Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The form of debate that calls us to “adhere to the rules” instates a subject that reproduces and rewards subjects who adhere to racializing logics built into the game.

Lu 21 (Melanie Lu, Writing Consultant at Vanderbilt's Writing Studio, Editor, Vanderbilt Lives, Undergraduate Creative Nonfiction Journal; April 27th, 2021, “Gendering the Techno-Orient: The Asian Woman in Speculative Fiction,” https://ir.vanderbilt.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1803/16493/LuMelanie_VUIRSubmission.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y; accessed 7/23/2022) ng

The possibilities are numerous, yet my interests here gravitate more specifically towards the emerging discourse on video games, the most lucrative entertainment industry in the world today. My previous analysis of films—especially Ghost in the Shell—has demonstrated the importance of taking into account the nature of visual form, in addition to narrative content, in shaping particular viewer interpretations. Paying attention to the creative medium itself becomes especially important when we enter the realm of video games, where interactivity is one of the defining characteristics of game experience. While any text, whether literary, visual, or otherwise, arguably “interacts” with an active reader/viewer in some way to produce meaning, video games offer unique challenges to how we think about interacting with texts. Not discounting the ongoing discussion regarding the role of narratology versus ludology in video games studies (Juul 16), I aim to briefly highlight here the medium’s high level of interactivity as a significant area in which racialization and gendering take place through mechanisms inherent to video games. I am therefore less interested in how fiction or storytelling in games can Otherize—they certainly do—but rather in how the underlying structures of video game mechanics do so, perhaps as part of a larger conversation on the ideological mapping of computer-mediated processes. For my purposes, I wish to call attention to the rule-based, outcome-oriented qualities that govern most video games; the fact that the player is encouraged, compelled, or simply allowed to perform certain actions in order to achieve certain outcomes is crucial to understanding how video games exert cultural influence and (re)produce ideology. Ian Bogost’s concept of procedural rhetoric is useful here: distinct from the verbal or visual rhetoric that accompanies more traditional forms of media, procedural rhetoric as often operating through digital systems designates the practice of using processes such as game mechanics persuasively, where “arguments are not made through the construction of words or images, but through the authorship of rules of behavior, the construction of dynamic models” (Bogost 29). Bogost contends that video games that effectively mount sophisticated procedural rhetoric can inform and challenge players to reflect on how processes in the material world do, can, or should work, thereby interrogating these material systems themselves (Bogost 57). But even as I accept Bogost’s fundamental premise that video games utilize argumentative procedure to great degree, I resist the suggestion that this procedure is necessarily rhetorical in nature: while players can indeed be persuaded to adopt certain views, it is also likely that the same procedures can manipulate or condition them into doing so. In other words, Bogost fails to adequately address the extent to which pre-existing ideologies may already naturalize, and thus reinforce, the very material processes video game procedures can literalize or seemingly call into question. Alexander Galloway has pointed out that procedures in video games—or what he calls “protocols”—can be viewed as allegories of control, where, through following and absorbing game rules that mirror the politics of the informatic age, players are “learning, internalizing, and becoming intimate with a massive, multipartite global algorithm” (Galloway 35). It is this more pernicious effect of video game procedure that I highlight as a reinstantiation of techno-Orientalism in new media. Let us briefly consider one example of a video game where this tension between procedure and allegory comes into play through racial Othering. While Lucas Pope’s 2013 independent game Papers, Please has garnered much critical attention for its procedural sophistication in interrogating the realities of immigration policy and authoritarian state violence, his most recent detective game Return of the Obra Dinn (2018) utilizes procedure in ways that are subtler and perhaps more troubling. On a general level, Obra Dinn employs procedural mechanics common to the detective genre’s idealization of objective, intelligible, and unmediated historical truths, such as by granting the detective means to traverse time and space when unravelling the Obra Dinn’s mystery; however, here it is important to elaborate on how racialization mechanisms are similarly woven into the structural pathways of the game. Set aboard a fictional East India Company trade ship from 1802, the game requires the player to investigate the fates of the Obra Dinn’s 60 crew members and passengers, who have all died or disappeared due to various natural and supernatural causes. The player navigates in first-person the complex layout of the monochromatic three-story ship with a magical pocket watch, which allows them to return to specific moments before each character’s death to explore relevant audio and visual clues. Using a roster and drawings of the crew, the player makes progress in the game whenever they correctly determine and input character fates into