Securitizing lethal autonomous weapons enables violence against ‘illegitimate states’—rhetoric is used as a means of othering.
Ronja Schahira Kaya Metzger 21, Spring 2021, Faculty of Culture and Society (KS), Department of Global Political Studies, "Security or Security Issue of tomorrow? Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems", Malmo University, https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1604606/FULLTEXT02.pdf //AW
This section examines how LAWS are presented as a threat or security issue in the material. Furthermore, to which extend LAWS are not securitized or portrayed as threatening, in which a discourse of progress and growth play a role. The threats or vulnerabilities that lethal autonomous weapon systems create are linked to different thematic clusters and discourses. They can be summarised under key themes of technological discourse and threat of other actors, a military threat. Firstly, an important aspect in the construction of a threat in LAWS identified in the material is a cluster which will be referred to here as a new technology discourse. In this discourse, rapid technological advances are perceived as a security issue. The term new technology appears repeatedly in the material, though not always associated with linguistic means of threat production, but it is characterised as a discourse concerned with technological development. Where new technology is variously clustered with terms as: “cyber attacks” (E1) a “new technological age” (E2), “Hackers” (E1; E8)) and consequential terms such as “miscalculation”(E2), “manipulation”(E1), “misuse”(E1). To demonstrate this discourse element, I will use various examples from the material: New technologies are far more susceptible to proliferation, manipulation and misuse that conventional weapons. Hackers don´t need much more that a computer in order to carry out cyber attacks. (E1) 28 The second big driver of change and new technologies the topic of our conference today autonomous weapons systems have created the fear of killer robots that attack targets without human control. Cyber-attacks on critical infrastructure could paralyse entire countries. And while attribution remains difficult, retaliation could easily provoke unintended conflicts. (E2, cursive by me) These quotes exemplify the threatening or concerning discourse around new technology. In the first quote the threat is enacted in temporal and special terms of proximity, an ‘attack’ could occur at any moment inflicting some sort of personal harm as nothing more than a computer is needed. In the second quote, the modality marker ‘could’ contributes to the creation of an ominous threat. The source is not known or a ‘killer robot without human control’. All these construe images of speed, devastating effects, and imminence toward the recipient of the message. killer robots that Lord over life and death on the basis of autonomous datasets and entirely beyond human control are already a frightening real prospect today (…) fully autonomous weapons are susceptible to manipulation and also to miscalculation. Automatic escalations - ‘flash wars’ - and arms races are virtually inevitable. This is therefore a red line that we must not cross we are committed to this in Geneva [and] We need your support for this. (E1) Here, the metaphor of a red line is invoked concerning autonomous weapons systems, which is commonly used to symbolize a point of no return. Additionally, in the speech, analogies are used to induce fear. Analogies are often used to illustrate a threat, creating a link between a current crisis and a past situation in which neglect led to the fulfilment of the threat scenario (Cap, 2017). For example, in the 2019 speech, a link between the current crisis of technological developments and their possible impact on warfare to the discoveries of the German chemist Fritz Haber is made. Besides paving the way for “mass production of artificial fertilizers” (E1) which saved countless lives, Haber is known as the “father of gas warfare” (E1). Therefore, the example exemplifies the potential as well as threat emanating from new technologies. The linguistic creation of a threat emanating from LAWS and new technologies is more pronounced in the speeches of Foreign Minister Maas than in the small inquiries and the material of the CCW. An observation that coincides with the fact the speech genre functions in a broad category in which the speech is argumentative and supposed to entertain and persuade (Fairclough, 1995). While the statements from the CCW and the small inquiries fall more strongly in a category that is more argumentative, in which the text serves to inform and persuade. The statements for the CCW are published in an environment in which what is said is very controlled and the content is intertextually linked to prior statements which as Fairclough argues, signals continuity of discourse practices (Jorgensen & Phillips, 2002). The threat discourse of new technologies closely links the threat of LAWS with a discourse of cyber threat. The perception of cyber space as a threat environment has developed in Germany in recent decades. Cyber security became part of the public debate in Germany in the early 1990s. Yet, it was not strongly perceived as a threat until the early 2000s with the fear of the Millennium, bug. Then the terror attacks of 9/11 led to increased attention to various security risks. These included cyber