Statistically proven to be meaningless.
Caliskan & Cramers 18 – Murat Caliskan, international relations PhD Candidate at Universite Catholique de Louvain and Senior Research Fellow at Beyond the Horizon International Strategic Studies, retired in 2016 after serving more than 20 years in the Turkish Army as a military officer, & Paul Alexander Cramers, international security and defence Master student at Institut Libre d’Etude des Relations Internationales [What Do You Mean by “Hybrid Warfare”? A Content Analysis on the Media Coverage of Hybrid Warfare Concept, Horizon Insights, https://www.academia.edu/38008898/What_Do_You_Mean_by_Hybrid_Warfare_A_Content_Analysis_on_the_Media_Coverage_of_Hybrid_Warfare_Concept]//BPS
The results show that in only 20 (30%) media items, the term “hybrid warfare” is used correctly and in accordance with its true definition. In other items, when the authors used the term “hybrid warfare”, they were implying other types of warfare such as “information warfare” in 18 (27%) items, “political warfare” in 14 (21%) items, “unconventional warfare” in 5 (6%) items. The results clearly demonstrate that hybrid warfare is an ambiguous concept and is not clearly understood by different stakeholders in defense community. In other words, there is not an agreed definition or understanding. Most of the time (70%), the authors imply another concept when they use hybrid warfare.10 These results suggest two potential reasons for the miscommunication. It is either because the authors have insufficient knowledge on military concepts or the concept is too weak ambiguous to explain current events that the authors imply different meanings. We believe that both options are valid. For instance, hybrid warfare is confused with political warfare in 14 media items, which is understandable as there is a similarity between two terms. Although it is author’s responsibility to know the difference between two terms, big part of the problem stems from the broadness of the term. Hybrid concept has such an inclusive definition that it allows authors to label any conflict as hybrid warfare even when the conflict in question includes only some part of the all characteristics. However, mistaking hybrid warfare for information warfare is a clear indication of the authors’ lack of knowledge on military concepts as there is a clear difference between two terms. Table 3- The Results of “author”, “media type” and “country” categories As it is shown in Table-3, there is no meaningful difference between academics and journalists in their capacity to use the term in its proper meaning. In both groups, only 29% of the population uses the term correctly, which is very close to the general average (30%). This ratio is even less in other groups, namely in experts or officials (11%-14%). Similarly, media types also do not suggest a meaningful difference in terms of correct use of the term. It is likely to infer in-depth implications if the sample size is enlarged. But current numbers do not suggest any implication. But as it stands for now, current numbers do not suggest any implication between the degree of expertise of the author and the correctness of the use of the term “hybrid warfare”.