Communities of Practice DA – uncritical acceptance of discourse embeds problematic practices that disrupt implementation.
Judith Kreuter ’21 [Research associate at the chair for International Relations, PhD thesis, Technische Universität Darmstadt; “Chapter 3: Ideas and Objects, Meaning and Causation—Frame Analysis from a Modernist Social Constructivism Perspective”; 2021; Springer; Climate Engineering as an Instance of Politicization: Talking Tomorrow’s Technology—Framing Political Choice?; Accessed 7/14/21]
Discourses play a significant role in this process of construction of meaning: “The world is not objectively accessible, but instead is imparted through language through discursive processes and symbolic interpretations” (Uther 2014: 60).2 This means that much of the meaning-construction of social reality, which the brand of social constructivism espoused here relies upon, is done through what many authors call discourse. The frames that are studied in this analysis are considered as elements in discourse. Discourse, here, is understood, following Maarten Hajer, as “an ensemble of ideas, concepts, and categories through which meaning is given to social and physical phenomena, and which is produced and reproduced through an identifiable set of practices” (Hajer 2006: 67). This captures the simultaneous constructedness and constructiveness of the social meaning of material objects: Through language and practice humans both capture the meaning material objects have, and change or reproduce this meaning. Similarly, Dryzek defines discourse as “a shared way of apprehending the world. Embedded in language, it enables those who subscribe to it to interpret bits of information and put them together into coherent stories or accounts” (Dryzek 2005: 9). This means that meaning is constructed in discourses in “supra-individual and rather unconscious” ways (Methmann et al. 2013a: 6).
At the same time, human actors, in this study, will not be considered as entities subordinate to a super-human structural power of discourse. Actors, according to Uther’s discussion, are both constructed and constructing (see Uther 2014: 55). Following her approach, actors are considered to be the central active agents in any meaning-making situation, and thus not helpless pawns in the flow of discourse: “The actor is not passively subdued to the discourse, as, for example, the subject of Foucault, but it actively participates in shaping the discourse through its own interpretive achievements” (Uther 2014: 66).3 This two-fold characterization of actors as both constructed and constructing is captured by practice theory. The terms ‘practice’ and ‘discourse’ are considered to not be antithetical to each other: Practices are “meaningful patterns of action, which, in being performed more or less competently, simultaneously embody, act out, and possibly reify background knowledge and discourse in and around the material world” (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 4). Thus, (non-linguistic) practices are understood to interact with (linguistic) discourses and in this interaction construct or deconstruct meanings. Other authors reconcile linguistic and non-linguistic elements of meaning-construction by subsuming both under the term ‘discourse’(see Anshelm and Hultman 2015: 11; Methmann et al. 2013a: 6) As Dryzek (2006: 3) argues, “discourses are a matter of practice as well as words, for actions in the social realm are always accompanied by language that establishes the meaning of action” (see also Adler 2008: 198). I assume, in line with these authors, that meaningful action—or practice—and meaningful talk—or discourse—construct or deconstruct the ideational meaning of an object. Further, I assume that practice is meaningful action which acts out certain meanings about the world, thus making it causally relevant.
Practice theory provides tools to put actors center stage as practice as meaningful action depends on the existence of an actor. Adler and Pouilot describe practice theory as an “invitation […] to conceive of the social as bundles of ideas and matter that are linguistically, materially, and intersubjectively mediated in the form of practices” (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 14). Practices as “meaningful patterns of action” (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 4) can more specifically be defined as a type of action, which, in turn, is a type of behavior. As Adler and Pouliot (2011: 5) describe: “[A]ction is behavior imbued with meaning. Running in the streets aimlessly is mere behavior, running after a thief is an action endowed with meaning.” For an action to be a practice, it needs to fulfill additional criteria: “Practices[…] are patterned actions that are embedded in particular organized contexts and, as such, are articulated into specific types of action and are socially developed through learning and training” (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 5). Accordingly, a practice is behavior endowed with meaning, “embedded in an organizational context, repeated over time and space, constituted by knowledge […], and articulated as part of a complex set of other social performances […]” (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 6). The knowledge in question is in part tacit, and it not only constitutes practices, but is also bound up in them. Adler and Pouliot call this ‘background knowledge’: “expectations, dispositions, skills, techniques, and rituals that are the basis for the constitution of practices and their boundaries” (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 17). This background knowledge “does not create uniformity of a group of community, but organize[s] their differences around pervasive understandings of reality” (Adler and Bernstein 2005: 296).