security. In Germany, the cyber threat is particularly perceived in connection to the protection of personal data. Besides the event of 9/11, especially Edward Snowden led to increased public attention. Snowden's disclosure of the US National Security Agency (NSA) documents led to the increased relevance of cyber security. It raised the threat perception in the general public in 2013 (Schallbruch & Skierk, 2018). Sandywell (2006) suggests that post 9/11 new technology and especially the cyber space caused new insecurities through a blurring of the boundary between the physical and virtual, the global/regional. Where “states of emergency settle into a condition of permanent societal instability” (p.48). That these insecurities create a field in which the extreme manifestations of the cyber threat are linked to the threat discourse of global terrorism. Sandywell (2006) suggests that both discourses are marked with boundary dissolving characteristics, which have intrusive attributes. Further,that the blurring of common and familiar binaries suggests a more general state of emergency. On the textual level, the temporal and spatial boundaries are dissolved, and the threat is emanating from an unknown intrusive other (Sandywell, 2006). It is this sociocultural context that the threat of new technologies and risk perception of LAWS is linked with within Germany. A second theme or cluster of threats in which LAWS is embedded is the threat of ‘other actors’ and the changing of capabilities that could come with LAWS. Particularly, other states and illegitimate actors. As previously mentioned delegitimization can be used as a counterpart to underpin own legitimization, which can be enacted through ideas of difference, negative representations and geographical or cultural boundaries (Cap, 2017). In the speeches a starker image of the ‘other’ is created in representations: ‘we are urging President Putin (…) to ensure that Russia returns to compliance with the INF treaty. Its termination would have grave consequences for Europeans` security. (…) as a result of infringements, trust, transparency, and stability which we have built up labouredly over decades [is] at risk of being forfeited’(E1) ‘Players such a China must also take responsibility for strategic stability’(E1) ‘I (…) therefore welcome the willingness shown by the US to conduct talks with North Korea on the North Korean nuclear programme’(E1) These quotes while taken out of direct context serve to demonstrate the creation of images of other states. Russia is represented as non-compliant ‘other’ and while the substantives serve as negative attributions toward Russia, they simultaneously positively represent the in-groups Europe and Germany. Thus, it reinforces the mental-geographical boundary of Europe as a whole and its common identity. Undergirding the call on China is implicit a lack of taking responsibility for strategic stability. Contrary, the US is portrayed as positive, willing to conduct talks, while North Korea becomes a passive other. Therefore, a representation of the world is reinforced with positive attributes to allies such as the US and representations of ‘other’ to Russia, North Korea, and China. The ‘other’ in terms of states in the CCW material is only visible in reference to ‘potential adversaries’(E8), however, there is a reference concerning illegitimate actors as “terrorists” (E1; E8), “criminals” (E1) “illegitimate actors” (E1), and “illegitimate groups” (E9) who are “expanding their capacity to indiscriminately inflict harm and inflict terror on civilians” (E8). There are also consequential threats present in the material which are in causal relation with the aforementioned threat of ‘other actors’, the threat of arms race and arms proliferation. The threat of arms race is mentioned in different ways. That with the development of LAWS “threat perceptions are likely to change under the impression that potential adversaries have or are in the process of acquiring such weapon systems” (E8, omitting underline) and that “Arms races are under way around the world” (E1). However, an increase of possible arms race is articulated as not being limited to the development of LAWS: [In] the German government's assessment, the development of autonomous functions for use in weapon systems can further strengthen the already existing armament trends. (E18) Noticeable is that while in the material of the CCW conference the threat of an arms race is discussed in future terms, it is declared as already ongoing in the small inquiries and speeches. An image of a growing threat is generated through increased capacities of other states, which are, however not named and thus contribute to an ominous external threat. Further, a consequential threat of proliferation is articulated. It relates to illegitimate actors and how “transfer of software” (E8) is “difficult to prevent and even harder to detect” (E18) and that “the risk of [LAWS or predecessor technologies] uncontrolled proliferation [is] significantly greater than the corresponding risks of uncontrolled proliferation of finished weapon systems” (E18). Acknowledgement of the problem is followed by arguments that: 32 these concerns are being addressed and regulated by national administrative laws, in particular weapon laws and transport and traffic law. This enables governments to effectively stop or limit the spread of dangerous dual use technologies, if necessary. (E18)