You should embrace reparative reading practices that reject neoliberal futures while sustaining futures toward survival
Bahng 17 (Aimee Bahng is an American academic. She is a professor of gender and women's studies at Pomona College in Claremont, California. Her previous denial of tenure at Dartmouth College sparked widespread protests about discrimination against racial minorities in academia. 2017, “Migrant Futures: Decolonizing Speculation in Financial Times,” p132-145, accessed 7/24/2022) ng *figures omitted
Set in a dilapidated urban landscape, Malinky Robot revisits the primal scene of techno-Orientalist fantasy: Tokyo. However, by focusing on Tokyo’s day-laboring district of San’ya, which remains home to Tokyo’s dispossessed, Liew shifts the origin point of Japan’s economic success and underscores the vulnerability of those who were not folded into the prosperity of global capitalism.38 Like the denizens of Tokyo’s San’ya, Oliver and Atari “eke out a life” in a geopolitical context that works hard to eliminate them from the picture.39 Together they scrape together bits and pieces of culture, currency, and materials from the discarded matter of the city. “Eking out a life”—one of Liew’s favorite characterizations of Oliver and Atari’s mode of engaging with the world around them—resonates profoundly with Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s formulation of reparative practices, which illuminates “the many ways selves and communities succeed in extracting sustenance from the objects of a culture—even of a culture whose avowed desire has often been not to sustain them.”40 Sedgwick’s formulations of reparative versus paranoid modalities distinguish between ways of experiencing time—within and beyond narrative forms. Distinct from paranoid reading, which is motivated by an attempt to inure oneself to potentially horrible futures, reparative reading stays open and vulnerable to the radical possibilities of surprise.41 Though called sequential art, comics as a literary form have a propensity for bending time across the page, wherein the space between panels—“the gutter”—could represent a fleeting moment or eons of time passing, not necessarily in chronological order. Malinky Robot flexes the possibilities of its graphic form to capture play and adventure in slow time at a moment when blockbuster films profit from ever more accelerated pacing. With sparse, unspectacularized story lines that amount to “a robot walks home,” or “two kids borrow bikes to visit a friend,” Liew’s utopian visions—ephemeral and provisional—unfurl across the daily exploits and mundane, communal acts of these unlikely heroes of the future. Malinky Robot ruminates on forms of idleness that upend conceptions of wasted time, while simultaneously highlighting the waste of capitalist overproduction. Whereas the dystopian tenor of techno-Orientalist cyberpunk and the breakneck ambition of Future•Singapore both engender a paranoid relation to futurity by manifesting either foreboding about or securitization of it, Malinky Robot remains remarkably open to surprise and radical uncertainty. In this way, it articulates a reparative form of speculation—one that revels in the play of chance rather than the taming of it.42 Malinky Robot opens in 2024 atop a skyscraper (figure 4.3), where sunrise finds the protagonists on top of the world, not because they own or dominate it, but because they have made the rooftop their makeshift shelter. Atari and Oliver are homeless, making do with life in urban decay. Here, “mornings are . . . stinky!!” (11). This is the surprising pronouncement that begins “Stinky Fish Blues,” the first story in the collection. At dawn, Oliver encounters not the optimistic vista of sunlit horizons but the smell of a stagnant city, littered with signs of broken technological promises. Yet morning does bring surprising, if fleeting, moments of hope and unexpected opportunity. Oliver and Atari go fishing at the docks and discover rare life in the toxic waters—the nearly extinct Foetidus piscis (the stinky fish), which has persisted despite barrels of industrial sludge polluting its home. Their fortuitous catch fosters the hope of cashing it in for reward, but the fish ultimately falls prey to a friend’s more pressing need to eat it. The kids are disappointed but not dejected, as prospects of cashing in recede to make allowances for the sharing of life in this contingent community. The stinky fish, living beyond all probability in pernicious condtions, serves as a fitting compatriot for Oliver and Atari, who manage to do more than just survive in a hostile environment. They dare to have dreams, foster friendships, and have adventures that actively extend the possibilities of the living conditions allotted to them, even if their dreams remain decidedly out of reach. Likely destined to earn a living through tough, menial, and temporary work, Oliver and Atari might entertain brief moments of hope, but the fantasy to fly is not about ascendancy or mastery. The view from the top of Oliver’s transient skyscraper haven differs from what Michel de Certeau