Western imaginations produce an Asiatic figure that is not only racialized, but gendered. The technological bounds between Being and Thing produce exclusionary binaries where Asiatic femininity is subjected to the ornament of Western fantasy. Only reimagining subject-object ontology can create space for the Asian woman’s cybernetic ontological entanglement.
Lu 21, Vanderbilt University, (Melanie, “Gendering the Techno-Orient: The Asian Woman in Speculative Fiction”, English & Asian Studies Honors Thesis, https://ir.vanderbilt.edu/bitstream/handle/1803/16493/LuMelanie_VUIRSubmission.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y) //CHC-DS 🐱👤
According to Cheng, fully understanding the unique nature of western constructions of Asiatic femininity demands a radical reconfiguration of the binaries between personhood and thingness. She offers the term Ornamentalism as a critical lens to examine the relations between objectification, aestheticization, and racialization in articulating a distinct ontology of and for the Asian woman: contrary to autonomous modes of being that arise from natural bodies, the racialization of the Asian woman involves “a process whereby personhood is conceived and suggested (legally, materially, and imaginatively) through ornamental gestures [...] that speak through the minute, the sartorial, the prosthetic, and the decorative” (Cheng 429). The western concept of the Person—which Cheng traces to Enlightenment thinkers such as John Locke and William Blackstone—and its idealization of the organic and integral body as designed by God is thus radically challenged, since the demarcations between personhood and objecthood are violently collapsed in the process (Cheng 436). It is not (yellow) flesh that constitutes a racialized body, but ornament. There is no Person, in the natural, embodied sense, to begin with, and one must imagine an alternative ontology for a being that exists in a realm of thingness.
For the Asian woman who is constructed this way, it is not the case that she is transformed into object, that is, objectified, but rather that she already exists as object; flesh and ornament amalgamate in representations of this racialized figure. To make her case, Cheng draws on a range of texts from Euro-American visual and literary culture, while focusing heavily on the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s dazzling 2015 exhibition entitled China: Through the Looking Glass. Indeed, the latter case, which featured more than 140 examples of haute couture and avant-garde wear from renowned western designers such as Yves Saint Laurent and John Galliano, was notable as it epitomizes precisely the kind of lavish ornamental stylization typically used to characterize Asian aesthetics. Looking at the clothing for female models that are supposedly inspired by “a pastiche of Chinese aesthetic and cultural traditions,” one senses a recurring conflation between materiality and organicity (“Exhibition Overview”). As highlighted by Cheng, flesh and ornament are often synonymous in these sumptuous pieces, as porcelain shards are laced into bodices and calligraphy script becomes sartorial prints. Through the exotic vessel of Chineseness and Asiatic femininity, the material ambiguity of the garments effectively racializes the Asian woman as a being that is defined by the ornamental. If this ontological formulation of the Asian woman as object is true, we come to further realize how noteworthy it is that the artificiality of Kyoko is signified in such a way as to contrast the humanness of Ava; the objecthood of her being as yellow woman overlaps with and extends the narrative of the Asian alien as human simulacra, culminating in her racialized figure as uncannily human-like but nonetheless inherently devoid of organic life.
Cheng’s theory of Ornamentalism is useful and highly relevant to our discussion for multiple reasons. In addition to examining the intersections between gender and race in Orientalizing the Asian woman, it highlights the importance of aesthetic style in the formal construction of racial narratives, thereby effectively refuting attempts such as those in Ex Machina to trivialize the role of racial signifiers in seemingly apolitical or post-racial contexts. The aforementioned exhibition, for instance, reclaims “postmodernism as a cure to Orientalism” by suggesting that the artistic value of the displayed pieces should be disaggregated from politics (Cheng 427). Such rhetoric is abundant in the museum’s gallery webpages, where China is designated as a “land of free-floating symbols” that invites postmodern reinterpretation and reconstruction (“Exhibition Galleries”). Indeed, even the exhibition title’s use of the notion of “looking glass,” repeatedly referenced elsewhere as the collection’s unifying theme, suggests an exculpatory self-awareness of the distorting effects of the western gaze. Under the guise of artistic creativity, the exhibition thus attempts to completely shed the burden of cultural authenticity by asserting that aesthetic style is innocuous and distinct from broader cultural or political narratives that more explicitly reflect ideologies of race.
