Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is the process of de-securitization.

Wilhelmsen 2017 (Julie Wilhelmsen, Senior fellow at the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs, “How does war become a legitimate undertaking? Re-engaging the post-structuralist foundation of securitization theory”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/48512937) //sethlee

Moreover, alternative articulations of the Self/Other boundary which attach a lower level of threat to the Other can emerge and render emergency measures illegitimate. This would be a process of de-securitization. A first step towards such a re-interpretation would be to substitute Austinian speech act with post-structuralist discourse as the core concept in the theory. Discourse, not Austinian speech act: According to Copenhagen School ST, threats and security are determined through the speech act. Understood as a speech act, ‘security’ means that the very identification, the articulation of words that describe something as a security threat, is an act (Wæver, 1995b: 55). The weight given to words in this explication seems to match post-structuralists’ foregrounding of language, but it is still not useful to theorize securitization as a speech act. It is an impossible attempt at reconciling relationalism with actor-centric understandings of social change. The initial focus on actors implicit in Copenhagen School ST is amplified with the adoption of speech act in the Austinian ‘once said, then done’ way. Not only is the securitizing actor projected as the driving force in the process, but also his words are accorded status as final and decisive. Thus, the audience is certainly not significant and the intersubjective process is lost (for a similar critique see Balzacq, 2005: 182–183; Stritzel, 2014: 20–24; Taureck, 2006: 52– 61). By adhering firmly to relationalism and placing agency not in an actor, but in the discursive practices that comprise a securitization, a post-structuralist approach offers a less contradictory theoretical framework and one that gives priority to intersubjectivity. Discourses are seen as structures of signification which construct social realities. The understanding of significative construction which informs most post-structuralist work is taken from the structuralist linguistics of Ferdinand de Saussure (1974). He held that language is not determined by the reality to which it refers – it should be understood as a system of signs, with the meaning of each sign determined by its relation to other signs. A sign is thus part of a structure together with other signs that it differs from, and it gains its specific value precisely from being different from other signs. The assumption, prevalent in most post-structuralist international relations (IR) work, that discourses are structured largely in terms of binary oppositions draws on the work of Jacques Derrida. According to Derrida (1981), language is a system of differential signs and meaning is established not by the essence of a thing itself but through a series of juxtapositions, where one element is valued over its opposite. Binary oppositions are not neutral, they establish a relation of power such that one element in the binary is privileged. Discourses are seen as made in a process of social practical interaction and are always textually interconnected; as such, they are a set of collectively articulated codes and are intersubjectively embedded at the outset. Moreover, they are continuously conditioned by intersubjectivity – because, despite being highly structured, they are seen not as stable grids, but as open-ended, changeable and historically contingent (Milliken, 1999: 230). This aspect of discourse implies that there is a play of practice, or struggles over which discourses should prevail. Some fixations of meaning become so conventionalized that we think of them as natural. Other fixations are always possible, but may become temporarily excluded by these hegemonic discourses (Laclau and Mouffe, 1985). The first argument for replacing Austinian ‘speech act’ with post-structuralist ‘discourse’ is, therefore, that it enables us to move from a self-contained and definite core concept in the theory to an inherently intersubjective and process-oriented concept. But also, if we consider what a securitization would look like in the empirical world, a more reasonable understanding would be that a ‘securitizing attempt’ consists of a series of utterances. Nothing can be constituted as an existential threat on a political arena through a ‘speech act’ in the ‘once said, then done’ sense. As Butler (1993) points out, the power of speech acts (not to be confused with Austinian illocutionary speech acts) lie in their iterability; that is, they can be cited, recited and changed through such citation. It is only through iterability that utterances have transformative potential.9 This makes it more appropriate to explicate ‘securitizing moves’ as the onset or strengthening of a discourse that constructs something as an existential threat. Finally, as regards the application of securitization to understand how war becomes acceptable, a discursive approach simply seems to have greater explicatory clout. The Second Chechen War and the acceptance of this violent undertaking in the wider Russian public cannot be thought of as a single authoritative act: it is better grasped as an evolving intersubjective process. The purpose of an enquiry informed by post-structuralist ST is to study how this intersubjective process of securitization unfolds.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.