describes in “Walking in the City.” From the summit of the World Trade Center, de Certeau experiences being “lifted out of the city’s grasp. . . . When one goes up there, he leaves behind the mass. . . . His elevation transfigures him into a voyeur.”43 But Oliver’s prospects remain decidedly unchanged by this perspectival shift. He remains untransfigured, looking up like a homeless alien, not “looking down like a god.” This difference reverberates profoundly across the context of Atari’s and Oliver’s likely futures working in the construction sites that emblematize New Asia and its speculative building frenzy. Indeed, when the two look upon a construction site, they consider their curtailed set of opportunities, and even Oliver’s act of momentary ebullience (“I wanna fly a plane!”) (figure 4.4) seems squelched as the frame zooms out to capture the dwarfing effects of the world around him. The tops of skyscrapers yield only visions of unattainable aspirations and failed promises for Atari and Oliver, but they pursue adventure nonetheless and find in an arcade a virtual realization of Oliver’s hopes to pilot a plane. In this closing frame of the story (figure 4.5), Liew leaves us with a stunning display of reparative practice, of engaging in fleeting acts of pleasure to carve out alternative ways of looking forward. Together, Atari and Oliver explore alternative economies of exchange: they “borrow” bicycles that allow them to visit their friend Misha across town. Their mundane push toward collective ownership stands in stark contrast to the stealing-for-profit story Misha shares with them over lunch at “McDonnell’s” about Obiyashi Takamashuru, an unscrupulous man who stole the design for cantilevered gears on bikes from their mentor Mr. Bon Bon. This short vignette about bicycle thievery turns sideways when it’s revealed that bicycles themselves carry with them another story of stolen property. As we learn from Misha’s tale, the bicycle—as concept, design, and mode of transport—is always already stolen: the very mechanism that facilitates its locomotion turns out to be a lifted idea. Framed as the first in a series of comics within a comic, Misha’s Ingrown Nale reveals the history of the bicycle as property privatized and patented in the shadiest of circumstances, throwing the world of propriety into ethical question. Drawn in the heavily cross-grained and stridently scraggy pen-and-ink style of graphic mavericks such as Robert Crumb, Ingrown Nale (ostensibly produced from Misha’s hand but of course also a testament to Liew’s creative range) takes the reader into Obiyashi’s demented world of ruthless corporate competition, greed, and dishonesty. We follow Obiyashi to work on the day of his death and descent to a Dante-inspired hell, where he confesses how he stole the design of the cantilevered gear system. Though certainly incentivized to villainous action, Obiyashi turns out to be a dupe, trapped in the promise of a better future (figure 4.6). Before his fateful cardiac arrest, he reflects on his situation: “30 years! My life, a series of dwindling offices. I long for: the ocean, the trees, the breadth [sic] of my children as yet unborn. Today, though, will be a day different from days before” (45). We witness this corporate wonk’s perpetually fruitless drive toward upward mobility in several key details. Obiyashi’s namesake might ironically be Obayashi Global, the Japanese multinational construction corporation behind the building of Tokyo Sky Tree, the world’s tallest broadcasting tower. Obiyashi’s ascent in the corporate elevator leads him to a dead-end cube of an office. In his futile attempt to climb out of hell, he maniacally exclaims: “They gave me an office! They gave me a car! And a hat to wear for when it got windy!” (48). In these exclamations we hear the despair wrought by this subject’s investments in “aspirational normativity”:44 a perpetually upskilled life, heteronormative reproductive futurity, and a drive toward individualistic achievement. Obiyashi has spent years subjected to the “good life” logics of neoliberal capitalism—the logics that rationalize financial and social speculations privileging profit for the few over more disposable lives that don’t fit or aspire to the same narrative. The astonishing and inspiring element of the Malinky Robot stories is their commitment to disarming the seduction of neoliberal ascension and individualism in favor of cultivating extended practices of care and more inclusive notions of family and collective responsibility. In figure 4.7, we see Oliver’s comic strip embedded within the larger comic world of Malinky Robot. “Hi-Life” features two construction workers on their lunch break, sitting on a beam high up in a skyscraper, evocative of Charles Clyde Ebbets’s famous photograph, Lunch atop a Skyscraper, shot at New York City’s Rockefeller Center in 1932. In both examples, the drama revolves around the precariousness of high-rise construction work. Without harnesses, the workers seem alarmingly casual about their safety. Unlike the Depression-era photo, though, the display of risk in Oliver’s