China: Through the Looking Glass is not alone in exemplifying such Orientalist practices; thus, while Said’s critique of western portrayals of a decadent Asia as Other remains valid, it does not as adequately emphasize the specific processes by which such aesthetic style itself is a gendered mechanism of racialization. Under the framework of Ornamentalism, we are not only able to recognize the gendered nature of the ethnic-cultural fetishization reflected by these garments, but to also understand why the west is persistently driven to denote Asia and Asiatic femininity with particular ornamental styles we see among this “land of free-floating symbols.” This enduring figure of the faceless female mannequin, always garnished with breathtakingly extravagant fabrics, textures, and appendages found throughout the collection, thus signifies for the western imagination a particular kind of person of desire. Instead of arbitrarily curating a pastiche of signs for aesthetic pleasure, the west has constructed a specific constellation of traits that racialize a being that is already characterized as an object. Looking back to our survey on the typology of western techno-Orientalist texts, we further see how this narrative of aesthetic style as seemingly raceless is similarly at play, as the mystifying Chinese character signboards typical in various SF settings are not inconsequential backgrounds but instead constitute a particular style that is inherently Orientalizing, even as these texts aim to prophesize a future that is less concerned with race than the fundamental biologies of human and machine.
Ultimately, Ornamentalism also presents a unique avenue to examine the figure of the cyborg as it encapsulates the challenges of (re)defining subjectivity within the techno-Orientalist narrative. Looking at the exhibition pieces on display in Looking Glass, which were assembled in juxtaposition to physical artifacts such as ceramics and paintings while using the same patterns on these objects for their design, we not only get the sense that they are meant to enact a particular mechanism of racialization for the Asian woman, but also that they subvert the notions of objecthood itself. Cheng suggests that what is ultimately at play is a foregrounding of the object’s primacy that is only made legible through the racial significations of the ornamental Asian woman (Cheng 435). This unique ontological entanglement with objecthood is significant in questioning subject-object relations not only as they pertain to perceptions of female Asian bodies, but also to the viewer’s own understanding of their human condition, as Ornamentalism facilitates the recognition that objecthood is part of being human. As Cheng explains eloquently, “while Orientalism is about turning persons into things that can be possessed and dominated, ornamentalism is about a fantasy of turning things into persons through the conduit of racial meaning in order, paradoxically, to allow us to abandon our humanness” (Cheng 435). Thus, as a concept, Ornamentalism spotlights the crisis of modern life that Asiatic femininity personifies, where it seems increasingly difficult to reconcile ideals of the purely organic body with visions of a technology-driven future. More broadly, Ornamentalism challenges the long-standing western traditions that view the object as a subordinate byproduct of the natural subject within the subject-object dichotomy, prompting us to radically reimagine more diverse modes of personhood and being.
We now see how Ornamentalism as an extension of Saidian Orientalism has immense potential in initiating conversations on alternative forms of being that challenge the categories of human and artificial, especially those pertaining to cyberspace and cyborg bodies. If the Asian woman has always been a product of the synthetic, then she is in a sense “the original cyborg,” compelling us to rethink the desires and anxieties surrounding materiality and artificiality (Cheng 433). In Donna Haraway’s 1985 Cyborg Manifesto, the notion of the cyborg—an abstract fusion between machine and organic matter—offers a utopian promise of a postmodern, genderless world that rejects essentialist and naturalist identity politics rooted in western heteropatriarchy (Haraway 7). The limitations of Haraway’s cyborg become especially clear now as we consider the figure of the Asian woman, who needs no bodily enhancement or modification to deprive her of organicity. Her cybernetic genealogy as traced through the western imagination predates what Haraway sees as technologically-aided liberation in the late twentieth century, since she has always existed ambiguously along the boundaries of Person and thing. She is thus crucial to understanding the expressions of modern personhood and life, where ideals of the natural, integrated individual are threatened not only by the potential fusion between technology, ornament, and flesh, but also by the emerging desires we hold towards confronting our own humanness as modern subjects.