Best scientific models concluded even worst-case scenarios do not produce anything close to a nuclear winter.
Jon Reisner et al 18, scientist at Los Alamos National Laboratory, with Gennaro D'Angelo, Eunmo Koo, Wesley Even, Matthew Hecht, Elizabeth Hunke, Darin Comeau, Randall Bos, James Cooley, February 13, 2018, “Climate Impact of a Regional Nuclear Weapons Exchange: An Improved Assessment Based On Detailed Source Calculations,” JGR Atmospheres Volume 123, Issue 5, https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/2017JD027331
There have recently been new simulations of a limited nuclear exchange in the India-Pakistan region using modern climate models (e.g., Mills et al., 2014; Stenke et al., 2013) that suggest devastating impacts on climate over a decadal time scale, although somewhat less extreme consequences have also been suggested (Pausata et al., 2016). Our team has taken a careful look at some of the assumptions that were used in those studies, using an end-to-end modeling sequence. Our series of simulations started with a nuclear weapon explosion followed by a simulation of the fireball and cloud rise. The key improvement in this study is our simulation of fire spread and soot transport in the environment that results from fires initiated by the fireball.
Due to the heat of the fire and of the BC particles that are produced, some of the particles are lofted into the stratosphere. However, our comprehensive urban fire simulations indicate that the bulk of the carbon mass remains in the troposphere, where it is quickly removed from the atmosphere. In most previous work, for example, that of Stenke et al. (2013) and Mills et al. (2014), all of the soot produced by the urban fires is directly injected near the top of the troposphere, and therefore much of it rises into the stratosphere, where it shades and cools the Earth. In contrast, if we use a realistic vertical profile for the BC aerosols as input to the climate model, the long-term global impacts on climate are much less severe than predicted by previous studies. This was true even with conservative, worst case assumptions regarding BC production.
To assess the significance of differences between a limited nuclear exchange scenario and the control climate, we created an ensemble of forced (BC-loaded) simulations using a range of realistic vertical emission profiles, all consistent with our detailed fire simulation. A similar ensemble generated using small atmospheric temperature perturbations allows a robust statistical comparison of our simulated results with and without the carbon forcing. This analysis demonstrates that while modest, statistically significant differences occur during the first few years, longer-term impacts are unlikely, regional in scope, and limited in scale. None of the simulations produced a nuclear winter effect.
We also completed a thorough nuclear weapon simulation, determining that it was not necessary for this study and that the impact on climate of the fireball and cloud rise is negligible. There are other, worse effects than those on climate, however, such as nuclear fallout in the region. Such consequences will be the focus of our future work using both xRage and HIGRAD-FIRETEC. Likewise, we will conduct a more comprehensive investigation of regional effects, such as potential consequences for the Asian monsoon during the first few years after the nuclear exchange in follow-on work. Additionally, although this study examines a possible exchange between India and Pakistan via the injection of soot over this region, our modeling system could be used to examine potential impacts of other regional exchange scenarios.
Acknowledgments
This work was done under the auspices of the National Nuclear Security Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy at Los Alamos National Laboratory under contract DE-AC52-06NA25396. The CESM project is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Office of Science, Biological and Environmental Research of the U.S. Department of Energy. Computing resources were provided by the High-Performance Computing Division and Institutional Computing at LANL as well as by the U.S. Department of Defense. Special thanks go to members of a LANL computing committee that enabled a special queue for calculation of the CESM ensemble members. Data for the figures produced by CESM as well as the CESM code and input decks can be moved to the Earth System Grid and accessed via that platform (https://www.earthsystemgrid.org/); xRage and HIGRAD-FIRETEC are export controlled models, and input decks and data can be requested via LANL's Richard P. Feynman Center for Innovation (feynmancenter@lanl.gov).