The dichotomy between language of disease and military threats causes diseases to be viewed as an explanation of constructed threats --- stems from malevolent nationalism
Mika Luoma-aho 02, Head of the Department of Social Studies and a Lecturer in International Relations at the University of Lapland in Finland, 12/01/2002, “Body of Europe and Malignant Nationalism: A Pathology of the Balkans in European Security Discourse”, Geopolotics, Vol. 7, Issue 3, p. 117 – 142 /lg
Cancer is a mysterious disease difficult to treat, and one that is often equated with death. Of all diseases, cancer has provided probably the most potent metaphor of illness since tuberculosis became treatable in the midtwentieth century.60 While tuberculosis is understood as a disease of one organ, cancer is understood as a disease that can turn up in any organ and one whose outreach is the whole body. It is a disease of growth – sometimes visible, more characteristically insidious – which may be arrested for periods of time, but is prone to recur. As defined by Mel Greaves, cancer is a collection of many disorders of cell and tissue function that have one special biological property in common: the territorial expansion of a mutant clone.61 Susan Sontag argued that when used as a metaphor, cancer appears as a pathology of space; its principal metaphors refer to topography – it may ‘spread, ‘proliferate’, or be ‘diffused’.62 This is also the most striking single image that can be found in almost all representations of malevolent nationalism in European security discourse: the threat of geographical escalation or spill-over from one part of Europe to another – most typically from east to west. Furthermore, the language used to describe cancer evokes a systemic catastrophe: ‘cells without inhibitions, cancer cells will continue to grow and extend over each other in a “chaotic” fashion, destroying the body’s normal cells, architecture, and functions’.63 Reliance on similar dichotomies, such as order/chaos and normal/abnormal, in the discursive economy of nationalism is striking and more than coincidental. What is also interesting is that in the discourse of cancer the language of military strategy is often applied: cancer cells do not simply multiply, but are ‘invasive’; they ‘colonise’ from the original tumour to far sites in the body by metastasising; and only rarely are the body’s own ‘defences’ strong enough to fight a tumour made of millions of destructive cells.