A counterforce strike would have less casualties – weakens the justification for the taboo.
Rebecca Davis Gibbons and Keir Lieber ’19. Rebecca Davis Gibbons is an assistant professor at the University of Southern Maine and formerly a postdoctoral research fellow with the Belfer Center's Project on Managing the Atom and International Security Program. Keir A. Lieber is the GOAT. “How durable is the nuclear weapons taboo?”, Journal of Strategic Studies, 42:1, 29-54, https://doi.org/10.1080/01402390.2018.1529568 // gbs
The extent of collateral damage caused by a nuclear weapon would likely play a significant role in determining the durability of a nuclear non-use norm based on moral considerations. If a nuclear detonation resulted in great destruction and many non-combatant causalities, as would likely be the case with an attack that targeted a city or generated substantial lethal nuclear fallout, one might expect that the moral underpinnings of the norm would remain intact – and perhaps even be bolstered. That is, a dramatic demonstration of the abhorrent consequences of nuclear weapons use could serve to reinforce subsequent adherence to the norm. By contrast, a nuclear attack that resulted in very few casualties – for example, as might conceivably occur with a limited counterforce strike using a few precise, low-yield weapons – would appear to weaken the normative constraint against nuclear use.30 That is, if the non-use norm were driven by revulsion at the expected massive and indiscriminate devastation that would occur if nuclear weapons were used, an instance of nuclear use that generated only modest collateral damage would undermine the norm.31