Centering debates on the Asian American subjectivity breaks new imaginative grounds that are illegible in the US national discourse that systematically excludes the Asian identity.
Song 12, University of California Riverside, (Mary, Cyborg Dreams in Asian American Transnationality: Transgression, Myth, Simulation, Coalition, University of California Riverside, https://escholarship.org/uc/item/53d2x7nd) //CHC-DS 🐱👤
In Imagine Otherwise, Kandice Chuh recognizes the critical cogency for Asian American studies to consider postmodern insights about the limitations of representation: “Asian American studies may be seen as a formation of the critical landscape configured by a (poststructural) problematization of referentiality, which facilitates the (postmodern) jettisoning of the authority of the meta-narrative.” (Chuh 5)2 However, not only does Chuh suggest a need for a critical postmodern lens, she asserts that Asian American subjectivity is a particularly productive space to explore evolving notions of referentiality and multiplicity. She observes how Asian American subjects are racially-marked bodies that exceed the nation-state circumscriptions of the abstracted citizen through their ability to traverse boundaries both geographical and ideological:
I suggest that it is precisely because U.S. nationalism has constituted “Asian America” as a transnational identity that it has power as an analytic in exposing the failures of the U.S. nation-state’s promises of universal equality. …. In this manner, transnationalism might be seen as a discourse that advances investigations of the technologies of race and U.S. national identity formation, or perhaps more pointedly, the technology of race as a technology of U.S. national identity. (Chuh 60-1)
Using transnationality as a physical and a metaphysical term, Chuh is careful to clarify that the Asian American transnational paradigm refers not only to the material “crossborder flows of people, capital and cultures” (Chuh 62), but also the “border crossings without literal movement” (ibid) that break new imaginative grounds towards “political and cultural practices illegible in the official discourse of the U.S. nation-state.” (ibid) In this way, Chuh calls for the crucial task to examine as yet unexamined postmodern permutations of hegemonic technologies that work to contain and oppress Asiatically-marked bodies.
In Immigrant Acts, Lisa Lowe applies a materialist critique in her examination of how U.S. nation-state technologies of citizenship based on the abstract liberal subject is predicated on the ideologically paradoxical foundations of national exclusion and material exploitation of the transnational Asian immigrant. Lowe emphasizes the political exigency for Asian American scholars to critically engage in the historical and sociological contradictions that simultaneously disenfranchise the Asian American subject and substantiate the abstract U.S. citizen. Focusing on the material conditions that have systemically excluded Asiatically-marked bodies from national subjecthood, Lowe locates political resistance in the very prefiguration of this racializing technology that constitutes U.S. citizenship:
As the state legally transforms the Asian alien into the Asian American citizen, it institutionalizes the disavowal of the history of racialized labor exploitation and disenfranchisement through the promise of freedom in the political sphere. Yet the historical and continued racialization of the Asian American, as citizen, exacerbates [my emphasis] the contradictions of the national project that promises the resolution of material inequalities through the political domain of equal representation. (Lowe 10)
Lowe elucidates a political potentiality in recognizing Asian American transnationality in that the racialization of Asian American subjects highlights the hypocrisy and racism of the U.S. democratic rhetoric of freedom and equality. Furthermore, Lowe reveals how the ideological sustains the material conditions that perpetuate political inequity for Asian Americans.