Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Securitization of the environment has become a central aspect of US foreign and defense policy --- NATO’s statements prove it considers the environment a security risk that can lead to violence

Peter Hough 22, Associate Professor in International Politics at Middlesex University with a PhD in International Relations from City University in London, 06/09/2022, “Ecological Security” (book chapter in Rethinking Security in the Twenty-First Century: A Reader), Middlesex University Research Repository, p. 183-194 /lg

Many states have come to take a widened approach to security since the 1990s and the resource wars literature was particularly influential on the Clinton Administration in the U.S. HomerDixon is known to have been invited to brief Vice President Al Gore and the State Department on several occasions in the early 1990s.13 In 1993, a new government position in the Defense Department was created with the Deputy Under Secretary for Environmental Security, and the Environmental Task Force set up as part of Washington’s intelligence network. The impact of all of this was made explicit in the 1994’s “National Security Strategy,” the US’s annual foreign policy manifesto. 

Not all security risks are military in nature. Transnational phenomena such as terrorism, narcotics trafficking, environmental degradation, rapid population growth and refugee flows also have security implications for both present and long term American policy.14

Other instances of governments making the environment the stuff of high politics have since emerged in North America and North Europe, most notably in several defense and foreign policy statements from Finland, Canada, the Netherlands, and the UK.15 In 2007, Foreign Minister Margaret Beckett used the UK’s presidency of the UN Security Council to push through, with some resistance from other members, the first discussion in that arena of on an overtly environmental topic. A major influence on this stance was the Stern Report of the previous year compiled by a British economist on behalf of the UK government, which provided an economic security rationale for prioritizing action on climate change. Stern calculated the cost of non-action on climate change as amounting to at the very least 5 percent of global GDP for evermore. Set against this, the costs of effective action to curb climate change would cost around 1 percent of global GDP per year.16 Perhaps, though, the clearest illustration of the environment becoming the stuff of widened security comes from its embrace by the cold warriors of NATO:

Based on a broad definition of security that recognizes the importance of political, economic, social and environmental factors, NATO is addressing security challenges emanating from the environment. This includes extreme weather conditions, depletion of natural resources, pollution and so on—factors that can ultimately lead to disasters, regional tensions and violence.17

As the NATO statement indicates, securitizing environmental issues in practice has tended to be in the traditional national security manner of factoring such concerns into calculations of defense needs. Many governments have politicized issues of environmental change when there is no obvious military dimension, even trumping anthropocentric interests for eco-centric reasons (such as in the restriction of polluting organochlorine pesticides like DDT) but few have “securitized” them and treated them as matters of urgent political priority. An exception is the low-lying states threatened with literal extinction under the waves of the rising oceans. Following the Security Council discussion of climate change two years earlier, the UN General Assembly in 2009 took up this theme with a resolution drafted by the government of low-lying Nauru called Climate Change and its Possible Security Implications (A64/350), calling on all UN agencies to prioritize climate change. While the resolution was unanimously adopted, Nauru—and other similarly threatened island states like Tuvalu, the Maldives—are amongst the smallest of small fry in the international political system and few of the “big fish” have prioritized climate change to the point of seriously compromising their short-term economic interests.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.