Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Argumentative discourse determines the value and outcome of policy.

Jessica M. Williams 20, Postdoctoral Research Fellow at The University of Hong Kong, 2020, “Discourse inertia and the governance of transboundary rivers in Asia,” Earth System Governance, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esg.2019.100041 [ML]

Institutional and governance approaches and theories have been widely utilised in the study of governance issues. However, it is argued that such approaches would be strengthened if greater attention is given to the ideational dimension (i.e., the ability to influence the perceptions and beliefs of others regarding specific issues (Mirumachi, 2015)). This is because discursive factors tend to be eclipsed by more formal and prominent governance and institutional perspectives. This is due to the predominance of positivist and neopositivist approaches towards international relations and political studies (Fischer, 1998; Phillips et al., 2004). Therefore, a discourse-centric approach that highlights the role of discourse and allows a focus on the interactive and dynamic processes that are determinative of policy is proposed. Discourse comprises the group of ideas, concepts and categories that are produced, reproduced and transformed in a certain nexus of practices. Social and physical relations are given meaning in this manner. Discourses are context dependent and cannot be separated from the social practices within which they are fashioned (Jӓgerskog, 2002; Mirumachi, 2015). To create material change, social agents first need to work on a discursive level by creating significant and stable meanings to the territory within which they are competing (Rear and Jones, 2013). Discourses can become sanctioned. This essentially means that they become unquestioned and dominant. With resources such as water, issues such as nationalism can become intertwined in the sanctioned discourse. As a result, decision makers may not always implement the most seemingly rational policies (Jӓgerskog, 2002). Assumptions that dominate the sanctioned discourse will act to constrain the options available to policymakers and in doing so signal policy outcomes (Dayton, 2000; Gerlak and Schmeier, 2014). Thus, changes in the sanctioned discourse can indicate changes in policy direction. However, identifying discourse change is difficult. Change can occur slowly, over a long time period, or be sudden and dramatic. What initially appears to be change may just be a continuation of a larger story or the same discourse in an alternative form. Thereby, discourse can appear to change when in reality it has co-opted elements from another discourse. Normative concepts, such as ‘sustainable development’, are particularly susceptible to being co-opted (Christoff, 2013). Exogenous events or crises that confront the sanctioned discourse can effect a change in discourse. Pressure from foreign governments or financial/donor institutions may incentivise a shift in discourse to align with a certain perspective. Actors may also intentionally try and effect change through discursive strategies. Such strategies include constructing narratives and counternarratives, exclusion strategies, as well as employing normative power and delegitimising tactics. The success and extent of change is dependent on the power, position and resources of those seeking to effect the change, and the level of change being sought (Leipold and Winkel, 2013). Discourse can be used to consider how issues reach and stay on the political agenda and become policy. Discourse can show how broader interests underlying policies are shaped into physical consequences, which then indicates policy direction. The way discourse is formulated shapes how the problem or issues around which it is constructed are framed, interpreted, discussed and analysed. Therefore, it implies the favoured solutions, how policies are to be implemented and their potential success (Crow-Miller, 2015). Policy documents also instruct what needs to be done, what stands to reason and what is unquestionable (Apthorpe and Gasper, 2014; Bacchi, 2000). Issues are not seen as political problems unless they are constructed as such by influential actors or society (Hajer, 1995). The framing of policies can immediately close off some responses while making others seem self-evident. It is also rare for a problem to be ‘solved’. Instead it can be removed from the discourse or discussed as if it were a different problem. Policies may be utilised to this effect to constrain the impact of reform initiatives (Bacchi, 2000). The argumentative approach to discourse holds that policymaking reflects competition over meaning. Therefore, policies are the result of competing interests that strategically utilise discourse and is, therefore, a social phenomenon (Taylor, 2004). Policy discourse is thus the group of ideas, concepts, frames and definitions that provide meaning to a real-world phenomenon and structure it as a policy problem (Hajer, 1995, 2006). Policy creation, change and continuation are held as an interactive process of discursive struggle between actors. Policymaking is considered the competition over meaning, with policies being the result of competing interests that employ discourse strategically (Taylor, 2004). Policy creation, change and continuation are interactive processes of discursive struggle between actors. Through argument, actors position themselves or try to impose their views on to others during negotiations (Fischer and Forester, 1993). Institutions can be mobilised and solutions sought once a problem definition is established (Hajer, 1995). Within policymaking, discourses are essential in finding settlements between conflicting interests and this assists in regulating underlying social conflicts (Taylor, 2004; Hajer, 1995). Here, discourse is concerned with redefining a social phenomenon in a manner that allows a solution to be identified (Hajer, 1995). Discourse can move policies up or down the political agenda through depoliticising or securitising moves (Zeitoun et al., 2011). Depoliticising the policy process acts to distance policy makers from the policy's impacts thereby removing responsibility for the policy's outcome. Foucault (2009) utilises the concept of ‘political technology’ to illustrate how issues that are essentially political are removed from policy discourse and reframed in neutral scientific language. The role of expert knowledge in designing institutional procedures is essential to this process (Shore and Wright, 1997). When policies become highly politicised, they become securitised and are regarded as high priority issues that constitute an issue of national interest and essential to state sovereignty. As a result, exceptional measures are, or may be, legitimised (Buzan et al., 1998; Allan and Mirumachi, 2010). The securitising actor's ability to convince the audience and elicit a certain action/reaction is decisive to the securitisation process (Mirumachi, 2015). Once a common understanding of a threat is formed between the securitising actor and the audience, securitisation is held as successful (Trombetta, 2011). The main objective of a securitising discourse is to allow potential violations of rules that would not otherwise be accepted. Threats do not have to be real or in existence for a securitising act to occur (Stritzel, 2007; Mirumachi, 2015).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.