Security rhetoric shapes reality and legitimize policy actions that construct imagined threats
Wilhelmsen 2017 (Julie Wilhelmsen, Senior fellow at the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs, “How does war become a legitimate undertaking? Re-engaging the post-structuralist foundation of securitization theory”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/48512937) //sethlee
The core insight of Copenhagen School ST is that issues can become ‘securitized’ when ‘securitizing actors’, by means of rhetorical strategies, elevate them to the status of an existential threat to a referent object and when a significant audience accepts this representation of the issue (Buzan, 1997: 5–28). This process generates endorsement for emergency measures beyond rules that would otherwise bind (Wæver, 1995a). The general thrust of the argument underlying this description of the securitization process is in many respects in line with post-structuralist ideas of how policies are coconstituted by identities and rely on accounts that make sense of them and legitimize them as they are launched (Campbell, 1992; Hansen, 2006). The post-structuralist stance is that policies are not a given response to an external reality to which the state (or other social actors) relates objectively, but are co-constituted by ideas or identities. References to identities are necessary to represent and legitimize policies, but at the same time these identities are constituted and reproduced through the formulation of policies. This is why the term ‘co-constituted’ is used. When the production of politics is understood in this way the task for the analyst is to ‘embrace a logic of interpretation that acknowledges the improbability of cataloguing, calculating and specifying “real causes” and concerns itself with considering the manifest political consequences of adopting one mode of representation over another’ (Campbell, 1992: 4). Studying politics then involves studying how some representations of reality become dominant discourses, and how problems, subjects and objects are constituted in these discourses that simultaneously indicate relevant policies to pursue. The claim is not that such dominant representations cause certain policies or actions, but that they both open up and constrain the range of policies and actions that seem possible and legitimate to undertake (Hansen, 2006). This link between identity and policies can be conceptualized more explicitly as one of legitimation. Jackson (2006: 16) sees legitimation as: the process of drawing and (re)establishing boundaries, ruling some courses of action acceptable and others unacceptable. Out of the general morass of public political debate, legitimation contingently stabilizes the boundaries of acceptable action, making it possible for certain policies to be enacted. ‘The process of drawing and (re)establishing boundaries’ is here taken to be the continuous references to Self and Other that policy formulation implies and which, in turn, legitimates policy implementation. Based on this understanding of how policies are produced and legitimized, a poststructuralist approach would imply treating securitization as a process through which a representation of something as an existential threat becomes dominant at the expense of other representations and uncovering, in the course of research, the changing boundary between this identity and that given to the ‘referent object’. These changing representations would not determine emergency action, but would condition the range of emergency measures political actors could undertake legitimately. In turn, the undertaking of such emergency measures against the something that is said to be threatening and in defence of the referent object would confirm and reinforce the new identity boundaries that were drawn up and legitimize the undertaking of emergency measures. From a poststructuralist perspective the process of securitization is a fundamentally co-constitutive process and one that implies legitimizing concrete material security practices (see below). This reading suggests that securitization cannot be treated as a sequential, linear process from securitizing actor through audience acceptance and to emergency measures. Rather, it is a much more dynamic development; securitizing actors, referent object, threat objects as well as exceptional measures are co-constituted within the securitizing process.4