The framing of an AI arms race is dangerous---turns the case--it creates a self-fulfilling prophecy and wrecks any safety precautions
Stephen Cave 18, Stephen holds a PhD in philosophy from Cambridge University, “An AI Race for Strategic Advantage: Rhetoric and Risks,” January 2018, AI Ethics and Society 2018, Volume 1 \\pairie
The Dangers of an AI Race for Technological Advantage: In Rhetoric and in Reality What is so bad about framing the development of AI in terms of a race for technological advantage? After all, it is widely agreed that AI brings enormous potential benefits across many sectors. One recent report estimated that it could add £232 billion by 2030 to the UK economy alone, with healthcare one of the sectors most enhanced, potentially bringing faster, better service to consumers (PwC 2017). There is a widespread belief that competition and other market forces are central to such innovation. So in as much as a race to develop AI technology means these kinds of benefit come sooner, we have reason to view it positively.
But at the same time, the development of such a potentially powerful new technology will need to be steered if it is to be as beneficial as possible while minimising the risks it might pose (Crawford and Calo 2016). In the words of the Future of Life Institute’s open letter on ‘Research Priorities for Robust and Beneficial Artificial Intelligence’, signed by over 8,000 people including many leading figures in AI, work should focus “not only on making AI more capable, but also on maximizing the societal benefit of AI.” (Future of Life Institute, 2017a). The danger of an AI race is that it makes exactly this thoughtful steering towards broadly beneficial outcomes more difficult.
Three Sets of Risks
We want to distinguish between three sets of risks:
i) The dangers of an AI ‘race for technological advantage’ framing, regardless of whether the race is seriously pursued;
ii) The dangers of an AI ‘race for technological advantage’ framing and an actual AI race for technological advantage, regardless of whether the race is won;
iii) The dangers of an AI race for technological advantage being won.
(i) Risks Posed by a Race Rhetoric Alone It is possible that the trend towards ‘race for technological advantage’ terminology in AI, including suggestions such as Vladimir Putin’s that the winner of such a race “will become the ruler of the world,” could pose risks even if the race is not pursued in earnest, let alone won. We perceive two main risks here:
(i.a) The kind of thoughtful consideration of how to achieve broadly beneficial AI, as mentioned above, will require subtle, inclusive, multi-stakeholder deliberation over a prolonged period. The rhetoric of the race for technological advantage, with its implicit or explicit threat that dire consequences will follow if some other group wins that race, is not likely to be conducive to such deliberation. Indeed, rhetoric around technological superiority (such as the ‘arms race’ rhetoric used in the Cold War in the US), played into what has been called a politics of fear, or a politics of insecurity -- that is, a political climate that discourages debate in favour of unquestioning support for a prescribed agenda (Griffith 1987). In The Politics of Insecurity, Jef Huysmans argues that use of the language of security (by which he means militarised language, which would include ‘arms race’ and related rhetoric) “is a particular technique of framing policy questions in logics of survival with a capacity to mobilize politics of fear in which social relations are structured on the basis of distrust” (Huysmans 2006).
(i.b) Second, if the rhetoric of a competitive, ‘winner takes all’ AI race is used in the absence of an actual race, it could contribute to sparking such a race.
(ii) Risks Posed by a Race Emerging
If the rhetoric of a race for technological advantage became an actual race to develop sophisticated AI, the risks increase further:
(ii.a) First, there is the risk that racing to achieve powerful AI would not be conducive to taking the proper safety precautions that such technology will require (Armstrong, Bostrom, and Shulman 2016). We mentioned above the need for broad consultation about the role AI should play in the life of a community. This might help address important considerations such as avoiding biased systems, or maximising fairness. But in addition to these goals, serious attention must also be given to ensuring humans do not lose control of systems. Such considerations become particularly important if AI approaches general intelligence or superintelligence (Bostrom 2014), but also long before, particularly when AI systems are performing critical functions. The risk is that as the perceived benefit to winning the race increases, so correspondingly does the incentive to cut corners on these safety considerations.
(ii.b) Second, a ‘race for technological advantage’ could increase the risk of competition in AI causing real conflict (overt or covert). Huysmans argues that militarised language such as this has “a specific capacity for fabricating and sustaining antagonistic relations between groups. In the case of the race for technological advantage, it encourages us to see competitors as threats or even enemies. The belief that a country intends in earnest to win an AI race, and that this would result in technological dominance, could, for example, prompt other countries to use aggression to prevent this (akin to the cyberattacks made against Iranian nuclear facilities attributed to the US and Israel) (Nakashima 2012), or motivate the targeting of key personnel (precedents -- though specific to their historical context -- might include Operation Paperclip, during which over 1,600 German scientists and engineers who had worked on military technology were taken to the US (Jacobsen 2014), or the apparently ongoing operations to encourage the defection of nuclear scientists between nations) (Golden 2017). Such scenarios would also increase the risk that a general race for technological superiority became increasingly a military AI arms race.
(iii) Risks Posed by Race Victory
The third category of risks of an AI race for technological superiority are those that would arise if a race were won. We will not explore these in detail here -- and the forms they take will anyway depend on the precise nature of the technology in question. But as an example, these risks include the concentration of power in the hands of whatever group possesses this transformative technology. If we survey the current international landscape, and consider the number of countries demonstrably willing to use force against others, as well as the speed with which political direction within a country can change, and the persistence of non-state actors such as terrorist groups, we might conclude that the number of groups we would not trust to responsibly manage an overwhelming technological advantage