Ontologically, practice theory is understood by its proponents to provide a way out of the dichotomy of agency versus structure, or to conceptualize the two-fold characterization of actors as both constructed and constructing (see above). The agency-structure-dichotomy describes an analytical problem similar to the one of hen and egg: Should agents inside of the structure be understood to have final causal power over phenomena in the social world, or is it the structure, which was in turn constructed by agents, that finally influences what happens? For example, should developments in global climate policy be accorded to the UNFCCC (structure) or to efforts of the government of small island states (actor)? According to the structuration theory by Giddens (1984), actors and structures determine and influence each other. Practice theory can give a more detailed insight into the workings of this reciprocal constitution:
[P]ractices are both individual (agential) and structural […]. When ‘disaggregated’, practices are ultimately performed by individual human beings and thus they clearly are what human agency is about. […] Recursively, in and through practice, agents lock in structural meaning in time and space. (Adler and Pouliot 2011: 16)
Adler argues that these agents, these
‘carriers’ of social structures across functional and geographical boundaries are not necessarily states or societal networks, but ‘communities of practice’ […] – like-minded groups of practitioners who are informally as well as contextually bound by a shared interest in learning and applying a common practice. (Adler 2008: 196)
In the analysis of the discursive construction of CE, the tool of the Communities of Practice (CoP) approach is applied. The CoP approach allows for the analysis of actors which transcend national borders, such as transnationally active scholars, researchers and scientists as well as political and economic actors, all of whom can conceivably influence the social construction of CE—both of its ideational meaning and its causal materiality. The focus in this study lies on academic actors as a community of practice. It needs to be kept in mind, however, that communities of practice can be characterized as both actor and structure:
Communities of practice are intersubjective social structures that constitute the normative and epistemic ground for action, but they also are agents, made up of real people, who – working via network channels, across national or organizational lines, and in the halls of government – affect political, economic, and social events. (Adler 2008: 199)
The Epistemic Communities (EC) approach (see Haas 1992; Adler and Haas 1992), an approach “considered to be the most influential” (Beck 2015: 286) in the debate on the role of academic and other experts in global governance, can, according to Adler, be understood as the description of the role of a very specific type of community of practice (Adler 2008: 199). This approach provides the background for the explication of one of the central ontological assumptions of this study, namely that the academic discussion is particularly relevant in the construction and enactment of the legitimacy or illegitimacy of CE as measure to address climate change.
To sum up, the moderately idealist social-constructivist ontology defining the understanding of reality in this study means that specific communities of practice can—in interaction with other factors—constitute the meaning of an object and, by enacting this meaning through practice—again, in interaction with other factors— cause material change in the configuration of objects in the world. For example, a community of practice constituting the “normative and epistemic ground for action” (Adler 2008: 199) on cyber security such as the German Chaos Computer Club regularly constitutes the meanings of objects such as virtual networks or computer viruses by defining, for the former, their vulnerability to attack, and, for the latter, their threat potential. This is done, for example, in interviews or reports. The community also enacts these meanings through practice, e.g. by interacting with federal offices and agencies in order to change the material configurations in our reality according to the meanings applied to objects, e.g., changing the material basis of digital infrastructures in order to make them more resilient.
In this study, the academic community researching CE constitutes the community of practice that is most interesting as it is assumed to play a significant role in the early construction of the legitimacy or illegitimacy of CE as a measure to address climate change.4 This community constitutes the legitimacy or illegitimacy of these approaches through framing them, for example in academic publications, which present a form of practice as these publications carry the framings of CE into the public, thus enacting these framings. However, it is important to note that this framing is, in most publications, not the main intention of the respective authors: Other than epistemic communities in their original conception, the group of academics researching and discussing CE approaches is not united in a common policy endeavor. The main intention of this diverse group of actors is the publication and discussion of research results. I claim, however, that even this disinterested activity can, when it concerns a set of physical objects that remain to be materially developed, influence the legitimacy or illegitimacy of these objects—in this case, CE approaches—even if this was not the intention of the actor.