Discourse analysis is a prerequisite to understand the potential effectiveness of policy
Kate Anderson and Jessica Holloway, 18, PhD and Associate Professor at Arizona State University; Senior research fellow at Australian Catholic University, “Discourse analysis as a theory, method, and epistemology in studies of education policy” https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329912399_Discourse_analysis_as_theory_method_and_epistemology_in_studies_of_education_policy/ekc
Discourse analysis as a theory, method, and tool has illuminated ways that education policy is messy and dynamic. Evaluative approaches to policy analysis might be appealing to policymakers and other government officials due to their supposed promise of efficiency and accuracy. However, discourse analytic approaches offer analytic and practical complementarity via their demonstration of the complexities of policy development and the context-dependence of policy effects. As such, discourse analysis offers invaluable tools for understanding the ‘how’ and the ‘why’ of education policy (rather than just the ‘what’ or ‘whether’), especially as policy landscapes and networks are shifting to more global terrains and relationalities (Ball 2012; Rizvi and Lingard 2009).
In this article, we have argued that acknowledgement of conceptual definitions and theoretical and epistemological stances are paramount toward establishing methodological coherence that allows for the continued creative and productive uses of discourse analysis to push the field forward. Our argument follows Rabinow and Rose’s (2003) call to treat ‘indeterminacies, contingencies and difference as assets rather than as disconfirming evidence that feeds into already established logics of “science” and established logics of “justice”’ (13, as cited in Webb and Gulson 2015, 46). Therefore, our effort is not to ‘tame the wild profusion of existing things’ (Foucault 1970, xv, cited in Lather 2006, 36), but rather to illustrate the complexity of the various ways discourse analysts structure and execute their projects in order to study educational policy. It would seem that there are as many ways of doing this as there are people who do it, which is itself not problematic. However, our conclusions from the analysis of these 37 articles is that complications in terms of theoretical and analytical coherence might prevent the promise we expect from our collective and individual work. The analysis of literature presented here took years to complete and only brings us through articles published in 2014. With the proliferation of discourse analytic studies focusing on education policy in the ensuing years increasing exponentially, the field is rife for further analysis of this dynamic and evolving sub-field from 2015 onward. We hope that this initial consideration can help identify the conceptual boundaries between operationalizations of discourse and policy, epistemological assumptions informing methods and findings, and ontological stances on the purpose and promise of research. Yet, we remind readers that these categories are never fixed, and that cracks and fissures within and between them always provide potential ‘site[s] of being and becoming’ (Lather 2006, 52) to emerge.