Racial discrimination has seeped into the incorporeal – only by blurring the lines between the virtual and the material can we adapt to and disrupt our representations.
Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 10: Thinking about Bodies, Souls, and Race in Gibson’s Bridge Trilogy”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱👤
In the 1990s both popular culture and academic theorists promised freedom from the constraints of race, gender, sexual preference, and class via the Internet. This optimism was short-lived: in the twenty-first century, we know that bodies matter and that narratives about virtual disembodiment or equality often depend upon the very racial or gendered stereotypes that they purport to be eradicating.3 Technoculture studies scholar Lisa Nakamura sets up a key question about race and the Internet: “Can the Internet propagate genuinely new and nonracist (and nonsexist and nonclassist) ways of being,” or is “online discourse . . . woven of stereotypical cultural narratives that reinstall [the] conditions of gender, race, and class as conditions of social interaction?” (Digitizing Race xii). Gibson’s Bridge trilogy investigates this very problem, ultimately demonstrating that discourses of race, gender, and class are reliant on the binary opposition between physical and virtual, as well as interiority and exteriority. Gibson destabilizes these easy binary distinctions through the creation of an alternative space, Walled City, and a character, Rei Toei, who is both real and virtual.
In the future universe of Gibson’s trilogy, the Internet has become as highly regulated and policed as actual physical spaces. In reaction to this, radicals create a digital city located outside of the restrictions of the mainstream Internet: Walled City has “no laws . . . just agreements,” and therefore houses an eclectic population who have founded a new space outside of, and resistant to, the dominant digital culture (Idoru 209). As Masahiko puts it, it is “of the Net, but not on it.” Gibson’s “Walled City” much resembles the “City of Bits” described by the late William J. Mitchell, who was dean of the school of architecture at MIT and a prescient urban and media theorist: “This will be a city unrooted to any definite spot on the surface of the earth, shaped by connectivity and bandwidth constraints rather than by accessibility and land values, largely asynchronous in its operation, and inhabited by disembodied and fragmented subjects who exist as collections of aliases and agents. Its places will be constructed virtually by software instead of physically from stones and timbers, and they will be connected by logical linkages rather than by doors, passageways, and streets” (William J. Mitchell 24).4 The emphasis on virtual “logical linkages” over physical barriers like “doors and passageways” suggests that the virtual city does not share the same social inequities that are represented by the architectural enclosures of material cities, meant to keep locals in and invaders out. At the same time, it would be inaccurate to maintain that Gibson’s Walled City is “unrooted to any definite spot . . . on earth” because we learn that Walled City is a reproduction of the real city of Kowloon (also known as Kowloon Walled City). A largely ungoverned settlement in Hong Kong, when it was a British colony, Kowloon functioned as an autonomous zone that had been without laws or police because of a mistake in the possession agreement with China. As described in Gibson’s novel Idoru, it was a tiny space but extremely densely populated, which housed “drugs and whores and gambling. But people living, too. Factories, restaurants. A city. No laws” (221).
Gibson’s allusion to the historical Kowloon Walled City goes beyond merely exoticizing the city for its criminality and otherness. Rather, I argue that the historical allusion grounds Gibson’s virtual Walled City in real, inhabited space, thus disrupting the taken for granted binary between digital and physical spaces. This linking together of virtual and material space continues in the first lengthy description of the city:
Something at the core of things moved simultaneously in mutually impossible directions. It wasn’t even like porting. Software conflict? Faint impression of light through a fluttering of rags. And then the thing before her: building or biomass or cliff face looming there, in countless unplanned strata, nothing about it even or regular. Accreted patchwork of shallow random balconies, thousands of small windows throwing back blank silver rectangles of fog. Stretching to the periphery of vision, and on the high, uneven crest of that ragged façade, a black fur of twisted pipe, antennas sagging under vine growth of cable. And past this scribbled border a sky where colors crawled like gasoline on water. Hak Nam . . . City of Darkness. Between the walls of the world. (Idoru 195)
Most salient in this passage about Gibson’s Walled City are the architectural structures that abound—buildings, balconies, windows, and façades. Even though these appear as man-made structures, Gibson weaves natural or organic imagery into their descriptions: Chia, the young protagonist of Gibson’s second text of the trilogy, can’t tell if what she first sees is a “building” or “cliff face,” windows become “silver rectangles of fog,” pipes are described as “black fur,” cables are dense as “vine growth,” and the sky is a combination of gasoline and water. Similarly, diction such as “countless unplanned strata, nothing about it even or regular,” “accreted patchwork,” “uneven crest of that ragged façade,” and “scribbled border” repeat the notion of improvisation over orderliness. This blurring of boundaries between natural and artificial, material and virtual is what composes this ideal city of Gibson’s. It is a different virtual experience from the cyberspace of Neuromancer, with its abstract, jewel-colored geometric forms and its clean dualism of “meat” and virtuality. Bodies and the spaces they inhabit—Laney’s deteriorating body in Cardboard City; Zona’s disabled, brown body in Mexico; Masahiko’s unconscious body sprawled in a love hotel in Tokyo—simply can’t be obscured under the Internet’s optimistic rhetoric of universal freedom and the disappearance of space and distance. The ideal city must combine the material and the virtual; it must use the new digital order to restructure and reconfigure our inhabited spaces.
