Hybrid warfare/misinformation discourses are empty signifiers and is just the Western means to delegitimize opposition and shift attention away from failing institutions
Akin Ünver and Ahmet Kurnaz 22, Department of International Relations, Özyeğin University, İstanbul; Turkey; Ahmet Kurnaz Department of Public Administration and Political Science Çanakkale Onsekiz Mart University, Çanakkale, Turkey. “Securitization of Disinformation in NATO Lexicon: A Computational Text Analysis”, 2/21/22 \\pairie
Since then, strategic communicative actions that are intended to influence, mislead and confuse foreign populations have assumed a central position in global debates about politics and foreign policy. Given the impact of such actions on elections, polarization and crisis management, it was natural for the rhetoric about these actions to assume such a central position(Bradshaw, Howard, 2018). However, over time, popular buzzwords like ‘disinformation/misinformation’, ‘fake news’, and ‘information operations’ have proliferated in global political mainstream discourse and assumed an accusatory nature worldwide as more leaders, diplomats, and politicians have begun using them to discredit and delegitimize their political opponents. This dynamic was later conceptualized as ‘discursive deflection’ (Ross, Rivers, 2018; Smith, 2019) and became acutely visible in the foreign policy domain, as more countries have begun securitizing the concepts ‘fake news’, ‘disinformation’, and ‘information warfare’ to similarly discredit, and delegitimize rival countries(Baum, Potter, 2019). Broadly speaking, ‘discursive-deflection’ is the strategy of discrediting competitors and rivals by portraying oneself as the sole source of truth. While the domestic political use of these terms is well-studied, we are still somewhat in the dark with regard to why countries choose to securitize these terms and what happens in their interactions with other countries when they do so.
The foreign policy use of such terms predates the 2016 US elections and proliferated after the Russian military involvement in Crimea and Donbas (Khaldarova, Pantti, 2016). The primary reason for this contextual proliferation was the Russian decision to deny the initial stages of its involvement in Ukraine and its broader strategy of distracting and dividing Western attention over Russian military operations (Mejias, Vokuev, 2017). There is still a debate over whether it was really Russian information operations that had derailed NATO response in Ukraine, or if disinformation discourses are employed in order to shift the blame over to Russia at a time when NATO was already divided over its commitment to Ukraine (Lysenko, Brooks, 2018). While there is robust evidence of Russian information operations in Ukraine and its role in spreading disinformation in NATO countries, sustained NATO apathy towards rising Russian military influence in the Black Sea after 2014 and Syria after 2015 support the latter claim.
Critics of Western disinformation discourses for example, argue that such discourses have turned into ‘floating (or empty) signifiers’, that have no specific or agreed-upon meaning (Farkas, Schou, 2018). In that vein, blaming others for engaging in disinformation often distracts attention away from a mistake or failed policy enacted by the blamer (Monsees, 2020). In this case, critics argue that Western discourses on disinformation are intended to distract attention away from NATO or EU divisions, or more domesticlevel polarization dynamics, by creating a unique empty signifier (disinformation) that is employed as a rallying rhetoric that bolsters the significance of external threats (Mas-Manchón et al., 2021). This way, disinformation and its associated terms like misinformation, fake news and information war get securitized, receiving disproportionate levels of attention in the policy domain. In this context, disinformation and its associated terms are used to exaggerate an existing threat and create a rallying discourse that would channel the attention of the divided Western nations away from their internal disagreements, and towards an inflated external threat. Some scholars go even further, arguing that disinformation is being securitized in the West (especially in NATO) to the extent the ‘war on terror’ was securitized through the 2000s (Lanoszka, 2019). In this line, disinformation is alleged to have become a new strategic glue that would help Western nations pool in their increasingly diverging interests and resources into a common cause (Baumann, 2020).
