Asian American critique of their own involvement in domestic settlerism can be the basis of conjoining global decolonization movements to domestic deimperialization—the creation of futures beyond settlerism requires the production of new knowledges that attack the stress points of global empire—
Fujikane 12
[3/7/12, Candace Fujikane, “Asian American critique and Moana Nui 2011: securing a future beyond empires, militarized capitalism and APEC”, Volume 13, Issue 2, 2012]
If one pushes even further to argue that there must be a dialectical process in any deimperialization movement, then what conditions need to be created in the United States to bring about an effective movement there? What would the concrete forms of such a movement be? What are the appropriate methodologies for making deimperialization a reality in the neoimperial center? (Kuan-Hsing Chen 2010) Our brother Attwood Makanani, a cultural practitioner and voyager, once told me, ‘You gotta haku’, and I didn't understand what he meant. ‘Haku’ is the term for braiding or composing something. And now I think I understand that Pacific peoples can take the most fragile fibers and weave them into powerful ropes to bind homes together, canoes together, and even move great objects through the forest. Let us braid our struggles together into an unbreakable cord that's much stronger than our individual parts. Let us make a net that's big enough and strong enough to restrain even the most powerful of these strange and dangerous fish that threaten to engulf us. (Kyle Kajihiro 2011) As essays in this volume of Inter-Asia Cultural Studies examine the implications of Asian American studies in Asia, I would like to open up this essay with a consideration of the fragile fictions of US imperialism in Asia and the Pacific. On October 11, 2011, US Secretary of State Hilary Clinton published an op-ed piece in Foreign Policy on the necessity of aggressive military and economic advances in the Asia-Pacific region. Entitled ‘America's Pacific Century’, Clinton's statement stakes a claim to the Pacific, opening with the conditions of war in Iraq and a repositioning of US military forces from Iraq and Afghanistan to Asia and the Pacific: As the war in Iraq winds down and America begins to withdraw its forces from Afghanistan, the United States stands at a pivot point. Over the last 10 years, we have allocated immense resources to those two theaters. In the next 10 years, we need to be smart and systematic about where we invest time and energy, so that we put ourselves in the best position to sustain our leadership, secure our interests, and advance our values. One of the most important tasks of American statecraft over the next decade will therefore be to lock in a substantially increased investment—diplomatic, economic, strategic, and otherwise—in the Asia-Pacific region. (Clinton 2011) Such a framing clearly articulates the militarized theater necessary for the performance of US economic policies. It is in the rhetoric of militarized capitalism that we see the nineteenth-century logic of US imperialism: gunboat diplomacy that forced open markets in Asia and the Pacific continues today as Aegis warships enforce free trade. In this way, Clinton's declaration prepared the ground for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum of 21 nations in the Asia and Pacific regions hosted by the United States in Honolulu, Hawai‘i, in November 2011. APEC's ostensible mission is ‘championing free and open trade and investments’, but as critics like Walden Bello have argued, APEC is being used by the United States to pull itself out of financial crisis, particularly in furthering the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), formed in reaction to the ASEAN-China Free Trade Area (ACFTA) that went into effect in 2010 (Bello 2011). The TPP countries include the United States, Australia, Brunei, Chile, Malaysia, New Zealand, Peru and Singapore with Japan, Indonesia, Russia and others as potential members. As Bello (2011) explains, the TPP is viewed as a ‘WTO-plus’ because it is even more stringent in its free trade rules than the World Trade Organization (WTO): The objective of the original agreement was to reduce all trade tariffs to zero by the year 2015. It now aims to be a comprehensive agreement covering all the main pillars of a free trade agreement, including trade in goods, rules of origin, trade remedies, sanitary and phytosanitary standards, technical barriers to trade, trade in services, intellectual property, government procurement, and competition policy. As critics agree, APEC's representation of transnational interests has led to the deregulation of Asian and Pacific economies that makes possible the exploitation of human and environmental resources with devastating effects for indigenous peoples, farming and fishing communities, workers, women and poverty-stricken people in Asia and the Pacific. As the APEC leaders met at the Hawai‘i Convention Center, an alternative conference was held by Pua Mohala i ka Pō and the International Forum on Globalization (IFG). The Moana Nui 2011 (Peoples of the Asia/Pacific vs. APEC/TPP) conference