The nuclear taboo is not durable. A first strike would let all hell break loose.
Rebecca Davis Gibbons and Keir Lieber ’19. Rebecca Davis Gibbons is an assistant professor at the University of Southern Maine and formerly a postdoctoral research fellow with the Belfer Center's Project on Managing the Atom and International Security Program. Keir A. Lieber is the GOAT. “How durable is the nuclear weapons taboo?”, Journal of Strategic Studies, 42:1, 29-54, https://doi.org/10.1080/01402390.2018.1529568 // gbs
If one of the established nuclear weapons states uses nuclear weapons, the strength of the nuclear taboo would be greatly undermined. As Mark Fitzpatrick concludes, ‘the rupture to the system would be strongest if it were committed by one of the charter members of the nuclear club’. 36 The moral norm is arguably strongest among this grouping. And nuclear use by one of these powerful states makes it less likely that there would be a strong and organized international response to the violation. The established nuclear powers all sit as permanent members of the U.N. Security Council, making costly action more complicated. Moreover, use by a nuclear weapons state, in cases other than in the darkest of circumstances when state survival is at stake, could undermine the nonproliferation regime and ultimately the durability of norm against nuclear use.