Securitization of disinformation in domestic politics is relatively well-studied (Freelon, Wells, 2020; Neo, 2021). Although these terms have entered into mainstream debate after the 2016 US elections, former President Donald Trump too, had securitized fake news to delegitimize his opponents by constructing rival disinformation as a national security problem, indirectly attributable to China (Polletta, Callahan, 2019). Following the tornado of accusations in the US, political actors in Britain, France, Italy, South Africa, Kenya and others have begun blaming each other for engaging in organized disinformation (Maweu, 2019; Saurwein, Spencer-Smith, 2020). Even in Sweden, there is empirical evidence that suggests accusing journalists of spreading fake news results in self-censorship of such outlets (Bennett, Livingston, 2018). There are further cases of evidence supporting the claim that elite-level discourses on disinformation have a direct effect on how the wider society perceives information and facts in general, creating a measurable effect on public trust towards such facts and information (Van Duyn, Collier, 2019). In Singapore for example, delegitimizing rival parties and news outlets through disinformation discourse is considered ‘acceptable’, as part of the state’s duty to discipline the opposition and its political actors (Tan, 2020). Similar trends emerging in democracies and authoritarian countries alike, such as in Austria, Australia, Poland, Russia, and South Africa, demonstrate the universality of instrumentalizing disinformation discourse as a political delegitimization tactic (Kurowska, Reshetnikov, 2018; Tandoc et al., 2018).
While a robust scholarship is emerging on the domestic political uses of disinformation discourse, there has so far been no longitudinal, large-N study that explored how such constructions emerge in international politics. Furthermore, there has so far been no exploration of how such discourses evolve over time and under what contexts in foreign affairs. We know that disinformation and fake news are important issues in world politics and that they are frequently used to bring an issue to public attention, but we are more in the dark over the contextual and temporal nuances that drive how these concepts are discursively constructed in foreign policy discourse.
This study aims to provide an early addition to the emerging literature on foreign policy uses of disinformation discourses by focusing on how the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) has used them in its documents and social media posts. It does so by studying 238,452 tweets from official NATO and affiliated accounts, and more than 2,000 NATO texts, news, statements, and publications using computational methods since January 2014 and presents an unsupervised structural topic model (stm) analysis to explore the main thematic and discursive contexts of these texts. Ultimately, we hope to trigger a wider debate on the securitization of disinformation and fake news in foreign policy, and the greater explanatory value of computational methods in studying large-N text data in studying such securitization strategies.
2 Securitizing Disinformation
Over the last few years, defining what misleading content is and how to measure the legitimacy of its dissemination has been at the forefront of journalistic, political and scientific debate (Tandoc et al., 2018). Even before its proliferation in 2016, disinformation was a widely-used term in the mainstream discourse, co-existing with other terms such as infoglut, or information overload (Andrejevic, 2013). Although at first disinformation and misinformation were terms used interchangeably, today, disinformation refers to the deliberate dissemination of false information with the intention to mislead and confuse its audiences. Misinformation, on the other hand, strictly defines unintended diffusion of false information by mistake, without malintent. There are also bridge terms such as ‘malinformation’ that is factually accurate but is deployed to harm and damage an individual or an entity, or the concept of ‘problematic information’ as defined by Caroline Jack (Jack, 2017; Morgan, 2018). Although it is not directly mentioned, all of these concepts refer to the digital space, where information manipulation is disseminated faster and wider on social media and digital communication technologies compared to more media forms of media.
As terms ‘disinformation/misinformation’, ‘fake news’, ‘information operation’, and ‘hybrid war’ are often used interchangeably in political discourse, there are no clear-cut differences in the strategic topic of each word choice (Guess, Lyons, 2020). Politicians and leaders can often use these terms as a bag of buzzwords, without a clear operational definition of what each of them precisely means. Each of these buzzwords generate roughly the same effect on the consumers of such messages, which is the delegitimization of their target (Tucker et al., 2018). Especially problematic is the fact that once the discourse on disinformation is weaponized to delegitimize rivals, there is very little such rivals can do to defend themselves. Given the significant political charge of these terms, individuals or institutions that are alleged to be engaging in disinformation-related activities often have to enter into a fruitless spar of words to challenge such allegations, which usually leads to further controversy. This renders the accuser - or the side that securitizes disinformation - more advantageous compared to the accused, generating a dynamic similar to the ‘attacker’s advantage’ in cyber security where the defender is continuously blindsided (Tong et al., 2020).