Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Narrative constructions of the future materialize the way we invest in the present. Their seemingly objective predictions calculate subjects into knowability while simultaneously rendering data into fiction, unleashing abstract symbolic violence onto the world. Our uncertainty disrupts securitization and embraces the knowable as lived experience, creating a horizon of the not yet for non-White futurities.

Bahng 17, Aimee Bahng is an American academic. She is a professor of gender and women's studies at Pomona College in Claremont, California. Her previous denial of tenure at Dartmouth College sparked widespread protests about discrimination against racial minorities in academia., (Aimee, “Introduction: On Speculation Fiction, Finance, and Futurity” in Migrant Futures: Decolonizing Speculation in Financial Times, Duke University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱‍👤

This book puts into conversation speculative finance and speculative fiction as two forms of extrapolative figuration that participate in the cultural production of futurity. To put these two seemingly disparate arenas of narrative production into conversation, I largely use the methodologies of an emerging field that could be called critical finance studies in conjunction with a longer standing field called feminist science studies, which trained me to beware of the “god trick of seeing everything from nowhere” purveyed by the seemingly pure, objective vision of scientific and capitalist realism.6 It is indeed a god trick to get people to mistake prophecy for truth, notional figure for value, or futurity for the future. As a lifetime student of the power of narrative to alter reality, or at least perceptions of it, I have often been awed by fiction’s nearly magical actuarial potency. By approaching both speculative finance and speculative fiction as narrative productions, I emphasize the performativity of economics and therefore the potential power of the literary imagination to call forth new political economies, ways of living, and alternative relational structures; and different sorts of subjects into the world.

I use the term “futurity” to highlight the construction of the future and denaturalize its singularity, while maintaining an emphasis on how narrative constructions of the future play a significant role in materializing the present. “Extrapolation,” for example, is the name for the mathematical modeling practice economists use to predict future commodity prices and investment trends based on data compiled in databases such as the crb Commodity Yearbook, Wharton Research Data Services, as well as Global Financial Data Solutions. At the same time, science fiction studies might first associate extrapolation with the eponymous academic journal, which publishes scholarly essays on science fiction (also called extrapolative or speculative fiction). Migrant Futures investigates how we narrate futurity across various platforms, from speculative fiction to financial speculation. How do our stories of the future chart the ways we invest—financially, politically, ideologically, and intellectually—in the present? How do the logics of preemption break across the shores of financial securitization, military preparedness, and scientific projection? These are some of the questions taken up by anthropologists, sociologists, historians, cultural theorists, and other scholars contributing to an interdisciplinary examination of financialization.7

Most notably, Edward LiPuma and Benjamin Lee assert the social construction of financial derivatives—a social construction that, like race, nonetheless has profound material effects on people’s livelihoods, state politics, and international conflicts. LiPuma and Lee call derivatives “socially imaginary objects” and assert “the social construction of the various types of derivatives.”8 They also emphasize the “abstract symbolic violence” that speculative capital wreaks on the world—“symbolic in the sense that it is not accomplished physically by means of military force or colonialism, though it may, of course, engender the conditions (such as impoverishment) that precipitate violent crime and warfare” and “abstract in the sense that it never appears directly; rather it mediates and stands behind local realities—such as interest rates, food costs, and the price of petroleum.”9 One poignant example that LiPuma and Lee provide is the effect of presidential elections on the global economy. In the case of the 2002 Brazilian presidential election, for example, when Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva of the Worker’s Party was projected to win, “the principal players in the Latin American financial markets started to sell and short the Brazilian currency.”10 Electoral projections produced economic reality. As Migrant Futures headed into the final stages of production, the United States has witnessed the election of Donald Trump as its president. On the evening of November 8, 2016, as people watched the results come in, they also noted the Dow Jones falling precipitously. By morning, though, markets seemed to have leveled out, and the futures markets in U.S. Steel and private prisons in particular were looking quite good, indeed. This last example, when read through the burgeoning body of critical work in prison abolition movements, yokes the abstract violence of finance capitalism to more overt manifestations of state violence as exacted through the police force disproportionately on black and brown, queer and trans bodies in the United States.

Predicated on prediction, the algorithmic models used in the financial sector as well as by insurance companies often count on the movements of legible and calculable subjects. Financial speculation, extrapolation, and prediction rely on mathematical models and probabilistic logics to transform quantitative data into a narrative arc. By plotting points along a line on a graph and deriving meaning from those data, these narratives require a rendering of a trajectory. Though that rendering often takes shape in the visual field of graphic representation, financial forecasters produce extrapolative fiction when they functionally convert data into an interpretive arc, to be articulated and narrativized in and beyond the graphic form. Econometrics extrapolates from data collected by the University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index and Index of Consumer Expectations, for example, which reduce sentiment and expectation to numeric values in an attempt to measure and then advise for or against hedging uncertain futures. This “datafication” is also a rendering of data into fiction or statistical narrative, which Kathleen Woodward has characterized as “the preeminent expression of late capitalism.”11 Financial speculation produces a kind of speculative fiction, and despite its overtures to fact over fiction, it both contributes to and is affected by a broader cultural production of futurity. By reading the social construction of financial derivatives alongside more readily recognizable forms of speculative fiction, Migrant Futures asks if another mode of speculation is possible, one that is not immediately captured by the anxious gatherings of risk.12 If finance is, as Max Haiven characterizes it, “capitalism’s imagination,” wherein neoliberal financialization “comes at the expense of the radical imagination,” I locate a primary site of radical imagination in migrant futures that shift the site of emergency away from terror toward deportation, attend to alternative pockets of wonder such as feminist fabulation rather than defense strategy think tanks, and speculate worlds that demand new onto-epistemological ways of being and thinking.

