Responses to disease from Western states and transnational organizations leads to securitization --- people are forced to govern their own bodies and associate disease with violence and terror
François Debrix & Alexander D. Barder 11, Professor and Director of ASPECT of the Department of Political Science at Virginia Tech University & Associate Professor and Graduate Program Director for International Relations at Florida International University, 08/29/2011, “2. Nothing to fear but fear itself: governmentality and the reproduction of terror” (book chapter in Beyond Biopolitics: Theory, violence, and horror in world politics) /lg
A telling example of this self-mobilization and self-immunization against one ’s body and flesh can be found in the way Western states (or, rather, some of their governmental agents and agencies) along with some transnational organizations (the World Health Organization, the United Nations) asked populations the world over to preemptively take charge of their health, hygiene, and everyday routines in the context of the recent A/H1N1 (or “ swine flu ” ) pandemic. In this popular health scare, as with many other instances of spreading epidemics over the past decade (SARS, the H5N1 “ bird flu, ” but also AIDS before), individual beings were asked to be the primary layer of securitization and defense against terror by turning their bodies (and those of family members, neighbors, co-workers, and so on) into primordial sites of scrutiny, intervention, and indeed governance. With the “ swine flu ” fear, a constant questioning of one ’s body movements and symptomatic features, along with one ’ s daily habits, became an automatic (and auto-immune) and mostly unquestioned safeguard against the epidemic. Humanity ’s bodies, the physiology of the human species, but also the meaning of what it means to be human (and whether humanity should be reduced to a management of the fl esh) became the main targets of the pandemic terror but, just as crucially, of the containment terror that followed the revelation of the pandemic. This governance of the “ swine flu ” and its scare (the disease and its terror were indeed inseparable from the moment a pandemic discourse was launched) was then based on a series of menial operations at the level of the human body and flesh (do I have a fever? Is my cough a sign that I have been infected? Did I remember to wash my hands after riding the bus or the subway?). Of course, it also relied on several self-cancellation measures (I must stay home for days if I feel sick; I must wear a protective mask if I venture outside and have a runny nose; we must close entire schools for as long as necessary if we suspect that children in the community have the flu).
In the end, the swine flu terror also raised vital questions about what humanity today is by proliferating a succession of moral quandaries that actually sought to recon figure humanity as that which is always already primed for sacrifice. Among such so-called fundamental social dilemmas were questions like: Must I sacrifice my body and my self if my children are not yet sick but I am (and thus, I could infect them)? Will I have to allow myself to go without treatment (and possibly not make it) if it turns out that, as was reported, there are not enough vaccines for everybody? Must I segregate myself, and remove my body from the community of the living, so as not to let the remaining healthy bodies be even more at risk? The sacrificial logic involved in the swine fl u scare may evoke some of René Girard ’ s theorizations, particularly to the extent that this form of sacrifice appears to be aimed at the safeguarding of the community. But today’s self-sacrificial or self effacing logic goes far beyond the claim advanced by Girard that “ the sacrifice serves to protect the entire community from its own violence. ” 71 Or, for that matter, that the ritual of the sacrifice “ prompts the entire community to choose victims outside itself. ” 72 To the contrary, the encouraged sacrificial ritual of the swine flu pandemic terror is, to repeat, an auto-immune response or attitude that, far from casting violence away, actually seeks to keep it within and strives to spread it, sometimes in a horrific fashion, to as many living members of the community as possible. In fact, by placing itself beyond the threshold of both life and death, and by questioning the meaning of the human itself (and suggesting that the human should be redefi ed as that which is always ready for sacrifice), the swine flu sacrificial terror enters the realm of agonal politics and brings in the specter of a horror whereby humans must allow themselves to be quarantined, potentially culled, possibly manipulated and tested upon beyond death, and eventually left to decay in a condition of neither life nor death (not bios , not zoe , and not even thanatos ) where the human is rendered unrecognizable as human.