Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Descriptions of the environment as posing existential threats stem from state-centered imaginaries --- even academic research fuels the narrative

Michael Mason & Mark Zeitoun 13, Associate Professor in the Department of Geography and Environment and Associate of the Grantham Research Institute for Climate Change and the Environment at the London School of Economics and Political Science & Professor of Water Security and Policy at the School of International Development of the University of East Anglia, December 2013, “Questioning Environmental Security”, The Geographical Journal, Vol. 179, No. 4, p. 294-297 /lg

Threats to and from ‘the environment’ inform geographical depictions of danger with wide- spread reach in political and policy circles. While these fears are partly replaying past neo- Malthusian concerns about limits to growth, they are also associated with a distinct millennialist anxiety about the lethality made possible by collapsing conditions of life. 'Dangerous climate change' is at the forefront of these apocalyptic imaginaries, but existential threats are seen to issue also from biodiversity extinction, fossil fuel depletion and endemic water shortages (Dalby 2009; Swyngedouw 2010). The 'securitisation' of environmental processes is at once both a consequence and driver of such apocalyptic concerns, and this discursive framing is intuitively straightforward for those who argue that it justifies urgent, even emergency, measures to prevent or miti- gate serious dangers. Security here denotes that which is evoked or invoked when acting to protect core institutions or freedoms in the face of serious ecologi- cal threats. This is the dominant notion of environ- mental security questioned by contributors to this themed section.

From a geographical perspective, environmental security straddles uneasily across a territorial/post- territorial axis, where tensions are immediately appar- ent between competing spatial performances of security. This expresses contrasting claims over the political subjectivity being secured. It is not surprising that state actors have invoked environmental security practices and discourses according to territorial doctrines of national security, whereby environmental risks supplement traditional threats to the state. Thus, 'climate security', 'biosecurity' and 'energy security' are employed to refer to the protection of state interests with regard to the projected and perceived con- sequences of environmental change, biotechnologies and fossil fuels scarcity. Numerous think-tank and academic publications have fed these state-centred imaginaries of environmental danger on the basis of disputed natural and social scientific scenarios (e.g. Klare 2008; Brown and Crawford 2009; Chellaney 2011). In apparent opposition to statist representa-tions of security are non-territorial notions of 'human security', which profess a universal concern for the protection of individuals or groups from serious threats to wellbeing. Constructions of human security have identified environmental dangers as potential threats to human welfare; for example, 'water secu- rity' and 'food security' mark out areas of practical application for international development and humanitarian organisations (Matthew et al. 2010; Cook and Bakker 2012).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.