The gamespace of debate is intertwined with late capitalism – assumptions of fair play and logistical mapping reinscribe the conditions that uphold the fantasy of perfecting space. Instead, our extreme Asian gaming disrupts capitalist time and blurs the boundaries between Occident and Orient.
Roh et al. 15, David Roh is Professor of English at the University of Utah. He holds a BA in English from the University of California, Los Angeles, an Ed.M in Educational Technology from Harvard University, and an MA and Ph.D in English from the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is author of Minor Transpacific: Triangulating American, Japanese, and Korean Fictions (Stanford University Press, 2021), Illegal Literature (University of Minnesota Press, 2015), and coeditor of Techno-Orientalism (Rutgers University Press, 2015). His work has appeared in Law & Literature, MELUS, Journal of Narrative Theory, and Verge., (“Chapter 8: Never Stop Playing”, Techno-Orientalism: Imagining Asia in Speculative Fiction, History, and Media, Rutgers University Press) //CHC-DS 🐱👤
In an essay called “Angels in Digital Armor: Technoculture and Terror Management” (2010), media scholar Marcel O’Gorman argues that notions of heroism in contemporary technoculture aim to satisfy two primary existential needs: the desire for recognition and the denial of death. Most video games interpellate players by reinforcing ideologies that underpin the sovereign subject, who believes herself to be immortal and master of the world represented on the computer screen. Gaming is one part of a broadly conceived digital technoculture for O’Gorman. Appropriating Bernard Stiegler’s thesis that the technologization of culture is linked to profound malaise and ontological indifference, O’Gorman argues that online heroism, constituted through attention garnered on Facebook, YouTube, and the news media, goes hand in hand with the disavowal of mortality and finitude. Toward this O’Gorman analyzes cases of gamer death in China and Korea, the Columbine High School shootings, and Cho Seung-Hui, the Virginia Tech shooter, as “explicitly technological, or even ‘cyber,’ because they involve the perpetrators’ use of media to rehearse or to promote their exploits in a desperate plea for recognition” (O’Gorman). He does not discuss race explicitly but implies that all users of digital media are somehow implicated.
While we agree with O’Gorman’s diagnosis of the culture of online celebrity and the proliferation of technically induced malaise, his analysis runs the danger of overgeneralization with the blanket term “technoculture.” We would like to attend to the specificity of video gaming and its Orientalist figuration by isolating a mechanic of StarCraft that is common to most video games: the acquisition of capital. More specifically, for the remainder of the essay we further interrogate the relationship between work and play. While drawing from McKenzie Wark’s Gamer Theory and key game play mechanics from StarCraft, we argue that extreme video gaming may be read to challenge the presuppositions that deem it “unproductive” labor. In doing so, we argue that extreme gaming upends notions of capitalist time, pointing to ontological aporias that blur the distinction between Occidental and Oriental.
Playing StarCraft teaches its players about life outside of the game, a testament perhaps to its broader relevance, training them to become better capitalists. Because of the cutthroat level of competition and the constant influx of new talent, professional gamers in Korea mostly enjoy short careers that are abbreviated by mandatory military service. After being discharged from the military, pro gamer Lee Joong Heon was employed at a video game company. But after a five-year retirement, Lee, formerly a Warcraft III player, decided to return to eSports and made the transition to StarCraft II. In a 2009 interview, Lee relates that his return is temporary and that he will retire again in three years. A job in a trading company is lined up for him once he is done gaming professionally (Yong-woo Kim). In a parallel career move, pro gamer Seo Jihoon found a position as a sports marketer with the Korean conglomerate CJ Group once he retired from StarCraft. A book published in 2000 in the wake of the financial crisis called Starcnomics connects StarCraft and its game play mechanics to the business world (Tae-heung Kim; Hee-jong Kang). The parallel between the logic of gaming and business may be evidenced in the United States as well. The University of Florida has offered a class on “21st Century Skills in StarCraft,” while the University of California, Berkeley campus has competitive StarCraft courses. Playing StarCraft teaches one to become better at life within capitalism.
These examples illustrate that StarCraft is not merely a form of play; instead, much of the “play” within the game could be considered a form of work. Unlike many video games, the player does not control an avatar or an in-game virtual representative (usually the main character of a narrative). In StarCraft and many RTS games, the player assumes a godlike overseer/ manager position with an isometric view of the battlefield. At the start of a session, the player can see and control his or her base, with the rest of the map, in the bottom-left corner of the screen, obscured by a “fog of war.” If the player clicks on parts of the map past his or her base, the view is hidden in blackness until it is traversed by one of the player’s military units. The player knows only two things: how large the map is and that an enemy is located somewhere. As in cognitive mapping, the player wishes to lift the fog of war to chart out the playing area and master the space. The player does not engage the enemy immediately, for he or she must first build up forces in preparation for it. And in order to prepare, the player must acquire and manage resources, like the capitalist in life outside the game.
