Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Biotechnology is an ethnicization of security--shapes the production of knowledge and truth

Rychnovská, 16 --- (Dagmar Rychnovská- Charles University In Prague and Metropolitan University Prague, Czech Republiccorresponding Author, "Governing dual-use knowledge: From the politics of responsible science to the ethicalization of security", 8-5-2016, SAGE Journals, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0967010616658848)//mishelle

Managing the risks of techno-scientific progress is unique neither to life sciences nor to contemporary politics. However, existing concerns over a potential misuse of scientific research were given a new meaning and salience in the post-9/11 environment with the rising fears of hostile non-state actors. In comparison with that of the Cold War era, though, the current focus is less on nuclear physics or technologies related to conventional weapons and more on emerging technologies that are more accessible and thus more attractive for potential terrorists. This article has pointed out that, as part of this development, more and more attention is given to the regulation of knowledge, and it has explored how knowledge politics plays out in life sciences, where these concerns have gained great prominence. It has found that the attempts to secure potentially dangerous research and innovation are based on redefining the principles and practices of scientific responsibility and transforming an ethics-based system of governance into a technology of security, and has suggested understanding this phenomenon as an ethicalization of security. However, building a ‘culture of responsibility’ as a technology of security may raise tensions both within the scientific field and between scientists and society and breed a ‘culture of insecurity’. The prevailing all-embracing approach to the security governance of science does not help in this regard either. Instead of providing better understanding of the ‘threatening’ issues at stake, along with their contextualization and prioritization, it shifts the attention to action – that is, how to effectively ‘secure’ science. This further reinforces the role of apparently apolitical expert decisionmaking processes and downplays debates on how relevant these issues are, who shall decide on them, on behalf of whom, and how. Especially in undemocratic settings, the introduction of similarly motivated policies may be prone to the misuse of power in academia and have unforeseen consequences (see Schiermeier, 2015). The implications of ethicalization for the ontology of science will be explored in further research. For science as a cognitive domain, ethicalization may lead to changing the criteria for the validity of knowledge – that is, the norms and practices defining how scientists observe the world, produce truth claims about its functioning and reflect on the process of knowledge production. By shaping the meaning of scientific progress and tying it more closely to the neoliberal risk–benefit framework, ethicalization is also related to shifting the attention to ‘desired’ objects and methods of research while downplaying others. As such, it may contribute to constructing new scientific taboos narrowly defined by material rather than social factors. However, the question is not only how ethicalization shapes the ‘production of knowledge and truth’ in science, but also what status this knowledge is to have under the new social contract for science. This raises further questions: How does the turn to state-imposed self-regulatory modes of governance affect the role of science in society as well as the functioning of the academic field? How does it affect the practices of security expertise and the prospects of politicizing and potentially resisting security? And how does the dynamic of ethicalization vary across different disciplinary fields and (political) contexts? To move beyond the simplistic understanding of scientific knowledge as a double-edged sword, it is important not only to better understand the functioning of science, but also to reflect on the interplay among science, politics and security in which the current concerns over dual-use research are situated. More critical engagement with this topic can not only move the debate on dual-use research, but also provide new inspiration for the social scientific research on security.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.