Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

b) Limits outweigh and turn case—rule-bounded debate is the only metric you have to fairly determine the winner, which is a prior concern to anything else you do with the ballot. Voting for disruption for its own sake when they don’t have a broader vision for how to settle disputes achieves nothing more than trolling racists online—articulating a vision for change and defending it against reasoned disagreement from a well-prepared opponent is a prerequisite to using the form of debate effectively, no matter what for.

Hansen, 17—Danish School of Media and Journalism (Ejvind, “Aporias of courage and the freedom of expression,” Philosophy & Social Criticism, October 2, 2017, dml)

We can now return to the field of public exchanges. According to Derrida, courage carries the aporia of death: we are courageous if we risk life in order to be able to live – but a life lost is not worth living. In the field of public exchanges this can be translated into: expressions are courageous if the speaker risks his or her public life – i.e. if he or she brings out views that radically challenge existing horizons of exchange. In doing so the speaker will risk losing his or her public reputation. If this is all that happens, the speaker ‘dies’ (and so does the message – ‘Isaac’) without having achieved his or her goal (a life lost is not worth living). Thus the paradox at the moral limit is that we need radical courage at the same time as courage needs to be moderated by the consideration of survival. It is not enough that we are courageous – we need to be courageous in ways that actually achieve our goals.

In a certain sense this aporia embodies a common experience that communicative exchanges are best if they carry a certain amount of disagreement between the participants (otherwise they cannot challenge each other), but without the disagreements becoming overwhelming (because then exchanges turn into quarrels – elaborated in Hansen, 2009, 2011, 2015b). When we analyse or assess actual public spheres it is thus important not only to focus upon the plurality of voices (because of our limited bandwidth of attention). Plurality needs to be supplemented with quests for radical courage that is moderated. We will return to this in sections VI and VII.

However, Derrida’s point is opposite to Aristotle’s: the mean challenge is not the right solution to the aporia. In some cases we may have to settle on some kind of mean between radicality and moderation; however, at other points compromise-communication may in itself have become part of the established normativity. In such cases courage calls for more radical expressions.

To take an example: discussions of the freedom of expressions are often summarized with the quote attributed to Voltaire: ‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it’ (actually it was written by Evelyn Beatrice Hall in Tallentyre, 1906: 199 – however, as a summary of Voltaire’s general attitude at a certain moment). Articulated as a statement in France in the 18th century it is fair to consider it as a radical moderation: to allow a public existence of unethical, dangerous or false statements was quite radical at the peak of Enlightenment cultures in which censorship was not all that uncommon. In some situations it probably still is.

At the same time, however, in other situations the quest for tolerance can itself become a public dogma used to de-legitimize or at least reduce voices of critique. Hardt and Negri have argued that power-holders in modern societies increasingly use the ability of cultures to contain critique as a mechanism to fortify the existing power structures (Hardt and Negri, 2000: ch. 2.4; Hardt and Negri, 2009: ch. 2.3). So, even though the saying attributed to Voltaire at first sight makes room for disagreement and critique, in a second step it actually also reduces the relevance of the other: ‘I disagree with you, but I don’t have to respond to your critique, because our culture is strong enough to be able to carry and contain differences.’

Furthermore, it may be argued that certain interpretations of the quest for tolerance, on the other hand, leave room open for recent public developments of ‘post-truth’ and ‘fake news’ (which means the use of expressions with very vague, alternative or even false references to truth claims are used to de-rail public discussions) because they need to be tolerated too. In Hansen (2015a) I thus argue that it is important that public expressions too are evaluated as to their commitment to some shareable account of truth.

To summarize: even though we grant that the Voltaire/Hall statement in a previous historical situation was an important radical challenge (if we cannot reach an agreement, then we must settle on agreeing to disagree) tolerance in historical situations coming after it and influenced by it may become a way to escape challenges put forward in the public sphere by shifting the focus to the issue of tolerance instead of the content of the disagreement. The saying embodies a compromise – but a compromise that should itself continuously be challenged by new radical challenges in order not to lose its public relevance.