Launching this examination are fundamental questions about who narrates these futurities and what kinds of subject positions play out in these projected temporal landscapes. Implicitly, the project interrogates who stands to profit from and who risks extinction in prevailing narratives about the future. The principal players in the derivatives markets are multinational corporations, international agencies such as the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, investment banks, and hedge funds that pool the investments of wealthy clients—basically, everyone but individuals and nations.13 The funds of the four largest U.S. participants—JPMorgan Chase, Citibank, Bank of America, and Goldman Sachs—represent more than 30 percent of the total global derivatives market.14 Furthermore, the fundamental governance of the global financial system has been dominated entirely by U.S. and European economic interests, though countries with clearly emerging market economies, such as China, India, and Brazil, have demanded a seat at the rule-making table.15 The financial colonization of the future builds on preexisting disparities of wealth held over from earlier histories of empire and neocolonial enterprises that break at the fault line between what has been called the Global North and South.

Meanwhile, mass migrations of the undocumented, unbanked, and state-less workers move in and out of geopolitical spaces, the nuances and histories of their displacement and precarity flattened by statistical aggregation. They are migrant noncitizens, outliers, most of whom hail from the Global South and have slipped beyond even “dividual” statistical legibility.16 In the calculus of risk, the unmeasurable uncertainty of this statistical undercommons generates some friction, some disruption of the would-be-unflappable promises of securitization. The economist Frank Knight, in his interrogation of risk, distinguishes calculable probability (risk) from the “absolute unpredictability of things” (true uncertainty).17 In the risk-uncertainty dialectic, sheer uncertainty invites profit seekers to convert profoundly unknowable states into probabilistic forecasts, to fold uncertainty back into risk practices—yet uncertainty cuts loose from risk discourse’s capture, eluding containment and quantification. While true uncertainty might refuse the grid of intelligibility that securitization would foist upon it, it remains knowable as lived experience, felt and negotiated perhaps most profoundly by those held in “the waiting-room of history.” As he describes this imaginary waiting room in Provincializing Europe, Dipesh Chakrabarty suggests that the “modern, European idea of history. . . came to non-European peoples in the 19th century as somebody’s way of saying ‘not yet’ to somebody else.”18 In the context of finance capitalism, though, the inhabitants of the waiting room are in fact being written out of the future. What would it mean to reconfigure that marginalization from European notions of progress, modernity, history, and futurity? What alternative futurities emerge from those living beyond the purview of statistical projection?

If the abstraction of populations into calculated risks and algorithmic approximations of lived experiences produces for state and international regulatory institutions “a legible and administratively convenient format,”19 queer and trans theorists have been particularly helpful in thinking through a politics that does not simply demand inclusion in that system. A 2015 special issue of Transgender Studies Quarterly, for example, takes aim at the “imperative to be counted,” which becomes “another form of normativizing violence that trans subjects can encounter.”20 Census Bureau and National Health Statistics data that feed U.S. biopolitical regimes of population regulation work to regularize a population and “flatten its zoetic confusions of movement and form, of time and space, of doing and being, into neat two-dimensional axes specifying static properties and numbers.”21 Population regulation and public health discourse, insofar as they share statistical methods with financial models of speculating on risk, could very well move toward three-dimensional models using differential geometry and statistical mechanics to predict volatility.22 But no matter how nuanced and complex the models get, Paisley Currah and Susan Stryker’s provocation to consider how trans disrupts configurations of “statistical citizenship” opens up a queering of speculation and perhaps even a queering of statistical data as numerical or categorical, discrete or continuous, nominal or ordinal.23 By “queering speculation,” I refer to a host of reconfigurations of our relationships to the “financialization of daily life” and the manifestation of a “risk society”—which is to say a normative investment in quantitative data to project futurity.24

When José Muñoz asserts that “the future is queerness’s domain,” he posits a horizon of potentiality. Though that horizon might invoke Martin Heidegger’s Being and Time and therefore asks us to contend with Heidegger’s Nazism, Muñoz’s articulation of a not yet draws more compellingly not only on Giorgio Agamben’s formulation but also on Ernst Bloch’s theorization of indeterminacy. Muñoz’s presentation of the not yet of queer futurity suggests a way to seize the not yet of European historicity as described in Chakrabarty’s waiting-room scenario. In Muñoz’s words, “we are left waiting but vigilant in our desire for another time that is not yet here.” Queer futurity offers a model for transforming the waiting room into a horizon. As it moves through examples of queer art, performance, and other queer utopian expressions, Muñoz’s Cruising Utopia looks to the realm of the open-ended gesture as an alternative to the way other forms of speculation attempt to pull that horizon of the future into the present for profit.25

By enjambing these two formulations of the not yet—one that seeks to illuminate histories of empire and exclusion, and another that insists on futurity as an opening up rather than a closing down—I want to consider the relationship between the waiting room and the horizon. For it is precisely in the exile’s relation to time—the point at which one is pushed out of what could be called straight time, settler time, or the profitable time of compound interest—that one can glimpse the horizon of the not yet, where not yet manifests itself not as a decree of foreclosure but as an embrace of the unknown. Building on the work of C. L. R. James, Muñoz writes: “To call for this notion of the future in the present is to summon a refunctioned notion of utopia in the service of subaltern politics.”26

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.