Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Biotechnologies are intertwined with racial disparities, marking Asians as the model minority while marking Blackness as contamination. They unleash the slippery slope to the specter of eugenics.

Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 7: Racial Speculations”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

This is the outcome that may result if the reproductive desires like those of “Want to Be a Dad” are met—that our current state of color-blind ideology is one that may boast of multiculturalism but is still engrained with racist beliefs and desires. At a time when headlines include “The End of White America” (Hsu), perhaps it is not too surprising that the emergence of designer babies and reproductive technologies is a growing trend. In this light, we are currently witnessing the scientific and technological manipulation of the face of race.

I introduce the implications of ART here in order to illustrate how race oftentimes produces a power differentiation between technology and reproduction. In 2013, not only are the rates of nonwhite babies rising,3 but the parallel increase of biracial and multiracial birthrates has fostered an atmosphere of what author Danzy Senna has satirically referred to as the “Mulatto Millennium.” Alongside this change in demographics is our growing reliance on biotechnology through which a parent can now select not only a child’s skin/ hair/eye color but also gender, athletic abilities, weight, height, and susceptibility to certain diseases. In terms of race selection, then, a white couple can have either their genetic white baby (via a white or nonwhite gestational carrier) or a nonwhite baby using an embryo adopted from a domestic or international agency. Despite not sharing any genetic link, a white woman can birth a nonwhite baby and nonwhite women can birth white babies.

Parents-to-be as well as ART practitioners place restrictions upon certain mixings that mirror centuries-old racial paradigms. For example, during her ethnographic research in the San Francisco Bay area, Gillian Goslinga-Roy uncovered racist ideologies where white surrogates refused to gestate a black baby but welcomed an Asian baby. As “Julie,” a white surrogate, explains, “It feels foreign to me. Different. I could carry a Japanese baby or a Chinese baby because they are white to me. Society sees them as white. But a Black child is more difficult. I’m already surrounded by controversy: I married a man thirtytwo years older than me. I work in a late-term, problem-pregnancy abortion facility. And I’m a surrogate. To give birth to a Black child would add one more controversial aspect to my life and I’m not ready to be on the front page of the National Enquirer” (116). Here, gestating blackness is a contamination too taboo to warrant consideration. As Goslinga-Roy points out, what is telling is “how carrying someone else’s (white) child provoked no gut reaction in her whatsoever. . . . But the mere thought of carrying someone else’s Black child immediately made her experience the surrogacy as a very intimate and at once very public violation of her bodily and moral boundaries” (116). In contrast, it is important to point out that gestating a Japanese or Chinese baby is not considered National Enquirer material. In other words, Asian-white mixes have overcome societal prohibition, symptomatic of broader perceptions of Asians as the model minority.

The fear of racial contamination is illustrated throughout the fertility treatment process in what Foucault would call the “biopower” of ART or the “techniques [used] for achieving the subjugations of bodies and the control of populations” (140), such as population control and selective reproduction. By managing and manipulating racial mixings, ART practitioners become arbiters of heredity and the future look of race. In her study of fertility technology, Seline Szkupinski Quiroga reveals how racial borders are policed and maintained during each step of the fertility treatment process. For example, in describing the matching process between sperm donor and recipient, she writes, “The goal of matching is threefold: (1) to increase the probability that the child’s physical characteristics will be similar enough to suggest that the social parent could have contributed his own genetic material; (2) to mimic the physical attributes of what white Americans perceive as a biological family; and (3) to maintain secrecy about the use of a donor by ensuring that the child could ‘pass’ as a genetic child and not be mistaken as a product of the mother’s sexual infidelity” (150). Szkupinski Quiroga explains that while the first two goals are reflective of biologism or the need to “look” like a natural family, the last goal reflects the “raced and gendered nature of the heteropatriarchal family model” (150). In other words, the child cannot be interpreted as the visual evidence of the mother’s infidelity. Here, the child’s racial visibility/ decipherability is the physical evidence of his/her mother’s loyalty not only to her husband but to the family’s genetics via the erasure of (her) infertility.4 In the ART process, the mother’s infidelity is achieved only hypothetically via a mixed-race sexual union. In order to prevent this, donor semen is “categorized racially, and sperm banks rely on donor self-identification and physiognomy to assess the validity of a donor’s claim to whiteness” (150). Oftentimes, sperm vials are, in fact, color-coded to match the donor’s racial identification (black/ brown caps for African Americans, yellow caps for Asians, white caps for Caucasians, and red caps for those with “unique ancestry” such as East Indians, American Indians, Latinos, and mixed race individuals). Sperm banks play race managers through careful cataloguing of various physical characteristics in order to choose the “appropriate” donor. This catalogue serves “as a proxy for proof of a donor’s racial pedigree” (150).

In contrast to the racist taboos and anxieties that black bodies, blood, and genes still signify in ART, it is interesting to note that Asian genetics and bodies are in high demand in both ART and adoption. With all factors being equal (health of infant, age, the adoption budget, the type of agency employed, etc.), white babies demand higher costs and longer wait periods in domestic adoption because they are the most desired. In contrast, black or multiracial babies are the least in demand, thus the cost and waiting period for them are considerably lower, especially if one adopts via the foster care program. One adoption agency, Wide Horizons for Children, states on their website that “[f ]amilies are especially needed for children of African American heritage and children who may have a health risk or concern.” Here, blackness and disease and/or disability are on par. On the contrary, Asian adoptions compose about 60 percent of all international adoptions according to the Department of Health and Human Services. Domestically, Asian American adoption composes such a small number that reliable estimates could not be generated; this disparity may be explained by the fact that very few Asian American babies are placed in adoptions due to cultural or religious taboos. Interestingly, however, Asian eggs are a hot commodity and demand as much as two or three times the price of other eggs (and, as noted in a recent Los Angeles Times article, up to a hundred thousand dollars). “asian egg donors needed” signs can be found all over Ivy League college campuses, for if the donor boasts an Ivy League pedigree with high SAT scores, she can command a higher price. Demand is so high that some egg donor agencies, such as the Asian Egg Donor Agency in New Jersey, specialize in Asian eggs. As Stanford bioethics professor David Magnus writes, “What we have is the beginnings of the specter of eugenics . . . the makings of a super-race and a slippery slope. What we have is an actual egg selling, not egg donation” (“Eggs from Young Asian Women in High Demand”).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.