their inspector’s logbook; with every three cases solved, they are able to access more scenes and proceed further into the mystery. Even on a narrative level, the game Orientalizes by relying heavily on a mystical Formosan treasure chest as a central plot device: belonging to a group of royal Formosan passengers, this exotic object is revealed to have set in motion the endless tragedies on board, where, through some unfathomable Oriental magic, hordes of “terrible beasts” of the sea are lured in to attack the Obra Dinn. What calls for scrutiny is not just how the plot of the mystery unfolds, however, but more importantly the procedural strategies of deduction players have at their disposal when identifying characters and subsequently their fates. While more scrupulous or ambitious players may meticulously look for conclusive clues embedded solely within the narrative, such as by reconstructing timelines, analyzing character relationships through dialogue, or tracking specific character items at key locations, the game also offers a more freeform reasoning space in which external factors, such as profession or race, can be exploited for processes of elimination. At more difficult stages within the game where clues are scarce, one inevitably finds themselves noticing the simplistically rendered, but unmistakably present, racialized appearances of the characters, or the pronounced accents and linguistic variation of the dialogue recordings replayed at each death. Combined with the logbook’s convenient catalogue of all character origins, which include a variety of European and Asian nationalities, these normative racial markers make it possible for the player to guess character identities through trial and error, since the logbook automatically progresses once any three correct fates are reached. For instance, a player might assume a certain character to be Chinese based on their appearance and/or accent; then, with two identifications already entered into the logbook, the player could input all the Chinese names given until one of them triggers a third correct response. The way the game portrays individual racial appearance, accent, or culture—whether “accurately” or otherwise—is irrelevant here; what Bogostian procedure highlights are the rule-based structural pathways encoded in the game that permit racialization to work as a strategy in the first place. Obra Dinn thus motivates the player to make the kind of racial generalizations—accent as natural index of identity, ethnic features as justified means of racial and subsequently social categorization, etc.—that Bogost anticipates such a game to critique through procedure. Yet, instead of using rhetoric to expose the harm of racial Othering, the game cements their normative nature; since players are able to proceed in the game in this way and uncover the “truth” of the mystery, Obra Dinn actually rewards them for engaging in these ideological practices, thus further naturalizing the constructed logic of racialization. This implicitly encoded notion of reward is especially important when we reflect on Bogostian procedure in terms of its argumentative qualities. Unlike language that aims to persuade through direct instruction or explication, the procedures players are introduced to in video games like Obra Dinn are powerful tools by which ideology is learned, in the sense that players internalize—through interacting first-hand with rules of the game—processes that they themselves observe to be effective, often in high-stakes settings. In Obra Dinn’s online community forums, some players comment gleefully or in frustration about the fact that they can use “brute force” logic to clear the game, while others retort that this is not how the game is “supposed to be played.” But a singular or mandatory method for playing the game does not exist, just as a singular method to interpret a text does not exist, and it is precisely this possibility, this hidden logic, embedded in the game that becomes critical to its treatment of racial ideology as argument. For Obra Dinn does not offer a puzzle in which race does not exist or signify, nor does it explicitly satirize racialization as its own procedural vice, as was perhaps done with Papers, Please; instead, players encounter situations where racialization, seemingly irrelevant, ultimately proves to be highly effective once learned. Indeed, racialization is deliberately made a covert, intuitive, indeed algorithmic logic, much as how it operates in the real world, and herein lies the argumentative, or “persuasive,” power of digital procedure. Whether it is the earlier forms of explicit racism seen in yellow-peril propaganda, or the appropriation and depoliticization of race under the disguise of postmodern aesthetics, or the increasingly common narratives of post-racial dystopia featured in speculative fiction, reinstantiations of Orientalism and techno-Orientalism continue to define and surveille how Asians speak, act, and exist in both fictional and real worlds. Thinking back to Said’s early concerns with Orientalism’s amorphous, self-adapting nature over time, it is imperative that we pay close attention to the rapidly evolving expressions of global media and continue to identify, resist, and ultimately dismantle the various languages and spaces by which such oppressive systems of Othering exist. By examining the nuanced constructions of the subject-object binary as manifest in the Asian woman’s ornamental objecthood, this thesis has hopefully taken a step towards the critical discourse on reimagining gendered racial ontologies to promote more productive and subversive understandings of modern personhood.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.