Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Rational political speculations produce cruel optimism, where progress narratives create empty promises that maximize productivity while leaving real people on the margins. Instead, we turn to the anomalies of discourse, where our strange futurity opens the aperture beyond frameworks of the knowable to open space for survivability.

Bahng 17, Aimee Bahng is an American academic. She is a professor of gender and women's studies at Pomona College in Claremont, California. Her previous denial of tenure at Dartmouth College sparked widespread protests about discrimination against racial minorities in academia., (Aimee, “Epilogue: Speculation as Discourse, Speculation as Exuberance” in Migrant Futures: Decolonizing Speculation in Financial Times, Duke University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

In an essay titled “The Rhetoric of Sex / The Discourse of Desire,” Samuel Delany examines one possible etymology for “discourse” that stems from the Latin word for an ancient Roman oval racetrack, where spectators stood on the inside of the track, while the runners raced around the encircled spectators. These Roman discourses, Delany notes, “were places of much betting . . . , the touting up of odds, and the endless speculative conversation on the merits of the racers characteristic today of horseracing tracks were a part of daily life at the discourse.”1 Building on Michel Foucault’s theorizations of discourse in Archaeology of Knowledge, Delany understands discourse as a structuring mechanism that not only “tells us what is central and what is peripheral,” but that also controls the entry and exit points of that facility.

Delany identifies the Roman discourse as an archaeology of knowledge that is simultaneously a primal scene for speculation. Discourse in this example presents itself as a mostly closed system that facilitates gambling by providing the conditions of manageable uncertainty without throwing itself over to chaos. The runners ostensibly never leave the track. What would happen, though, if they did? Like Foucault, Delany takes more interest in the multiplicity of discourses, discursive practices, and their relationships to the anomaly—that which falls beyond the purview of the discourse. For him, paying attention to the “anomalous and nonserious” discards of discourse reveals the exclusionary structuring mechanisms of the discourse itself.2 Delany moves through these thoughts on discourse to arrive at his perhaps better known set of formulations on paraliterature, which includes speculative fiction and all sorts of other “anomalous and nonserious” forms of writing. And as Delany points out, “‘anomalous and nonserious’ is how the accomplishments of women, whether in the arts or in the world, were judged. And the writings of blacks in this country were, until very recently, considered even more of an accident.”

“By our strangeness, we write our bodies into the future,” Miranda says.3 She’s talking about genetic mutation, but Larissa Lai also invokes queer and migrant futurity. These are the anomalous futures that have run amok from the discourse of speculation. Migrant Futures has been a study of speculation not so much as a genre, but rather as a discursive practice. Migrant futures are epistemological anomalies. They are science fictions less interested in getting the science right than in interrogating the systems that produced that science.

Speculation becomes a colonizing mechanism when it attempts to capture, profit from, and realize the future. Predictions, premeditations, precautions, preparedness—these are all signposts of a speculative science working to colonize the future. This book has located several arenas in which speculation has met up with these imperialist logics: the financial derivatives market, military securitization, transnational surrogacy insurance, global development banking, as well as bio- and geo-engineering. Speculation as discourse has been around for some time in various guises. Consider, for example, the progress narrative that primes the funding rationale for Henry Ford’s rubber plantation in Brazil. I have called attention to it in the figuration of homeland futurity at the U.S.-Mexico border. But it has been more interested in highlighting what it might mean to speculate otherwise.

In an article titled “Hope over Experience: Desirability and the Persistence of Optimism,” a team of Yale economists concluded that people’s desires direct them toward optimism over and against their so-called better judgment. Alan Greenspan denounced the “irrational exuberance” and blamed it for the Asian financial crisis in the 1990s. Through the work of queer theorists like Lauren Berlant and Jasbir Puar, we can see that capitalism thrives on the energy of this cruel optimism, pathologizing it only when the market collapses to save its idealized rational subject from reproach.

Migrant Futures addresses counterfactual futures as they are imagined in both apparent fictions—novels and films—as well as masked fictions such as economic forecasts, founding documents of scientific consortia, and development plans linked to structural adjustment loans. Rather than using the latter as background to understand the former, Migrant Futures places both types of extrapolative enterprises on an equal footing. Both generate cultural fictions that then produce material effects. If financialization is a project that turns human sentiment into data with the goal of predicting and mitigating risk for wealthy elites, Migrant Futures focuses on the speculative fictions of those populations shuttled in and out of zones of growth. The members of this undercommons refuse to participate in, and are denied access to, the ladder of corporate productivity and take comfort instead in forms of kinship and occupation that survive alongside and below the radar of freewheeling global entrepreneurialism. Their irrational exuberance serves them well in the struggle to enact an alternative economy of sharing amid destitution, love for others amid austerity, and collaboration amid incentivized competition.

To think of migrant futures is to posit that which may never come to pass but must nevertheless persist speculatively, against all odds. Perhaps the primary function of their existence is to hold open the aperture to the beyond, where the systems that seemingly dominate cease to overwhelm. The cultural texts assembled in this book explore a sense of wonder that exceeds or runs parallel to frameworks of the knowable. These speculations from below face uncertainty with exuberance, daring to stay open to chance, in part because that is all they have, but also because they are no longer playing the same game. They have left the track.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.