brought together activists from Hawai‘i, Rapanui, the Philippines, Guåhan/Guam, Okinawa, Aotearoa/New Zealand, the Marshall Islands, Palau, Tonga, Fiji, Micronesia, Australia, Sāmoa, Siberia, Vanuatu, Malaysia, South Korea, Japan and the United States. Invited speakers included Native economists, farming and fishing practitioners, advocates for political and economic sovereignty, globalization experts, experts on the global land grab, specialists in media, public education, environmental studies and law, and anti-bases movement activists. In their description of the event, the coordinators of Moana Nui sent out a call to the peoples of Asia and the Pacific to articulate their own self-determining visions of a sustainable economic and political future: Moana Nui is intended to provide a voice and possible direction for the economies of Pacific Islands in the era of powerful transnational corporations, global industrial expansion and global climate change. This conference will issue a challenge to Pacific Island nations and communities to look for cooperative ways to strengthen subsistence and to protect cultural properties and natural resources. The timing of this conference is intended to overlap the next meeting of the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) in Honolulu and hopes to call public attention to the critical importance of maintaining sound and productive local economies in the Pacific Islands both for their own sake and food security in the world. (Moana Nui 2011a) Against the fictions of free trade, the most powerful note of consensus at the conference was that traditional cultural practices that sustained indigenous peoples for millennia are the most sustainable. These international gatherings enable us to protect and promote those practices by piecing together our local analyses for a clearer picture of the global operations of interlinking forms of imperialisms, colonialisms, corporate capitalisms and militarisms. As anti-APEC and Moana Nui organizing and demonstrations illustrated the fragile fictions of empires, it is the cumulative effect of these deimperializing moments that is restructuring a future beyond empires. The magnitude of this imperial, militarized capitalism is rendered as a global map of stress points that cannot bear its inhumane burdens. Interlinked popular movements and their production of knowledge, then, become like bursts of runaway voltage striking at these stress points. Visions of the future hinge upon the ideological wars over the production of knowledge, and these insights into the vulnerabilities of empires enable us to chart emergent formations and to map new directions for Asian American critical praxis. As I contend in this essay, the seemingly unassailable architecture of US empire is under erosion from both within and without. Although Asian American studies as a discipline was born out of the civil rights movement and criticisms of imperialist wars being fought in Asia, Africa and South America, Asian Americans later turned to delineating the institutional parameters of Asian American studies, focusing on domestic issues of racism in the United States and the ‘claiming of America’. It was in the 1990s that theorists in postcolonial studies and Third World feminist studies raised questions about the artificial boundaries that were being drawn in examinations of Asian American texts. Later work on the continuities between Asian American studies and the imperial and colonial contexts of Asia was inspired by writers who traversed international boundaries, including Chandra Mohanty (1988), Trinh T. Minh-Ha (1989), E. San Juan, Jr. (1991a, 1991b, 1991c), Oscar Campomanes (1992, 1995), Chungmoo Choi (1993), Lisa Lowe (1991, 1993), and Inderpal Grewal (1994). Most recently, texts such as Setsu Shigematsu and Keith Camacho's (2010) edited collection Militarized Currents: Toward a Decolonized Future in Asia and the Pacific have worked to connect the histories of Japanese and US empires across Asia and the Pacific. On another register, an emergent form of Asian American critique challenges the presence of the United States within its imagined borders. The etymological narrative that the United States is ‘home’ to Asian American studies is being critically re-examined in analyses of settler colonialism and the US settler state's assault on indigenous peoples, their land, and their state sovereignty. In the fall of 2000, Jonathan Okamura and I co-edited a special issue of UCLA's Amerasia Journal entitled ‘Whose vision? Asian settler colonialism in Hawai‘i’ (Fujikane and Okamura 2000), followed by an expanded collection, Asian Settler Colonialism: From Local Governance to the Habits of Everyday Life in Hawai‘i (Fujikane and Okamura 2008). Kanaka ‘Ōiwi scholars Haunani-Kay Trask, Mililani Trask, Momiala Kamahele, ku‘ualoha ho‘omanawanui, and Healani Sonoda foreground the genocidal operations of the US settler state and raise critical questions for Asian Americans about their status as settlers on indigenous lands.1 As a fourth-generation Japanese American settler in Hawai‘i and co-editor of the collection, I describe