The discourse of ‘food insecurity’ is one that allows for liberal humanitarian interventions – that alienates the global south as a place to expand the neoliberal system
Melanie Sommerville et al 14, Professor in the Department of Geography, University of British Columbia, Jamey Essex, Professor in the Department of Political Science, University of Windsor, & Philippe Le Billon, Professor in the Department of Geography, University of British Columbia, June 20th 2014, “The ‘Global Food Crisis’ and the Geopolitics of Food Security”, Geopolitics, 19,
The emergence of food security as a pressing geopolitical concern is clearly demonstrated in the popular press, which has carried a steady flow of stories about poor harvests, food shortages, famine, and rising food prices over the last six years. More in-depth studies asking “Could Food Shortages Bring Down Civilization?” and explaining “How Hunger Could Topple Regimes” have appeared in Scientific American and Time, respectively.3 A June 2009 story in National Geographic asserted that the crisis represents a Malthusian moment in humankind’s struggle to feed an ever-growing population, while former head of the US Agency for International Development Andrew Natsios warned of “The Coming Food Coups” in The Washington Quarterly. 4 More recently, prominent environmental commentator and Melanie Sommerville et al. activist Lester Brown identified a “new geopolitics of food,” arguing that the failure to resolve the underlying causes of the 2007–2008 food price increases and volatility meant that “the food crisis of 2011 is for real.” He warns that “farmers and foreign ministers alike” should get ready “for a new era in which world food scarcity increasingly shapes global politics.” This new era of food-insecure geopolitics is driven by familiar ills (for example, “population growth and climate change”) coupled with deepening global inequalities and an international system unable or unwilling to coordinate across the range of policy fronts required to resolve the underlying roots of crisis.5
Yet it is not just the media that is heralding a new era of food-insecure geopolitics, but also mainstream policy narratives. A report to the World Food Program suggested that “food insecurity – especially when caused by a rise in food prices – is a threat and impact multiplier for violent conflict”, though noting it is rarely the direct (and singular) cause of conflict.6 Participants to an FAO Forum on Addressing Food Insecurity in Protracted Crises “emphasized the circular link between food insecurity and conflict”.7 The UN High Level Task Force on Global Food Security, the philanthropocapitalist Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa (AGRA), and many other development, aid, and philanthropic organisations have suggested that there is an urgent geopolitical need for rapidly increased food production through a so-called “new” or “second Green Revolution”, with massive new investments targeted for agricultural production and research in the developing world.8 At a 2012 symposium in Washington on global food security, US President Barack Obama stated that the danger of food riots and price volatility producing global geopolitical instability “will only grow if a surging global population isn’t matched by surging food production.” Investment in agricultural productivity that reduces the incidence of hunger and vulnerability, argued Obama, “advances international peace and security – and that includes the national security of the United States.”9
Although it is unsurprising that concerns about overpopulation, dwindling resources, (under)productivity, and political turmoil are being aired amid the lingering impacts of food price shifts, we assert that such concerns must be critically interrogated. Grounded in neo-Malthusian discourses of eco-catastrophe and the return of environmental determinism (or, as Robert Kaplan put it, the ‘revenge of geography’), such narratives overlook the central role of politics in organising abundance and scarcity.10 They offer a securitised framing of food insecurity, where hunger is seen not only as a politically revolutionary force but also as a fount of secondary problems such as disease, terrorism, illicit drugs and refugees. In such framings, the dangers posed by hunger threaten to reach far beyond the low-income populations and countries in which hunger resides. In doing so, they open the way for liberal humanitarian responses rooted in the nexus of security and development, and which rely on ‘tecFhnologies of betterment’ to resolve the threats posed by hunger and thereby prevent their circulation.11 These efforts Downloaded by [The University of British Columbia] at 09:38 13 January 2016 The ‘Global Food Crisis’ and Food Security 243 and discourses privilege technological solutions to complex conditions of food insecurity, and hinge on the expansion and intensification of liberalised market relations and North-to-South technology transfers, doing little to challenge existing inequalities or limit exposure to economic shocks that threaten livelihoods and contribute to vulnerability, poverty, and hunger. As such they reflect not only the ‘rendering technical’ and ‘anti-politics’ aspects of aid projects, but also more broadly the ‘post-political’ character of ‘common sense’ neoliberal policy debates.12
