Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Deterrence against China submarines is successful—ASW forces prove

Carnegie Endowment, 18 (Carnegie endowment for International peace, 10-24-18, “US Anti-submarine Warfare and Its Impact,” https://carnegieendowment.org/2018/10/24/u.s.-anti-submarine-warfare-and-its-impact-pub-77495)

Geography lends various advantages to the United States’ and its allies’ efforts to block Chinese SSBNs from patrolling in the Pacific Ocean. The biggest roadblock is the existence of major chokepoints separating China’s coastal waters from the Pacific Ocean. Along the First Island Chain, there are only a limited number of waterways—including the Miyako Strait and the Bashi Channel (in the Luzon Strait near the Philippines)—through which Chinese SSBNs can transit. All of these waterways are adjacent to land features possessed or controlled by U.S. allies, so the passages are under close surveillance by U.S. or U.S.-friendly ASW forces.

In fact, some Japanese defense officials used to boast that Chinese submarines would not be able to slip into the Pacific through the Ryukyus, a chain of islands scattered along the north and south of Taiwan, or through the Bashi Channel without being detected by U.S. and Japanese ASW systems.1 Indeed, there have been cases when foreign countries have reportedly detected Chinese SSNs in transit. In 2004, for example, a Chinese 091-class nuclear attack submarine was reportedly detected by Japanese, Taiwanese, and U.S. ASW platforms as the submarine sailed from the Western Pacific back to China, passing through Japanese waters.2 Similarly, in January 2018, a Chinese 093-class SSN—which is believed to be considerably quieter than the 091-class SSN, and which may have a noise level similar to that of the 094-class SSBN—was reportedly detected by Japan while it was submerged near the Diaoyu/Senkaku Islands.3 Notably, Chinese SSBNs face greater geographical constraints today than Soviet SSBNs did during the Cold War. The barrier formed by Greenland, Iceland, and the UK that Soviet SSBNs needed to pass through to reach the North Atlantic Ocean is much wider than the waterways in the First Island Chain.

To compound the geographical advantages that China’s rivals enjoy, the United States and its allies have significantly augmented their sound surveillance networks in and around the Pacific in recent decades, in the face of increasing Chinese submarine activity.4 The United States even has reportedly extended its underwater hydrophone systems to the south of the Philippines to connect with islands belonging to Indonesia and, from there, north to India’s Andaman Islands.5 This all-encompassing, seamless network—known as the U.S. Navy’s Fish Hook Undersea Defense Line—has the potential to seriously undermine Chinese SSBNs’ ability to leave China’s coastal waters and sail into the Pacific or Indian Oceans.

Beyond Chinese concerns about detection, the United States could undermine the efficacy of China’s sea-based nuclear deterrent by interfering with its command, control, and communications (C3) system. Foreign analysts have long raised doubts about China’s ability to maintain reliable communication channels with SSBNs operating in distant oceans.6 Conducting long distance communications with a submerged SSBN is challenging, though Beijing has been seeking to improve in this area. Open-source research indicates that China is now capable of communicating with submarines at super low frequencies (SLF) of 30–300 hertz.7 In 2009, China reportedly completed construction on its first military SLF transmission station and conducted several tests. One year later, a Chinese nuclear submarine successfully received messages from the SLF transmission station, as China became the third country in the world to establish a comparable submarine communications system.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.