Asian settler colonialism as a constellation of the colonial ideologies and practices of Asian American settlers who are part of the broader structure of the US settler state (Fujikane 2008: 6).2 Asian settler colonialism refers to the present participation of all Asian Americans in Hawai‘i in US settler colonialism through different kinds of settler practices, ranging from colonial administration to the routines of everyday life. Asian American settler contributors to those volumes illuminate aspects of Asian settler colonialism from different fields and disciplines to illustrate its diverse operations and material impact on Kānaka ‘Ōiwi. As those of us who have critiqued Asian American settler colonialism have argued, an understanding of our positions as settlers in Hawai‘i and in the United States has become critical to reconceptualizing Asian American critique. As in poststructuralist work, the critique of Asian American settler colonialism asks us to enter into a more self-reflexive inquiry about our positions both in relation to the US settler state and to indigenous peoples. Far from an essentializing move, the critique of Asian American settler colonialism invites us to investigate the complex ways that Asian Americans are implicated in the settler colonial policies of the United States and to delineate the kind of anticolonial and anti-imperial work that must be done. The international workshop on ‘Asian American Studies in Asia’ became a critical site of inquiry for me in articulating the continuities between a critique of Asian American settler colonialism and deimperialization in Asia. In thinking about these questions, I was particularly struck by the kinds of critical analyses Kuan-Hsing Chen makes in his call for a deimperialization of both Asia and the United States. As Chen argues, the study of Asia as method alerts us to the possibilities of reorienting Asian American critique by using Asia as a reference point, moving beyond the imperial centers and imagining and engaging in post-imperial practices inspired by different geopolitical sites. As Chen writes, The implication of Asia as method is that using Asia as an imaginary anchoring point can allow societies in Asia to become one another's reference points, so that the understanding of the self can be transformed, and subjectivity rebuilt. Pushing the project one step further, it becomes possible to imagine that historical experiences and practices in Asia can be developed as an alternative horizon, perspective, or method for posing a different set of questions about world history. (Chen 2010: xv) In the quotation I take as my first epigraph, Chen also asks what methodologies can make deimperialization a reality in the neoimperial center. The question is derived from his concern that ‘the collapse of the empire does not mean the collapse of the former colonizing population's imperial consciousness’, and he cites Mutō Ichiyō's argument that critical intellectuals must assume the responsibilities for being accomplices to the crimes committed by the imperial state (Chen 2010: 206). Only in this way can deimperialization occur. I would argue that a critique of Asian American settler colonialism constitutes one such methodology that mobilizes a mode of self-reflexive inquiry in Asian American critique and conjoins it to a decolonizing and deimperializing movement in Asia and the United States. It is a methodology that calls upon us to re-examine the settler colonial underpinnings of Asian American narratives and praxis, underscoring the need for Asian American settlers to challenge settler colonialism in their own communities as well as in the larger US settler state. It is in tracing the production of settler colonial knowledges that we can expose the operations by which Asian American settlers have participated in obscuring the conditions of US occupation, colonialism, and imperialism. Only by achieving justice for Kānaka ‘Ōiwi and for American Indians can we as Asian American settlers liberate ourselves from our positions as agents in a settler colonial system of violence. It is in this work that I see a critique of Asian American settler colonialism broadening out in shared affinities with the project of deimperializing Asia. This now brings me to a key argument about Asian American studies in Asia: Asian American critique must engage in Asia and the Pacific as method, to borrow and extend Chen's argument, which means reorienting ourselves in more expansive ways toward Asia and the Pacific in order to work toward a decolonized, deimperialized future. This is not to say that we must abandon our own important local or national analyses of racism, heteropatriarchy, class struggle, or the relationships between indigenous peoples and settlers, or the transnational flows of people and resources among global sites. Instead, we can expand our work simultaneously in these different arenas and bring those critical analyses together
to show how globalization has an impact on Asian American critique and also that the Asian American critique can be part of a decolonizing and deimperializing force in Asia and the Pacific.