US securitization of terror causes state follow-on AND excessive use of violence – Bush administration proves
Ellen Edman 19, Evaluator in civil preparedness at MSB (Swedish Civil Contingencies Agency), B.S. at Lund University, 2019, “Can securitization be just? A case study of the U.S securitization of bioterrorism post 9/11”, Lund University, https://www.lunduniversity.lu.se/lup/publication/8977756\\iris
Critique has been directed towards the U.S after the consequences of the global War on Terror have been unveiled. The security policy of the Bush administration has been described as a deeply illiberal means, for achieving liberal ends (Singh, 2014: 117). The security measures described in the previous section will be discussed with regards to how harmful they were to the referent object, bystanders and the aggressor.
The consequences of the securitization will be compared to the imminent risk of a bioterrorist attack. As mentioned before, 50 kg of anthrax could kill 250.000 people in an urban city. Human extinction is not very likely as a consequence of bioterrorism, especially not with anthrax since it is not contagious. However, it has been estimated that it would not be difficult to smuggle five bags of anthrax, containing 50 kg each, into the U.S. If five bags were to be efficiently dispersed in five major cities, the casualties could amount to over a million. Such a coordinated attack would completely overwhelm the U.S medical system. This is the threat the U.S was dealing with and acted to prevent (Millett & Snyder-Beattie, 2017: 380, Davis, 2004: 303).
The War on Terror that took place primarily in Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan entailed large numbers of casualties. The wars fought by the U.S and its allies, have caused somewhere between an estimated 480.000 and 507.000 casualties. This number includes the deaths of not only civilians, but every death related to the violence of the War on Terror in 2001-2018. Of course, other estimates have been made of a lesser death toll, but the human suffering and the political destabilization of the region has been extensive (Crawford, 2018: 1-6).
Another impact of the War on Terror is the extended function of U.S intelligence and defense agencies. Interrogation techniques of suspected terrorists escalated in Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib during the War on Terror. These methods do not comply with human rights or international humanitarian law, and the U.S has received critique for it. The PATRIOT Act gave intelligence services more extensive possibilities of monitoring terrorists, which also infringed on the integrity of ordinary citizens in the U.S (NE2, HRW 2004).
A third consequence is the security paradox of the U.S biodefense program. Government spending has increased enormously, by some estimates to 41 billion USD. Most efforts made by the new biodefense program has been benign and reduced the risk of a catastrophe if a bioterrorist attack would occur. If other states saw the U.S activity as a breach of the BWC, the biodefense industry could escalate in other parts of the world. This could cause a security paradox and make the U.S countermeasures counterproductive (Leitenberg et al., 2004: 3, Enemark, 2006: 40).
The U.S biodefense program has not only affected other states and their perception of the U.S. As explained in the introduction, the biodefense program has been expanded to a 30-fold increase of personnel and institutions. Most importantly, 15.000 people had access to BW in 2007, compared to about 100 people at the time of the amerithrax attack. This surely heightens the risk of bioterrorism with agents obtained from U.S biolaboratories (Dudley Miller, 2008: 20).
The evidence presented in this section suggests that the U.S securitization of bioterrorism was very harmful. It has entailed great risks for the U.S population, it has affected innocent bystanders at the sites of the War on Terror, and al-Qaeda terrorists have been inhumanely treated at Guantánamo Bay and Abu Ghraib. Human suffering, infringed integrity and the breach of human rights are consequences caused by the U.S securitization.