Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Inertia DA – countering securitizing discourse via debates usurps hegemonic narratives.

Jessica M Williams ’20 [Post-doctoral fellow at the Centre for Civil Society and Governance, Faculty of Social Science, The University of Hong Kong. LLB in Law from the University of Exeter, Master of Science (International Relations) from Cardiff University, Ph.D. in Social Sciences from the University of Hong Kong.; “Discourse inertia and the governance of transboundary rivers in Asia”; March 2020; Volume 3; Earth System Governance; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esg.2019.100041; Accessed 7/19/21]

In the present paper elements of institutional theory, policy networks and analytical governance are used to complement discourse theory. This leads us to propose the conceptualisation of discourse inertia. In terms of discourse, inertia is considered to represent the persistent promotion and dominance of a perception of reality. This leads to the continuous reproduction of certain storylines and elements of a discourse. Sanctioned discourses, often ones that are institutionalised, are thought more likely to achieve or display inertia due to the involvement of path dependent tendencies and powerful entrenched interests.

Discourse is considered to be dynamic, even where discourse inertia is present, as discourses must constantly be represented and reinforced. Once an actor's, or a group's, discourse becomes dominant, it is fiercely defended. Subsequently, dominant discourses are constantly reinforced and embedded. This can lead to certain narratives becoming entrenched within both institutions and political and social practices, thus reaching an ideational status. These privileged narratives become taken for granted and self-reinforcing, making them prone to discourse inertia. More shallow narratives can function over privileged narratives to achieve an interest or align with an outside commitment. These narratives are more fluid and flexible and are, therefore, easily manipulated.

The concept of discourse inertia reflects how a discourse may persist and resist pressures for change. It contributes to our understanding discourse dynamics, dissonance and governance. Discourse inertia may aid in understanding the persistence of a certain policy pathway, despite evidence of its ineffectiveness or the presence of more suitable alternative approaches.

Discourse inertia is illustrated by utilising and extending Den Besten et al. (2014) ‘discursive-institutional spiral’ (Fig. 1). The discursive-institutional spiral demonstrates how discourses evolve. A spiral exists between actors, their ideas, subject areas and institutional initiatives. Moments of institutionalisation start each loop of the spiral, which then leads to discussion and debates that draw in new actors. The more actors that become involved, the more likely that new ideas and concepts will be introduced. The expansion of actors and ideas subsequently leads to institutionalisation, which narrows the discourse. Certain ideas are excluded and actors are empowered or disempowered. Institutionalisation then begins the next loop of the spiral as well as the inception of new ideas and rise of critical discourses. Power can be exercised by excluding or including actors or ideas in the discursive-institutional process (Den Besten et al., 2014).

This concept is extended through the proposal of a narrowing discursive-institutional spiral. Here, a process akin to institutional path dependency occurs within the spiral, which restricts the entry of new actors and ideas into the discourse. As a result, the evolution and expansion of the discursive-institutional spiral is limited (Fig. 2 and 3). Certain discursive elements that become institutionalised may be self-reinforcing along subsequent spirals. These elements may consistently exclude other elements and actors. This can further limit the ability of new actors to access the discourse, which reduces the introduction of alternative ideas

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.