Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Discourse articulates the scope of hegemonic interests—securitization legitimizes interests to construct new political structures

Eva Herschinger, 11, research associate and lecturer in the Department of Political Science at the Universität der Bunderswehr, MÃ1⁄4nchen, Germany. Constructing Global Enemies: Hegemony and Identity in International Discourses on Terrorism and Drug Prohibition, Taylor & Francis Group, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/umichigan/detail.action?docID=604159.

Language and articulation, discourse and practice. For positivism, language works as a transparent medium for the indexing of data giving us a clear view on reality while the interpretation of reality can rely on correlations and facts. In contrast, poststructuralism conceives of language as ontologically significant and productive. Such an understanding situates the study within theories that comply with the ‘linguistic turn’ in the social sciences: they refuse to conceptualize language as a means of representation, as a transparent medium or key for the researcher to investigate an objective perception of reality. ‘Reality’ cannot be objectively perceived; hence, there is no objective or ‘true’ meaning behind or beyond linguistic representations. The discourse functions as the theoretical horizon on which objects are constituted: all objects are objects of discourse, as their meaning depends on a socially constructed system of rules and significant differences (Howarth and Stavrakakis 2000: 3). This is the tragedy of the old man: the productivity of language allowed him to turn the table in a rug and the bed into a painting; it allowed him to construct a world of his own full of things and objects with new meanings. But language is also a socially constructed and collectively shared system of rules, codes and conventions to which individuals have to comply in order to be understood and to participate in societal life, language can never be a private property – there is no private language exclusively for the old man (Wittgenstein 2001: 75/243).

To further understand language as political not only makes it a site of social interaction but also a space for producing and denouncing specific subjectivities within the political realm – language is a site of exclusion and inclusion. For instance, the understanding of drug use in the nineteenth century was radically different from today: drug use was a tolerated behaviour, people in various societal strata consumed drugs for pleasure, recreation or for medical reasons, and states even promoted the drug trade by claiming the monopoly on, for example, the trade with opium. Such a stance is inconceivable today, since the political nature of these formerly accepted practices became subject of contestations and, eventually, exclusions: states would not act as trader of drugs anymore and consuming drugs is considered as deviant, sick and illegal behaviour. Thus, drug prohibition (and equally terrorism) are not a mere liguistic reflection of processes or patterns of behaviour one can discover in the world ‘out there’ and described ‘as they are’. They are as much in need of interpretation as they open up space for interpretation. How they are interpreted and why some interpretations dominate and others do not is – as this book argues – a question of hegemonic orders.

By claiming that it is only through language that things acquire meaning, the imagination of an extra-discursive realm able to determine the meaning of an object is excluded. However, such a stance does not imply that objects of knowledge might not exist independently of language, that there is no materiality of say a body or a table outside of discourse. The fact that every object is constituted as an object of discourse has nothing to do with whether there is a world external to thought, or with the realism/ idealism opposition. An earthquake or the falling of a brick is an event that certainly exists, in the sense that it occurs here and now, independently of my will. But whether their specificity as objects is constructed in terms of ‘natural phenomena’ or ‘expression of the wrath of God’ depends upon the structuring of a discursive field. What is denied is not that such objects exist externally to thought, but the rather different assertion that they could constitute themselves as objects outside any discursive conditions of emergence. (Laclau and Mouffe 2001: 108)2

Hence, poststructuralism conceptualizes language in a twofold manner. First, language is highly structured, since – as Derrida once argued – it is a system of differential signs, and meaning can only emerge through a series of juxtapositions, where one element is valued over its opposite and not via the essence of the thing itself (Derrida 1980). In principle, signs are composed of the signifier (the letters on the page or the sound that bounces off our eardrum) and the signified (the concept that appears in our brain when we read or hear the signifier). Hence, a drug addict can only be identified as such through a differentiation from the non-user, a terrorist needs to be delineated from the legitimate freedom fighter and a state’s national identity acquires meaning via juxtaposition with a different national identity.

