Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The 1AC is a theatrical performance of international relations that discursively brings the state into existence.

Erik Ringmar, 14, a professor in the Department of Political Science and International Relations at İbn Haldun Üniversitesi, Istanbul, Turkey, 2014, “Performance, Not Performativity: An Embodied Critique of Post-Structural IR Theory,” Lund University, https://lucris.lub.lu.se/ws/files/6266345/7512005.pdf [ML]

Yet performances do not only take place in theaters, but also in society at large. Social interaction is to a considerable extent a matter of presenting oneself before others on any of the many small stages constituted by daily interpersonal interaction.96 Here too we project an imaginary self, a person we would like to be, and we ask the people observing us to recognize us under this description. In the process we build sociality and inauthenticity into our being. It is easy to be disgusted with this spectacle, especially of course if the performance goes badly and we fail to receive the kind of recognition we feel we deserve. For this reason the playacting self, its antics and its fate, have often been a source of mournful laments. “Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player,” as Shakespeare's Macbeth put it, “That struts and frets his hour upon the stage.”97 And Jean-Jacques Rousseau, scathing in his criticism of the superficiality and decadence of Parisian high-society, was equally scathing of the theater which he saw as a threat to a more natural, more rural and thereby more authentic, way of life.98 Yet what Rousseau wished for is not available. Away from the many small stages of everyday life, the self, as we know it, does not exist. But performances are presented also on a larger stage as social and political events are made to happen, and to appear, in a certain manner.99 We can talk of “public performances” as staged events through which imaginary blends of social facts and visions are presented to vast audiences, perhaps to entire societies, at the same time. Through the public performance the world is cast in a certain form and held up for our contemplation; something is discovered, something is remembered or exposed.100 Examples include a terrorist attack on a building in a major city; an attempt to “shock and awe” a civilian population; the signing of a peace treaty by two former enemies; the funeral of a world leader; the diplomatic rituals shared by members of the same international system.101 But make no mistake, these are not the performative reiterations of discursive practices. Public performances are originals, not citations; they involve all the senses and engage all neurological systems, not just the literal-minded mind. The way we, as members of the audience, react to these public performances may often surprise us. We scream at a rock concert; we raise our fists at a political rally, or we speak in tongues at a religious convocation. These are physical reactions, performed by us to be sure, yet they are in a sense not ours. They may be referred to as cases of “mass hysteria,” or as examples of “conversion syndrome,” but we could also say that they are the reactions of a shared, a public, body.102 It is in this public performance and in this public body that we come across ourselves as a society. It is also here that we find the state. The state ― pace Weber, Campbell, Derrida and Butler ― is not declared into existence through the iteration of texts, but neither is it abolished through military interventions. Instead, in next to all cases, before independence could be declared it had to be fought for. People had to present themselves to themselves and to others as willing to risk their lives for the right to self-determination.103 Such struggles constitute clashes of real interests, and often of real weapons, but they are also performances in a fully theatrical sense ― involving aspirational plots, fluttering flags, arousing music, self-sacrifice, betrayal, and heroism. It was by watching these performances, and by getting involved with them themselves, that “the people” and “the state” came to be constituted as subjects of international politics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.