VI

Derrida’s voice in the previous section certainly embodies a disruptive impulse in public cultures. In his reading, the aporia of courage calls for continuous challenges of existing structures. He is, however, on the other hand quite aware that this impulse leads to both responsibility and irresponsibility (cf. the quote above), and according to the deconstructive approach no destruction is possible without a construction. Justice is not possible without the laws and norms of right; challenges to existing rules and norms are not courageous in themselves. In the public spheres there are numerous examples of expressions that challenge prevailing norms and rules, trolls that obstruct ongoing communicative expressions without necessarily being courageous. We will in this section seek to explain the moral status of the notion of courage by looking at two ways courage can be said to operate in the public spheres. On the one hand, the mere challenge is not enough to establish the courageousness of the interlocutor. Second, the aims or goals of the acts are constituent of the degree to which a gesture is courageous.

In order to see that the mere challenge is not enough for an act to be courageous we can think of the recent emergence of trolls in Internet communication (Hardaker, 2010; Binns, 2012). Trolls specialize in disruptive and non-constructive interferences in discussions through expressions of outrageous views. Their practices should not, however, be called courageous because they do not actually risk any reputational capital (at least to the extent that the anonymity measures are effective).

Second, however, the notion of courage, as Aristotle noticed, is more than mere challenge and the risking of life – the notion of courage also carries an implication of fighting for something. Aristotle distinguished foolhardiness from courage. For instance, to go to war unarmed against an armed enemy is foolhardy. There are many instances where lack of preparation or foresight, or emotional acting out, vitiate the bravery of the action.

In order for a practice to be courageous there needs to be some kind of goal, and, furthermore, some kind of connection between the goal and the practice. This is admittedly still pretty vague. Insofar as we define courage as a challenging practice in which we risk our lives in order to reasonably further some kind of goal, we have reached a definition with elements (‘risk’, ‘lives’, ‘reasonably’ ‘further’, ‘some kind of goal’) that are very open to differing views.

On the one hand, this is certainly as it has to be. If we are to articulate a positive supplement to the negative definitions of the freedom of expression, it must be very open, because it should be open to the improvisational and disruptive impulses of courage. As soon as we start to define the goals and the ways of reaching them too strictly, these very definitions might themselves become objects of challenge through the aporias of courage.

On the other hand, even though the positive freedom we are seeking to instantiate is open to differing views, this does not mean that we might as well do without it – especially not when we are talking about communicative expressions. It draws on the intuition that life at the outset is the prime value, and if you risk your life you are thus expected to be able to say something about why this sacrifice is necessary. The agent who risks her or his life always has the burden of proof.

Certainly, what is taken to be necessary may vary almost endlessly. That cannot be determined in advance, once and for all. But an agent who risks her or his life without being able to give some account of why, is foolhardy – and the chances that she or he in some sense will be taken seriously is minimal.

With this last move, we are, as premised above, closing in on a deliberative approach (as articulated in Cohen, 1989, 1997; Habermas, 1981, 1992, 1996; Rawls, 1999[1971]), something that may seem surprising given the French inspiration of the previous sections. Knowing Habermas’ hostility towards the anti-rational impulses in these positions (Habermas, 1985) on the one hand, and Derrida’s hesitation on linguistic generality (cf. the previous sections) on the other hand, this calls for some comments.

We are not going to claim that the Habermasian and Derridean approaches could be reconciled. In previous writings we have, however, argued that Habermas’ deliberative approach and the world-disclosing approaches (in this article: Foucault and Derrida) articulate two different (and to some extent opposing) impulses in our social, political and communicative practices: the impulses of systematicity (attempting to bring together seemingly disparate phenomena) and the quest for adequacy (attempting to understand phenomena in their entire diversity) (e.g. in Hansen, 2005a, 2005b, 2013).

As shown above, Derrida’s deconstructive approach can certainly be seen as an attempt to reveal the necessary gaps and aporias embodied in the generalizing aspects in argumentative deliberation. At the same time, however, the findings of his analyses do not lead to a refusal of the generalizing approaches as such:

The undecidable is not merely the oscillation or the tension between two decisions; it is the experience of that which, though heterogeneous, foreign to the order of the calculable and the rule, is still obliged – it is of obligation that we must speak – to give itself up to the impossible decision, while taking account of law and rules. (Derrida, 1994: 539; emphases added)

Even though Derrida in the above quote is reflecting upon the undecidable and the moment of freedom he still acknowledges that the resulting decision needs to take account of laws and rules. Derrida is very clear that true decisions are not determined by existing rules and laws, but at the same time, however, neither are they entirely independent of rules and laws.