Thus despite its twenty-fifth-century settings, game play in StarCraft proceeds with twentieth-century late capitalistic assumptions. At the start of each game, the player is given a central base, four worker units, and start-up capital. With these resources, the player constructs more buildings such as barracks, factories, gateways, and spawning pools in order to recruit more workers, build new structures, and produce new military units. The worker units acquire vespene gas (a resource only found in the game) from geysers and harvest minerals from the environment. The barracks train an array of offensive and defensive military units, each with particular modes of movement and attack patterns. Oftentimes preparation for battle—and the battle itself—can take only minutes or an hour and more, and the player is forced to make most of these crucial moments by planning ahead, making quick decisions, and moving rapidly. The thrill of engaging the enemy must be preceded by this tedious labor, which is squandered when the player’s units are destroyed in combat. As such, the aim of producing only in order to destroy and be destroyed aligns StarCraft with something akin to building a sand castle. The pleasure of constructing a sand castle is embodied in the labor utilized to build something ephemeral. Within capitalism, this ephemerality is obscured by the ideological belief that tedious labor is productive labor, yet management within StarCraft brings the basic ephemerality of capital itself to the fore.
In Gamer Theory, McKenzie Wark breaks down the distinction between the real world and the illusory world of the video game. He coins the term “gamespace” to signify not the virtual realm depicted on a screen, but a physically placeless realm where the logic of gaming, including quantitative modes of human valuation such as the “lifebar,” indicated underneath each unit, underpins lived existence. In contrast to Johan Huizinga’s famous definition of play as “a stepping out of ‘real’ life into a temporary sphere of activity with a disposition all of its own,” for Wark playing video games is coextensive with the human operation of hardware and software in our contemporary postFordist economy (26). “Games are not representations of this world,” Wark writes, “they are more like allegories of a world made over as gamespace. They encode the abstract principles upon which decisions about the realness of this or that world are now decided” (20). Considered within the logic of late capitalism, gamespace quickly takes on a holistic aspect, for it also describes the total administration of human activity outside the video game, while perpetuating the ideology that the game is nevertheless predicated on the “fair fight” and the maintenance of a “level playing field.” Gamespace overlaps with the space of the neoliberal, global economy. For Wark, a critical theory of video games begins by taking outside reality not as the model to which games should aspire, but itself as “a gamespace that appears as an imperfect form of the computer game” (22).
As Wark dismantles the binary between reality and game, other distinctions are implicated. Specifically, if gamespace describes an existential condition in late capitalism, and if the mechanics of reward and punishment operative in video games allegorizes an identical mechanics in contemporary lived life, then Wark’s deconstruction necessarily carries similar implications for the distinction between work and play. While in an earlier era of capitalist development such a distinction structured what Marx called “species-being,” as well as productive and unproductive activity, in the age of video games work becomes another form of play, and vice versa. Gaming is a form of work, but as of yet not everyone is paid to play.
The rules of fair play in video games and the ideology of neoliberalism intersect: if the player works hard, the player’s efforts will be acknowledged and the work compensated. Most video games are motivated by this reward dynamic through the achievement of a high score or the acquisition of coveted items and money, both of which correspond to the acquisition of capital in the nonvirtual space. Endless acquisition in gamespace is particularly pronounced in the practice of “gold farming,” widespread in China. Gold farmers play for hours acquiring virtual capital in MMORPG games such as World of Warcraft in order to sell it for real capital (Vincent). Yet through this, traditional ontological distinctions between gaming and the actual world are radically confused. Approaching online RPGs as an economist, Edward Castronova describes the relatively banal “economics of fun” that underpin the synthetic world of games. “The economy is in fact an integral part of the fantasy,” Castronova writes. “Nothing makes a world feel more alive than an active market system” (172). Gold farming, the most laborious form of contemporary video gaming in the neoliberal economy, troubles Western capitalist notions of work and play by bringing tedium into play. It is thus perhaps not a surprise that certain journalists express disdain for professional video gaming and with the idea of eSports: for them, video games belong to the realm of leisure, sitting for hours being unproductive, and are not supposed to be laborious.