version has not been staged by corporate interest to promote the building of another Rockefeller skyscraper. Neither is the uncertainty of a person’s future contained by a narrative about the importance of saving. Liew opts, instead, to stay with the awkwardness of uncertainty, as one of the workers admits that he spends all his money on alcohol. In Malinky Robot, a post–financial crash story, putting money in a savings or interest-bearing retirement account might actually be more foolish than squandering one’s earnings on the pleasure of daily drinking. The snippet demonstrates Liew’s purposive undercutting of the “good life” promise—a promise of better futures that the act of building skyscrapers would seem to deliver. However, in Malinky Robot technological inventions, whether in the form of skyscrapers or cantilevered bike gears, fail to deliver on their promises. Oliver’s “Hi-Life” points to the irrelevance of whether these workers invest in the future or not; it recasts the tale of opportunity as a farce for those whom capitalism has deemed disposable, replaceable, and ultimately without a future. Liew sabotages reproductive futurity in a similar comic within a comic that plays on the popular children’s magazine activity of spotting the difference. Whereas a smiling child secures the happiness of the family portrait in the first panel, a tombstone supplants the child in the second and shatters the sunny disposition of reproductive futurity. Shattered also is the very exercise of spotting differences. These images make no pretense to similitude; with starkly contrasting color palettes—the first is in bright, mostly primary, colors, and the second is in macabre gray scale—spotting their differences hardly requires practiced sleuthing or careful discernment of the normal from the aberrant. Refusing to engage the familiar, normative apparatus, Liew puts pressure on Highlights’s slogan “fun with a purpose.”45 Oliver’s morbid rendering of spotting differences interrogates and dramatically halts the instrumentalization of fun. The critique of instrumentalized fun stands in direct contrast to Oliver’s preference for “irrational exuberance” over edutainment’s developmental games, designed to put kids on the dubious cutting edge of competitively tracked educational systems governed by quantitative evaluation and techno-positivist entrepreneurs. In this way, Oliver’s “Spot the Difference” comic registers a complaint against what Lee Edelman has termed “reproductive futurism,”46 a holding up of the figure of the child as the naturalized site of political incitement. The fraught case of imagining who shall inherit future Singapore, though, charts how capitalist development and ecological sustainability hold the question of reproduction and futurity in tension. Whereas a pronatalist movement in the 1980s led to a baby-bonus program with financial incentives for couples considering having second or third children, 1999 (on the heels of the financial crash of 1997–98) marked the launch of Singapore’s international head-hunting program to recruit students and professionals primarily from India and China.47 In 2001, the baby-bonus program was reinstated, awarding mothers $4,000 for each of the first two children born and $6,000 for the next two. More recently, at Singapore’s 2008 National Day, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong dedicated more than 5,000 words of his speech to discussing the falling birth rate.48 Singapore’s concern over its low birth rate—among the lowest in the world—was perhaps most overtly broadcast when a 2012 Mentos ad went viral, calling for a National Night wherein Singaporeans would enact their “civic duty” to make babies.49 Set to a song in which a male vocalist raps: “It’s National Night and I want a baby, boo, I know you want it, so duz the sdu,” the commercial refers to the Social Development Unit (renamed the Social Development Network), a governmental body devoted to addressing the low birth rate and housed under the broader reaching Ministry of Social and Family Development. That state development includes such calls to reproduction as civic duty situates Singaporean futurity not in the figure of the child, but in actual children. The Mentos commercial, in its unapologetic overture to heterosexual baby making, makes clear the connections between reproductive futurity and other speculative futures. National Night, according to the video, also means getting aroused by the potential of buying a $900 stroller and taking a stroll through the Gardens by the Bay park—a billion-dollar, 103-acre public construction project that even looks like a giant bubble of speculative financing with all the aesthetic trappings of speculative futurity. It is against these financial forms of irrational exuberance that Atari and Oliver’s flights of fancy and moments of ebullience stand in contrast. Nevertheless, the exuberance Liew captures in his vibrant, dynamic, and wiggling lines also distinguishes itself from the imaginary of austerity and responsibility, marshaled by discourses of personal finance.50 In another sidebar