There is a long philosophical tradition of theorizing the virtual in a way that suggests that the virtual is consistently tied to the real. I will briefly survey some of the dominant critical approaches here, before turning specifically to Brian Massumi’s theoretical model that links new modes of bodily sensation to virtual experience—of particular importance to our discussion of digital technologies, race, and embodiment. In Matter and Memory, Henri Bergson aligns the virtual with memories and dreams: “Whenever we are trying to recover a recollection, to call up some period of our history, we become conscious of an act sui generis by which we detach ourselves from the present in order to replace ourselves, first, in the past in general, then in a certain region of the past—a work of adjustment, something like the focusing of a camera. But our recollection still remains virtual” (143). For Bergson, the virtual (dreams, memories, imaginations, pure qualities) is real insofar as it has an effect on us; in other words, the virtual insists on the real. It is not accidental that Bergson uses the analogy of a technological apparatus—the “focusing of a camera”—to ground his notion of the virtual in material reality. Building on Bergson’s ideas, Gilles Deleuze writes that both the actual and the virtual are real, but not everything that is virtual is or becomes actual. Similarly, science philosopher Pierre Levy maintains: “The virtual is that which has potential rather than actual existence. The virtual tends toward actualization. . . . The tree is virtually present in the seed” (23).
Political philosopher and social theorist Brian Massumi describes the virtual as being akin to unused, potential energy. As he puts it, “One way of starting to get a grasp on the real-material-but-incorporeal is to say it is to the body, as a positioned thing, as energy is to matter. Energy and matter are mutually convertible modes of the same reality. This would make the incorporeal something like a phase-shift of the body in the usual sense, but not one that comes after it in time. It would be a conversion or unfolding of the body contemporary to its every move. Always accompanying. Fellow-traveling dimension of the same reality” (5). Most helpful about Massumi’s theory is the manner in which he describes the virtual in relation to the body’s sense of affect and sensation. Rather than existing as abstract information, for Massumi, the virtual consists of processes that operate on multiple registers of sensation. He sums this phenomenon up as the “‘real but abstract’ incorporeality of the body” (21).
Massumi’s notion of the virtual sensations of the body finds an illustrative example in Gibson’s Idoru. Returning again to the passage that details Chia McKenzie’s first experience of virtual Walled City, we encounter multiple references to movement and affect in cyberspace: “They were inside now, smoothly accelerating, and the squirming density of the thing was continual visual impact, an optical drumming. . . . A sharp turn. Another. Then they were ascending a maze of twisting stairwells, still accelerating, and Chia took a deep breath and closed her eyes. Retinal fireworks bursting there, but the pressure was gone” (195–196). The primary sensory quality evident in this passage is that of sight or vision. On the surface, this dominance of vision aligns with our typical experience of interacting with the computer or laptop: viewing a virtual two-dimensional image (or sometimes three-dimensional, as Internet connectivity and bandwidth constraints evolve) on a screen and pointing and clicking simultaneously with one’s fingers on an electronic mouse. However, Gibson’s depiction of Walled City exceeds these purely physical, bodily sensations. The visual sensation described occurs on another register beyond merely seeing, given the diction of “impact,” “drumming,” and “fireworks bursting” in conjunction with the eyes. In terms of the tactile, we are informed of Chia’s experience of a “squirming density” and “pressure” that appears alien and estranging to our regular body’s resistance against gravity. The pressure and density that Chia experiences most likely come in conjunction with the intense speeds at which she is traveling in cyberspace. Gibson’s portrayal of her movement in the cyber plane mostly resembles flight, particularly in conjunction with the pressure that Chia describes (g-force, per chance?). The way that Chia is able to navigate her virtual body with sharp turns and accelerations around Walled City’s immaterial architecture, its labyrinth of stairwells and buildings, constitutes an affective experience that exceed the regular sensations perceived by the body’s sensory organs; Chia’s online venture into Walled City can be accurately described only as sensations of Massumi’s “real-material-but-incorporeal” body. Chia’s navigation of her virtual urban space becomes an experience that augments, supplements, and cross-hatches her material urban inhabited space.
In creating an alternate space that straddles the incorporeal and the material, Gibson is perhaps offering us his vision of “genuinely new and nonracist (and nonsexist and nonclassist) ways of being” (to borrow Nakamura’s earlier phrasing). It is a virtual experience that does not negate the physical. Put another way, Thomas Foster reminds us that discourses of race have long been constructed within realms of the virtual and incorporeal, even before the advent of digital technologies. He points out “there is a specific racial history of the expropriability of the ‘soul’” (xxiii) and that “white power to represent blackness . . . takes the form of ‘miscegenated texts,’ in which AfricanAmericans figure as black bodies with white souls, that is, with an interiority comprehensible to white readers” (xxiii). Given this history, we might conclude that discourses of race have been reliant on the binary opposition between incorporeal and material, as well as interiority and exteriority. Gibson’s Idoru, Rei Toei, proves to be a thought experiment that challenges and disrupts such oppositions.
