Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Asian body becomes locked in the uncanny valley, marked as simultaneously human and racially subhuman. Yellow life in the US is not natural, but an invasive parody of White liveliness.

Shi 21, University of Pennsylvania, (Vicki, “WHERE IS THE ASIAN BODY? THE PROBLEM OF ERASURE IN WESTERN VISUAL CULTURE”, Thesis in Visual Studies, https://cpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/web.sas.upenn.edu/dist/6/736/files/2021/05/Shi_Vicky_Thesis.pdf) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In 1970, Japanese scientist Masahiro Mori published an article on what he coined the “uncanny valley,” or his theory of human reactions to objects that are humanistic. On the graph, the y-axis represents human affinity while the y-axis represents the degree of realistic portrayal. Mori explains that as things go further along the x-axis, people start feeling a negative affinity to those objects. For example, a toy robot will vaguely represent a human, but is not frightening because they are not made to look realistic. The toy robot retains features that make it undeniably inhuman. However, something like a prosthetic hand or a corpse may bring about a feeling of unease to a healthy human being, since they resemble something human but are not, or no longer, human. This reaction is represented by the deep plunge at the bottom of the graph, where the curve goes south in measurements of human affinity.7 Mori’s uncanny valley is often used in android design in an autonomous future to describe the unease that occurs when looking at objects that mimic humanity. The response is perhaps even instinctual as androids are a clear example of what could replace humans altogether. It is only natural for people to ostracize that which can destroy them; therefore, the crux of the uncanny valley lies in the innate fear of human mortality.8 In this vein of thought, the uncanny valley can also be applied through a racial context in Western societies, especially in Europe and the United States. Revealed on a microscopic level, “research on immigrant students of color reveals that students undergo a process of racialization as they are incorporated into the existing racial hierarchy of the United States—one that places White people at the top and defines them as the only true Americans.”9 Furthermore, “participants in both of our studies internalized these notions of Americanness, evidenced strongly in their reserving the term ‘American’ to refer to White people, while using ethnically or racially specific language to identify themselves or other people of color.”10 When enlarged to a national scale and enforced by systematic ostracization, compared to the white majority or “true Americans,” the racial Other seems to invade the United States or exists in it unnaturally in the eyes of both parties. Since these “Others” do not resemble the white majority, their existence becomes a parody of white livelihood and their humanity comes into question.

This racial division in the U.S. is further perpetrated by the stereotypes and biases the white majority forces on these Others. By creating these exaggerations, the white majority can control how the racial Other is portrayed. These caricatures are the start of the systematic dehumanization, with different archetypes assigned to different racial group. With East Asians, alienation peaked with the spread of the Yellow Peril ideology. Throughout the late 19th and the early 20th century, mass immigration brought an increase of Asian population in the United States as a direct result of Western military and imperialistic influences on Asia. However, this influx brought fear that these so-called “foreigners” would disrupt or potentially overtake the white majority. As a response, British author Sax Rohmer created Fu Manchu, a crafty Chinese mastermind plotting to overthrow the white, Eurocentric world, at the height of the Yellow Peril. While Fu Manchu himself represented the white man’s fear of the Chinese invasion, his army of minions that carried out his orders had traits that paralleled with what people believed of the Chinese laborers at that time. They were seen as “‘instruments’—that is, as ‘exploitable, containable, and inhuman,’ and as ‘the perfect ‘laboring machine[s]’—a swarm of mindless coolies who could be easily ‘programmed.’”11 The Chinese were seen as unintelligent and robotic; they were “beings that appear human and behave in human-like ways, but that are really subhuman on the ‘inside.’”12 Yet the white man still feels anxiety in regards to the Chinese because they are a “contradiction between [the] thing's appearance and the essence that one has attributed to it.”13 To the white man, the Chinaman is “felt to be both human and subhuman— and therefore as an uncanny entity”14 because he is simultaneously both Fu Manchu and his faceless, mechanical minions.

Needless to say, Fu Manchu did not only represent the Chinese, but the looming threat of the East and Asian bodies to white society. Unsurprisingly, the character of Fu Manchu has always been represented onscreen by a white man in costume; even his description in Rhomer’s books contained Anglo-Saxon features such as “[a] brow like Shakespeare” and “shimmering green irises.”15 As the embodiment of the Yellow Peril, Rhomer created the Chinese mastermind with intelligence and agency; to the white majority, these traits cannot be separated from whiteness as evident in the appearance of Fu Manchu as they are understood as human traits. Therefore, by imposing Asian features on a white man while trying to maintain that the danger he embodies in fact resides in the East, Rhomer created a truly uncanny and inhuman monster as it forces his audience to think about racial implications.16 If Fu Manchu is an intelligent mastermind, then he must be white. But his role of representing the Yellow Peril categorizes him as a racial Other. The racial contradiction of Fu Manchu reflects the unease of white audience as they are confronted with the possibility of humanity residing in the racial Other. One of the solutions to ameliorate this anxiety is not only by marking the Asian body as uncanny but destroying the Asian body altogether.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.