In this sense, a critical political geography approach towards food crisis narratives can not only help reveal the assumptions and perspectives that frame them, but also how this framing contributes to the reproduction of a conventional agro-food political paradigm. This paradigm is predicated on assumptions drawn from two main realms. On the one hand, it employs the tropes of political realism to construct a world in which combative nationstates are competing in a zero-sum contest for global influence and power, with food security envisioned and strategised as an element of geopolitical risk and calculation. On the other, it re-substantiates the battered but still dominant economic assumptions and practices of global neoliberalism, in which market openness and economic interdependence and connectivity are enthusiastically embraced as policy platforms for advancing food security. Both visions of world geopolitical space envision geographic relationships between people and places in which food insecurity and resultant sociopolitical unrest threaten, respectively, geospatial order and the security of the state and the unimpeded flow of investment and trade upon which capitalist globalisation depends. The resulting ‘neoliberal geopolitics’ frame those people and places that are disconnected from or that lie outside of such flows and systems of accumulation and calculation as gaps, risks, and threats. Security oriented responses reliant on traditional institutions of state power and geopolitical control uneasily intertwine with coercive and unequal forms of neoliberalised economic connection, extending and reproducing the power of dominant institutions and conventional paradigms while excluding other policy approaches and discourses as unfeasible, too expensive, too radical, or simply illegitimate.13
Predictions of rapidly unfolding chaos sparked by unequal access to uncertain food supplies advance a powerful geopolitical view of a world struggling with scarcity, as opposed to inequality and domination, and on the brink of conflict, disaster, and generalised turmoil. Such chaos threatens the vision of ever-increasing stability and growth that has guided the governance of food and agriculture since the end of World War II, a vision of continued improvements in food security premised on the sustained expansion of food supplies through Green Revolution technologies and methods designed to intensify and industrialise agricultural production. The structural adjustment programmes that began in the 1980s and the liberalisation of agricultural trade at the World Trade Organization after 1995 was supposed to stretch the benefits of this system even further through a new supra-national governance and regulatory structure that would bring the benefits of liberalised market dynamics to poor farmers and consumers around the world. In the promised and hoped-for success of these initiatives, food security had little geopolitical relevance. While significant food insecurity continued to exist, especially in many parts of the Global South, this was seen primarily as an economic rather than a geopolitical issue, to be addressed through injections of commodities, technology, capital, or expertise.14 In short, the increasingly hegemonic geopolitical practices of a globalising agro-industrial model were rendered largely invisible by universalising discourses of neoliberal development that depoliticised the model’s social and environmental consequences.
Popular framings of and responses to the current ‘global food crisis’ could challenge these developmentalist discourses by postulating a future marked not by steady progression toward improved food security, cohesive economic integration and international peace, but by deteriorating food security, economic unravelling and political upheaval in the Global South and, potentially, the North as well. The food crisis thus represents a disruption to the existing geopolitical order of global agro-food systems, calling into question established food production and consumption practices and neoliberal framings of food security. At the same time, however, it serves as an opportunity to re-establish some dimensions of neoliberal hegemony, by directing new funding and investment streams into the agro-industrial model, thereby reproducing and expanding the dominant geopolitical order to incorporate new spaces, populations, and agro-food systems (especially but not uniquely in the Global South), in effect turning ‘zones of chaos’ into ‘zones of potential growth’. What the food crisis reveals is the degree to which shifting geopolitical discourses and interventions into global agro-food systems are not just intimately interlinked with the political economy of agricultural production and food consumption, but rather integrally constitutive of this political economy (and vice versa).15
In this context, conceptualising recent shifts in food security as a temporally discrete and global ‘crisis’ is not a neutral framing, but one that risks neglecting longer term and structural drivers of food insecurity, lending legitimacy to securitised forms of intervention and creating new opportunities for capitalist accumulation in the global agro-food system. This speaks to the need to bring a critical eye to shifts in governance resulting from the food crisis, and to situate these amid longer term trajectories of both agrarian change and geopolitical projects and discursive formations. Within this, it is also imperative to examine the opportunities opened by gaps, silences, and failures in the prevailing geopolitical order and to engage critical and radical voices that emphasise alternative geopolitical arrangements, including governance from below and forms of de-globalisation, localisation, and translocal networking based on peasant and consumer power.16