Gibson’s Idoru: Cybertype or Multicultural Cyborg?
Rei Toei, the idoru or idol singer of the second text of Gibson’s trilogy, is a world-famous pop star, an ideal beauty, an icon of sexual desire, and an artificially created avatar that disrupts the boundary between the completely virtual and the completely real. We are told she is “a personality-construct, a congeries of software agents, the creation of information-designers” (55). Rei is basically an exotic, virtual pinup girl, her immateriality inspiring physical male lust. When she first appears before Rydell—a rent-a-cop who appears in all three books of the trilogy—she is first naked, and then seen wearing clothes identical to his own. The detail of mirroring Rydell’s clothing suggests that Rei has no subjectivity of her own, but is only a reflection of Rydell’s masculine, Western desire. Her digital perfection creates an unrealistic ideal of beauty, which is most likely Gibson’s commentary on media stardom with the fan club that chases Rei and her “lover” Rez in Idoru.5
Eventually, however, the idoru evolves beyond this simulation of exotic Asian feminine beauty. At the end of All Tomorrow’s Parties, multiple physical Rei Toeis emerge from nanofax assemblers (a device utilizing nanotechnology to replicate items in various locations) across the world, a far cry from her original form as ephemeral hologram. In a fateful twist of irony, the nanofax assemblers are stationed at Lucky Dragon franchises. The stores, stereotypes of impersonal Asian global commodity culture, and their nanotechnology are subversively reappropriated by Rei. Rather than the goal of virtual disembodiment and “jacking in” to cyberspace that characterized Gibson’s earlier Sprawl novels, the idoru achieves the opposite objective of moving away from her original status as digital code toward literal corporeality and physical embodiment. We are told that she becomes “an emergent system, a self continually being iterated from experiential input . . . that river in to which one can never step twice. As she became more herself, through the inputting of experience, through human interaction, she grew and changed” (163). Rei Toei herself comments, “I’m so much more . . . I could go anywhere.” Here, while the idoru does not move entirely from being the sexual object of the male gaze (the multiple Reis emerge naked from the assemblers), Rei does appear to emerge as sentient subject, capable of independent thought and mobility. Her nakedness, in contrast to her earlier propensity to reflect others’ clothing appearances, may suggest a rebirth of sorts, in which Rei is now a blank slate ready to learn and acclimate to her external environment according to her own choices and will. The multiple Reis, however, also work to destabilize the notion of independent subjectivity and free will: we are left wondering which is the true Rei, or if there never was a true originary Rei in the first place since she was artificially constructed as a virtual, hologram idol.
The idoru shifts from object to subject, along with the resultant potential destabilizing of such subjectivity. As mere software, code, and programmed sexual desire at her inception, Rei Toei literally cements the notion of the Orient as an object devoid of subjectivity. Later, as she emerges naked from every Lucky Dragon nanofax kiosk on earth, the exoticized desire that she inspires has an uneasy and anxious merger with her status as autonomous subject. The bystanders watch her materialize from the assemblers first on television screens (every Lucky Dragon franchise has television displays of video surveillance of other Lucky Dragon franchises, all across the world), and then turn in shock to see Rei, not in the digitally mediated form of the TV screen, but directly before them in the flesh. This part in the narrative has a surprising effect of breaking the fourth wall for the reader of Gibson’s text as well: we, like the bystanders outside of the Lucky Dragon, are accessing Rei virtually (albeit in literary form), but the multiple Reis that pop out all over the world suggest that she can turn up anywhere, pushing the reader to not grow too comfortable with passively and pleasurably absorbing Rei and her story.
In challenging assumed notions regarding virtuality/reality, interiority/ exteriority, and subjectivity/objectification, Gibson’s Bridge trilogy destabilizes certain binary oppositions and preconceptions that consistently undergird techno-Orientalist stereotypes and narratives about Asian peoples and places. His texts demonstrate that techno-Orientalist discourses depend upon these oversimplified and neat binarisms. For instance, Gibson’s earlier Sprawl trilogy was contingent upon oppositions between “meat” and cyberspace, while the Bridge trilogy challenges us to think about the slippage and permeable boundaries between the virtual and the real. Such speculation allows for heterotopias like Gibson’s Walled City, where new modes of bodily sensation are introduced, and perhaps if we speculate further, new modes of thinking about racial embodiment beyond fantasies of Western penetration of the East. This is not to say that there is a symmetry between Western projections of the East and Eastern imaginings of the West; the West’s technoOrientalist representations of the East are quite powerful and pervasive. While it is important to critique representations of virtual Orientalism, I argue that such critiques are incomplete if they do not move beyond the unidirectional gaze that the West focuses on the East. We can do such work by examining the potential for dynamic crosscurrents or transactions that move in both directions (for instance, the East’s projections of the West, or even of itself ), and by examining the potential for techno-Orientalist discourse to adapt and disrupt its own stereotypes and representations.