comic within a comic, Atari’s imagined superhero Doctor Midnight (Mr. Bon Bon in disguise) administers punishment to his foes even as he spouts after-school specials’ canned statements about health and fitness. With each pow! krak! bif! blow to the thugs who have come to claim the stolen bicycles, the doctor administers “medicine”: “floss after every meal!” “always wear your seat-belt!” and “Maintain an active lifestyle!” (60). Doctor Midnight’s recitation of sound-bites about selfimprovement and healthy living as civic virtue is decidedly ironic. For all of modern science’s promises of its beneficial effects on the population, these pledged benefits have passed over Oliver and Atari, who seem wholly unmoved by overtures to longevity and prosperity. As the sworn defender of street urchins, Doctor Midnight interrogates for whom these logics of prolonging life are designed. After dispatching his adversaries, he rebukes the thin assurances of better tomorrows: “Who builds the cities? By whose sweat, by whose blood?? And in return to ask nothing but a roof over their heads. . . . Seeking merely to manage from day to day . . . in these times of unending change . . . and in the bitter end to shuffle into the darkness of this mortal coil that binds us all. What is it that awaits us beyond that final frontier? What indignities, what sorrows? What semblance of this hell that we have already tasted on this cruel earth?” (61). The city of the future does not provide a roof over the heads of those who built it. Oliver and Atari “manage from day to day” by squatting in makeshift shelters either on rooftops or in abandoned “McDonnell’s” sites, making do with the materials of dilapidated futurity. Doctor Midnight’s closing monologue alludes to the oscillatory quality of Hamlet’s considerations “to be or not to be.” The allusion helps illuminate the relationship between life and futurity— “perchance to dream”—and insists on the importance of thinking of the future as contested and critical terrain. If they were to buy into the aspirations of upward mobility and the gleaming promises of Asian futurity, Oliver and Atari would partake in what Lauren Berlant has called “cruel optimism.” Berlant investigates “what happens to fantasies of the good life when the ordinary becomes a landfill for overwhelming and impending crises of life-building and expectation whose sheer volume so threatens what it has meant to ‘have a life’ that adjustment seems like an accomplishment.”51 In many ways, Malinky Robot sketches out in haunting beauty the condition of “living in crisis,”52 wherein we encounter Atari and Oliver negotiating “the impasse” of everyday crisis in their temporary shelters and tender socialities.53 In Atari and Oliver’s daily exploits, we find a sustained rumination on the caring relationship between two truant geeks who aspire “toward and beyond survival,” but in ways that move “toward an opening that does not involve rehabituation, the invention of new normativities, or working through and beyond trauma.”54 Rather than eschewing Asian futurity in the face of techno-Orientalism, Malinky Robot follows Berlant’s injunction “to imagine better economies of intimacy and labor.”55 Launched from within a “McDonnell’s” where Atari and Oliver have scored a free lunch from their friend Misha, this series of embedded comics, which include Misha’s story of the theft of Mr. Bon Bon’s intellectual property, Oliver’s Sunday funnies about joblessness and curtailed futures, and Atari’s Doctor Midnight superhero comic, allows incredible artistry and imaginative storytelling to unfurl against the backdrop of Super size french fries and the multinational reach of corporations like McDonald’s. As the friends return to their neighborhood on their borrowed bicycles, they run into Mr. Bon Bon, whose backstory they’ve just learned over lunch. In the closing full-page panel of “Bicycles,” we see Bon Bon crouch to inspect the cantilevered gear, the sign of all that could have been. But, as the ordinary hero, Mr. Bon Bon simply asks if the kids are hungry and suggests a new noodle place where they can eat, “his treat.” In the cruel world of foreclosed opportunities, where Mr. Bon Bon works construction even though his invention could have gained him access to a life of financial security and relative comfort, Liew’s story bears witness to the startling willingness to cultivate tender ties in precarious times. Malinky Robot posits an alternative to cruel optimism—call it a queer exuberance—that persists not only in the queer kinships Misha, Atari, Oliver, and Mr. Bon Bon form amid conditions of contingency and precarity, but also in Liew’s ekphrastic exercise that restores texture to Asian futurity when techno-Orientalism works to smooth over the vicissitudes of neoliberalism. As Singapore relies increasingly on temporary migrant workers, its flexible accumulation trades on the cruelly optimistic drive toward a good life and the promise of an Asian futurity that will never arrive for the vast majority of the workers who sustain the wealth of the few. Malinky Robot imagines otherwise.