Habermas and Derrida certainly disagree in their analyses of how rules and laws are (should be) established – Derrida focusing on emergence through continuous challenges, Habermas focusing on the deliberative and argumentative trying to overcome mutual disagreements. Habermas’ account has its limits when it comes to articulating reasonable resentments towards existing discursive structures (this is an often raised criticism of Habermas’ approach – see, for example, in Thomassen, 2007), Derrida’s approach is lacking in reflections on the forces or mechanisms that bring back new accounts of the general: how and why do new rules, laws and accounts of courage come about?

Both positions are (if not in their full articulations then at least in their founding intuitions) in fact right. In order for deconstruction not to become merely destructive, we need to understand how reason in communication plays the role of helping agents to reach reasonably towards each other. Otherwise public discussions will tend to dissolve into an infinite ocean of unconnected conversations; any point of view will appear as equally valid; any decision will be prevented by the persistent possibility of raising counter-voices by minority groups. Deliberation is the responsibility of trying to reach common understandings in spite of initial disagreements. This is where Habermas is right. On the other hand, in order for such reasonable accounts not to freeze into dogma, we need (courageous) challenges of the very accounts of reasonability. This is where world-disclosing approaches as suggested by Foucault and Derrida are at their strongest.

However, having seen that every human practice is embedded in aporetic paradoxes, it should not come as a surprise that even reason is aporetically structured: seeking deliberative consensus is a legitimate aim only insofar as the exchanged arguments seek to include courageous challenges (possible disturbances of consensus) of the discursive horizons, just as we have seen that notions of courage make sense only through some deliberative reflections of our means and goals.

VII

The quest for a reasonable account of the necessity of change does not imply that (1) an act without such accounts is by itself illegitimate – sometimes we do things without any reason or clear ideas of what we try to accomplish that turn out to be of value nevertheless. But in public exchanges where we want to affect others, the others should in some way come to understand why change is necessary.

Neither do we want to imply that (2) changes may never come about without agents being able themselves to give an account of why this is necessary. Quite often actions and events are conceived in ways that the initiators did not foresee.

What we are trying to argue here is thus not that the suggested reflections on positive freedom of expression should replace prevailing accounts of negative freedom. It may be argued that a freedom of expression that is only thought through negative accounts of freedom is problematic, but that is quite another argument and it is not implied by the above reflections. The reflections merely suggest that in evaluations of actual public spheres it is inadequate merely to consider the plurality of voices (as suggested in the negatively conceived accounts of the freedom of expression).

This is where we suggest turning our attention towards notions of courage. If our bandwidth of attention is limited, it is important that we in our engagements in the public spheres are not overwhelmed by insignificant utterances that merely affirm existing states of affairs. For public deliberation to become democratically fruitful it is important that we are attentive to courageously challenging statements; challenges that are, certainly, made comprehensible to us by the speakers’ attempts to convince us of the underlying goals and means.

Certainly, if these reflections are to gain any real relevance they will need to be further articulated, and in such articulations it will be necessary to substantiate notions of ‘life’, ‘reasonably’, ‘some kind of goal’, etc. And these substantiations might narrow the plurality of voices heard in the public.

As demonstrated in the previous sections the alternative to doing this is, however, not to make every voice visible in the public spheres. Even though they may exist in the public sphere, it is not certain that the limited bandwidth of attention leaves room for their actually being heard by any critical mass.

Insofar as we consider the public spheres not merely as spheres in which voices should be uttered but also as spheres in which voices should be heard, we need some way to select out those voices from the chorus that are significant in relation to some given context. Unlimited plurality is not an option. The question thus becomes how plurality should be limited. Should plurality be limited according to explicitly articulated rules and norms, rules and norms that can, due to their explicit articulations, themselves become subjects of dispute? Or should plurality be limited according to unconscious power structures, the rules of the strongest?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.