Yet in this, StarCraft offers peculiar problems. StarCraft provides abundant financial reward, especially for professional gamers, who are among the highest paid in Korean eSports, but its game play does not depend on conventional systems of reward. In-game capital provides player satisfaction in most games. However in StarCraft, since in-game capital is ephemeral, the player has only his or her professional record. This is contrary to other games where gamers have something “to show,” such as a powerful avatar with the capital, commodities, and experience to signify the labor and time put into the game. In StarCraft the only record of total labor time is the players’ IDs with their career wins and losses. The point of StarCraft is not to accumulate resources, but to use them as efficiently as possible before the match is over. In-game resources such as minerals and vespene gas imitate the exchange value of money in order to produce more buildings and units, but there is no long-term merit to the production of surplus value beyond the length of the individual match. Unlike in gold farming, accumulated capital retains no exchange value. Instead, resources have use value insofar as they become mobilized to defeat the enemy. Seen from the perspective of gamespace, the conditions of the professional StarCraft player imitate those of temporary capitalist labor, but the player’s activity also reveals the virtual ontology and short-term orientation of capital itself. The management of minerals and vespene gas in many ways allegorizes the management of virtual funds for short-term, liquid markets in the shadow banking system.
If games create environments where gamers, regardless of their identity, compete in “fair play,” then extreme gamers push its limits by playing harder than everyone else. The morbid fascination in gamers who play themselves to death then threatens to expose an older ideological assumption that underpins this very interest: that human activity may be divided cleanly between unproductive leisure and productive labor. Despite the claim that postindustrial economies have unilaterally dissolved the boundary between leisure and labor, within techno-Orientalism this ideological remnant of the industrial economy reinscribes the division. Asian gamer death then remains ambivalent, for it blurs the discursive boundaries that underpin the gamespace of contemporary capitalism while taking the logic of life in neoliberalism to its limit. The threatened subject of the neoliberal economy must subsequently underscore the real historical specificities that persist between cultures and reconstitute them on the level of ontology. The Western gamer then, like that depicted in Sony’s commercial, believes that he or she can stay on top without having to compete with the rising Asian economies. Such differences are all too often understood within the tropes of racism and technology: Asians are chained to their computers through their addiction to StarCraft, while the West remains essentially free, having a much more “healthy” relationship to video games. However, our analysis of gaming and capital suggests that all users are implicated in the logic of gamespace.
The dream of “never stop playing,” like the mystifications of Orientalism, reflects not the truth of the exotic Other, or the transgressive possibilities opened up by purchasing a PlayStation Vita, but the narcissism of the capitalist subject. The dream of gaming endlessly reflects the dream of the hip gamer who never has to work, while the Asian gamer, who dies from playing, points to a fundamental aporia that subtends the binary between work and play, and between self and exotic other. As Alexander R. Galloway puts it in his book The Interface Effect, “We are all gold farmers” (136). This thought troubles binaries of life in industrial capitalism by which we understand value and productivity in modernity. In this, the Asian gamer may be thought of as “ahead” of the West in terms of the development of the neoliberal economy. Reinstating racial binaries functions as a bulwark against the deconstruction of life (which should be productive in capitalism) and death (which is often considered unproductive), as well as against the anxiety this deconstruction produces. Fetishizing Asian gamer death and the Asian work ethic performs the work of disavowal, disavowal of the fundamental differences that persist between self and other, while attempting to mediate non-Western modes of capitalist productivity.
When Blizzard released StarCraft II in 2010, eAthletes immediately embraced the new installment. Professional leagues sprouted up, and in May 2012 both OnGameNet (the most prestigious StarCraft league) and the Korean eSports Association announced that they would be making the official transition to StarCraft II (TeamLiquid). Lim Yo-hwan, the player most synonymous with StarCraft, also retired from StarCraft: Brood War to begin playing StarCraft II, a move so significant that a documentary titled Lim Yo-hwan’s Wings was produced (Ho-kyung Choi). The industry was able to migrate quickly because of the similarity of the mechanics between StarCraft and StarCraft II. And thus like its predecessor, StarCraft II may be read to problematize the binary between work and play outside the game, as well as imaginations of Occident and Orient. It also makes apparent the quick turns in the cutthroat Internet gaming milieu that characterizes much of East Asia and brings to the fore the culmination of capitalist logic. This is the very same mechanism that cycles eAthletes, while leaving young men, and the occasional young woman, dead in PC bangs just as quickly as it promotes them to national heroes. While these gamers perish in their quest to never stop playing, the death of the Asian gamer will be appropriated within the geopolitics of labor in Asia—unless, of course, video gaming is allowed to transcend reified notions of play.