Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Discourse and discursive acts shape reality.

Dave Elder-Vass 12, a senior lecturer in sociology at Loughborough University. He is the author of The Causal Power of Social Structures (Cambridge University Press, 2010), 2012, “The Reality of Social Construction,” Cambridge University Press, https://libgen.is/book/index.php?md5=4F125B95651CDBF9BB8A28354A03797E [ML]

For a more radical version of the claim that reality itself is socially constructed, yet one that sometimes (but not always) seems consistent with an ontological framework of common sense realism, we can turn to the work of a number of social psychologists, notably the group known as discursive psychologists. 3 Within the discipline of psychology, this approach is marked by turning its attention away from the cognitive study of individual minds, which it sees as inaccessible, towards the study of our interactions with each other. As Jonathan Potter and Margaret Wetherell put it, “for research purposes we are inevitably faced with discourse … Given the essentially performative and indexical nature of language use how can researchers construe it as a neutral record of secondary phenomena, in this case cognitive or mental states?” (1987: 145). This is a kind of sceptical empiricism that takes talk as empirically accessible but radically questions claims that talk tells us anything about what lies behind it: not only whether it tells us anything about the individual or the mind that is taken by other psychologists to have produced it, but also whether it tells us anything about what it purports to be about. From this perspective, our sense of what is real is a product of discourse or of rhetoric. According to Potter, for example, “Reality enters into human practices by way of the categories and descriptions that are part of those practices. The world is not ready categorized by God or nature in ways that we are all forced to accept. It is constituted in one way or another as people talk it, write it and argue it” (1996: 98). From a critical realist perspective, it is surprising to find these statements juxtaposed in this way. As Chapter 7 argued, for example, it seems overwhelmingly likely that there are natural kinds in the world, but this is a separate question from the question of how we categorize the things of the world; the relation between natural kinds and linguistic categories is an open one and a fallible one. Potter’s last sentence, therefore, would be entirely acceptable to realists if it said that the world was categorized as people talk it, write it, and argue it. But for a critical realist there is a logical gap between his second sentence and the argument that the world is constituted in this way. The world is already constituted, and in the case of ordinary material objects (disregarding any physical part that humans may have had in their shaping) this is independent of our talking, writing, and arguing. But from the kind of perspective adopted by writers like Potter, it seems that there is nothing we can say about how the world is, independently of our talking, writing, and arguing, so in discussing how it is constituted we can only be discussing how our accounts of it are constituted. Nevertheless, there is still a sense in here of a basic realism, a sense that although the world is not ready categorized, it is nevertheless somehow there before we constitute our accounts of it. Potter explicitly distances himself from the view that our descriptions lead to the material world “literally springing in to existence as it is talked or written about” (1996: 98) in some kind of “mystical process” (Potter 1996: 177). As Laclau and Mouffe have put it, “What is denied is not that such objects exist externally to thought, but the rather different assertion that they could constitute themselves as objects outside any discursive conditions of emergence” (1985: 108). Burr suggests that Foucault thinks in similar terms: He does not deny the materiality of events, but says that our only way of apprehending reality is through discourse, which determines our perceptions of reality. In a sense, Foucault brackets off the question of reality. Since we can never have direct access to a reality beyond discourse we cannot concern ourselves with its nature. (2003: 90) This kind of thinking has been counterposed to realism most provocatively in Edwards, Ashmore, and Potter’s well-known paper ‘Death and Furniture’, which seeks to undermine classic realist responses to radical social constructionism by analysing the rhetoric that is used in them (1995).4 The paradigm case they examine is that of the realist seeking to demonstrate the existence of material reality by thumping on a table. But such thumping, they argue, is in itself a discursive act: The very act of producing a non-represented, unconstructed external world is inevitably representational, threatening, as soon as it is produced, to turn around upon and counter the very position it is meant to demonstrate. Furniture ‘arguments’ perform categorization and relevance via semiosis. (Edwards et al. 1995: 27) Realist arguments, they are suggesting, fail to prove that there is a world beyond discourse because they are themselves discursive acts, even in the case of thumping on a table.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.