Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Aff’s framing of “China threat” is part of a broader violent attempt to protect the “American identity”

Qiana Gilkey, xx-xx-2022, "How do speech acts contribute to the securitization of China?," Malmo University, https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1667683/FULLTEXT01.pdf //jc

The framing of the ‘China threat’ draws attention to securitization theory as this construction is a distinctive example of securitization. Many are divided on if China actually poses an existential threat. Amongst scholars, the threat China poses is overinflated, while US elites frame China as a genuine threat that should be taken seriously and policies should reflect it. The US-Sino tensions are based in relevance to competition regarding hegemonic status based on the perceived ‘China threat’ from the US. This power shift of China as a rising power can lead to the US and China falling to the Thucydides Trap (Lee, 2019; Mastro, 2018), and there will be a major war during the shift of power. This concept is closely related to the power transition theory which can be operationalized to predict the probability of a war between the two states. While power transition theory is important in understanding the potential for conflict, it does not illustrate why and how tensions arose, much less the effect securitization had on the tensions. It can also lead to a security dilemma in which the US perceives the modernization of China’s military as a threat and challenging its regional hegemonic status (Ambrosio et al, 2020; Jie, 2020). The modernization and advances in military capabilities are not the only way in which the US perceives China as a threat. The ‘China threat’ has been used by the US to protect its interests in national security, the international economic sector, and energy security (Campion, 2020; Nyman, 2014). Campion (2020) and Nyman (2014) use a critical discourse analysis of the energy and cybersecurity sectors to see how they have become intertwined in the construction of China as a threat. Since perceptions of security and insecurity are discursive constructions, it is useful to use speech-acts to uncover how the issues are advanced from everyday politics to high politics (Buzan and Wæver, 2009) and how it constitutes an existential threat. Despite both countries being economically intertwined and cooperative through international organizations and bilateral agreements, China perceives the US as untrustworthy and imposing, while the US views China as a threat in many sectors and a potential challenger to its position as a unipole and regional hegemon. (Nyman, 2014). China is perceived as a threat to the status quo, therefore it poses a threat to the American identity. Chengqiu’s (2020) article does not analyze the US-Sino rivalry in relevance to securitization, but ideational differences and perceptions have been factors that affect the relationship between the two countries. The theoretical framework used is a combination of the cognitive psychology of perceptions and misperceptions by Jervis and social constructivism by Wendt. The data of the American strategy toward China was surmised on four aspects, 7 integrating China into the Western-dominated international economic system, transforming China into a liberal democracy, engaging with China to solve regional and international issues, and preventing China from challenging American hegemony (Chengqiu, 2020: 35). By analyzing the policies towards China from the 1990s to 2020 the results showed how much of a threat China was constructed to be according to each president and if they were competitive or collaborative. The results showed the policies towards China varied according to the perceptions of each president but have progressively become more combative while China’s policies towards the US have been relatively stable. Contrastingly, Almén et al (2021) specifically analyze the perceptional differences between the US and China in three sectors: political, economic, and security. Diverging from Chengqiu, their findings show that the US perceives China as trying to spread authoritarian and communist ideologies and overturn the international order, which China perceives the US as an ‘increasingly antagonistic hegemon that strives for regime change in China’ (Almén et al, 2021: 79). Their position and findings are better suited to this thesis, as the assumption is the US perceiving China as an existential threat that needs immediate attention.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.