its conception of the individual as essentially the proprietor of his own person or capacities, owing nothing to society for them” (3). The possessive individual owns himself as property, and engages with other individuals to the degree that they can also be recognized as property owners, something often denied to racialized others. This is also inherently the gendered male body of the patriarch that imagines itself as both inviolable from outside penetration and as one with his property, which can include women, children, slaves, animals, and inanimate objects (Dubber 2005). White racial formation views the life of the possessive individual as one carefully bounded and aloof from the messiness of reality, while also master of all other forms of life (Lipsitz 2006).
This life of the possessive individual fears constantly the violation of his own boundaries through contagion and infection. Following Roberto Esposito's (2008) work on biopolitics, the possessive individual seeks immunity as “a temporary or definitive exemption on the part of the subject with regard to concrete obligations or responsibilities that under normal circumstances would bind one to others” (45). In Esposito's reading, community is the “obligation of reciprocal donation” (50) that threatens “risky contact” with otherness, so that the immunized individual seeks to restore “its own borders that were jeopardized by the common” (50). To speak of the Human, as a white liberal subject, then is to speak of this immunized possessive individual who sees his body as property, and seeks to maintain it as such, while also refusing to live in a common world with life that threatens his body as property. Through the process of bio-orientalism, Yellow Life appears as what threatens to overcome the immunized white life and the form of life against which the possessive individual comes into being. A necessary response to bio-orientalism therefore, I argue, is to dismantle the white possessive individual’s immunized response to otherness and risk exposure to other imagined forms of life.
By emphasizing the ontology of liveliness, bio-orientalism responds to transformations in anti-Asian racism that cannot be reduced to images of Asia as the threat of technological non-life or inhuman labor. Scholarship on Asiatic racial form argues that the figure of the Asian comes into being as a misplaced but concrete representation for the abstract violence of capitalism (Lye 2004; Day 2016). By paying attention to Asiatic racial form’s relationship to capitalism, what often receives the most attention are those representations that paint the Asian body as a form of inhuman technology and labor. Such representations fit under the label of techno-orientalism, which names “the phenomenon of imagining Asia and Asians in hypo- or hypertechnological terms in cultural productions and political discourse” (Roh et al. 2015, 2). Techno-orientalism represents the linking of Asiatic racial form with technology to produce an inhuman non-life overcoming life itself, understood properly as the biologically bounded and autonomous white possessive individual. For STS, techno-orientalism helps draw attention to the ways that technology does not just produce race, but is itself already thoroughly saturated by racial categories and conceptions (Chun 2012; Benjamin 2019). Yet by the very nature of its focus, the examples and cases techno-orientalism highlights overwhelmingly favor the robotic and mechanical, losing sight of life itself as the category under contestation in anti-Asian racism.
Distinct from yet working in tandem with techno-orientalism, which deploys technology to define the Asiatic inhuman, what I term bio-orientalism relies on biological and disease metaphors to characterize Asiatic racial form as nonhuman life, and supplements research on Asiatic racial form by drawing attention to that “bios” of life itself in biopolitics (Esposito 2008; Thacker 2011). Rachel Lee's work on theorizing the biological in Asian American studies provides a jumping off point for thinking through this bios of bio-orientalism. Lee (2014) opens her book The Exquisite Corpse of Asian America with the question of, when Asian American Studies orients itself around discursive and economic determinants of racial formations, why do “Asian American artists, authors, and performers keep scrutinizing their body parts?” (10). She answers the question by dismissing Asian American studies’ anxiety around the apparent “stolidity of the biological” (Lee 2014, 12) and instead focuses on the anxiety of “biological personhood not as fixed or singular but as multiform and distributed across time spans and spatial ecologies” (15). Lee’s project, like other work under the label of new materialism, seeks to recognize that nature and matter are not mechanical or inert, but instead lively and agentic actors in their own right (Bennett 2010; Coole and Frost 2010; Shomura 2017). In recognizing the agency of matter, however, Lee also brings attention to how this matter is not socially blank but already racialized; even to speak of genes or microbes already carries the specter of Asian racialization. She argues then that contemporary racism functions at scales greater and lesser than the individual body, crafting immunized populations of what I call the white possessive individual through the extraction and disposability of racialized others. This form of racism “depends upon the ‘immune’ subject’s mystified property—bounded self-possession—in his/herself and in an array of planetary materials that in actuality remain, biologically speaking, habitats for countless others” (Lee 2014, 223). In disavowing his connection to lively matter, the white possessive individual also expresses the fear of expropriation by, in Esposito's (2008) terms, the munis, by what is both common and other to them. Through bio-orientalism, I argue that Yellow Life comes to stand in for this threat to white immunity, even as to fully imagine the life of the white possessive individual requires expropriation of Yellow Life.
Rather than an attention to the biological being a novel intervention to anti-Asian racism, bio-orientalism highlights how the biological threat of Yellow Life has been a longstanding hallmark of racializing Asia as a threat to white life and white futures. To modify the definition of techno-orientalism, I view bio-orientalism as the phenomenon of imagining Asia and Asians in hypo- or hyperbiological terms in cultural productions and political discourse. In bio-orientalism Asiatic racial form appears as a particular form of life that questions the contours of the possessive individual conception of life itself. Yellow Life seems to always be reproducing itself, expanding, growing—in short, spreading beyond and spilling over what should be the proper boundaries of a life form. As in other forms of orientalism, there is the representation of Asians as a group-collective that denies the possibility of individuation, but here bio-orientalism imagines that collective through vitalist terms, as an aggregate or multiplicity of the barely differentiated whose singular undecidability appears through its constant transformations. In contrast to the problem often tackled within new materialism and STS of recognizing the creative agency of matter, rather than inert and mechanical Asiatic racial form appears as too lively and agentic. Yellow Life becomes impossible to pin down because it refuses to stay within the proper boundaries of life, invading both the tiniest cells of the body and entire nations in its expansive growth. Yellow Life becomes what must be immunized against, the munis that threatens dissolution, the loss of individuality, and death for the white possessive individual (Esposito 2008).