While signifier and signified capture the structured nature of language, meaning within linguistic structures is organized by articulation. Against the background of the ontological significance of language, poststructuralists valorize the role of articulatory practices in the structuring of social relations by claiming that every social process of putting elements together is to some degree articulatory. In this respect, and secondly, poststructuralists conceive of language not only as highly structured but also as instable at the same time. Due to this instable nature of language, the practice of articulation is ‘the construction of nodal points which partially fix meaning’ (Laclau and Mouffe 2001: 113). By speaking of the partial ability to fix meaning only, Laclau and Mouffe highlight the instable nature of language. Signifiers are always referring to other signifiers without ever coming to an irrevocable meaning. Derrida circumscribed this process with his neologism différance: words and signs can never fully summon forth what they mean, but can only be defined or explained by using more words; thus, the ‘fuller’ meaning is always postponed in language, there is never a moment when one can say the meaning is complete (Derrida 1972).

Such diverse writers as Derrida, Julia Kristeva, Foucault, Roland Barthes, Jacques Lacan or Laclau and Mouffe acknowledge that the articulatory practice always alters the identity of each articulated element. ‘[C]ontingency now inhabits not only the different elements that are linked together to form a discourse, but also the hegemonic projects or subjects that strive to fix meanings’ (Glynos and Howarth 2007: 179). This brings about a conceptualization of discourse as ‘the structured totality resulting from the articulatory practice’ (Laclau and Mouffe 2001: 105). Hence, discourses refer to systems of meaningful practices that form the identities of subjects and objects; they relate elements to establish meaning, since elements need to be set in relation to other elements to acquire meaning. This is implied when the meaning of a terrorist can only be established by juxtaposing it to a non-terrorist. Discursive structures are not cognitive entities, they are articulatory practices, which constitute and organize social relations.

Although being defined as a structured totality the process of constantly relating elements and organize meaning rules out the impression of discourse as a static, fixed structure. On the contrary, discourse is a structure penetrated by contingency and temporality, marked by fissures, ruptures and breaches. Attempts to halt the inherent dynamic that haunts discourses and to fix meaning around closed structures are in vain: ‘neither absolute fixity nor absolute non-fixity is possible’ (Laclau and Mouffe 2001: 111). Thus, what counts for the articulatory practice also counts for discourses: meaning can be partially fixed because without partial fixations the very flow of differences would not be possible and no identity or social formation would ever be constructed. Partial fixations are achieved as any discourse situates itself as ‘an attempt to dominate the field of discursivity [. . .] to construct a centre’ (Laclau and Mouffe 2001: 111–2) and subjects search for a constitutive decision articulating social meaning in one particular way rather than another – to paraphrase Derrida’s ‘undecidability’ of any text.

One central implication of denying the existence of an extra-discursive realm within which things and objects can be constructed consists of acknowledging that policies like the ‘war on terror’ and the ‘war on drugs’ are based on specific discursive representations of the security problem they want to address and on specific constructions of identities, of Self and Other. But how are linguistic representations and policies like the two ‘wars’ linked exactly? In this respect, the notion of practice is crucial. Practices are the ongoing, routinized forms of human and societal reproduction. As largely repetitive activities (not entailing a strong notion of self-conscious reflexivity), they contribute to the reproduction of wider systems of social relations. However, every practice is also articulatory ‘as human beings constantly engage in the process of linking together different elements of their social lives in these continuous and projective sequences of human action’ (Glynos and Howarth 2007: 104).

While such social practices and the identities they maintain tend to dissimulate the inherent contingency that inhabits social systems, the ghost of this contingency leaves its traces within the structure: discursive structures are precarious, they are full of breaches and gaps, i.e. any social edifice suffers from an inbuilt defect which may become visible in moments of dislocation (Lacan 2006: 693). Dislocation destabilizes a discourse due to events that cannot be symbolized by this very discourse – it refers to the ‘decentring’ of the structure through social processes which disrupt the structure (like a severe crisis), as they cannot be mastered by it. In such a moment, new opportunities arise, allowing (but also forcing) a subject to situate itself anew as its former points of identification have vanished in the process of dislocation. We will see later in how far the terrorist attacks at the Olympic Games in 1972 represent such a moment of dislocation as they could not be represented in the discourse on terrorism at that time.

Yet, dislocation is problematic and productive at the same time, since the dislocated social practices give rise to political practices, as in the moment of dislocation, of a crisis, grievances or dissatisfactions are publicly articulated as demands. Thus, political practices are about struggles challenging and transforming current norms, institutions and practices – or an entire regime of practices – in the name of a different, particular idea, ideal or principle (Howarth 2000: 108–9). If political practices are successful in challenging existing norms and institutions in the name of something new, they bring about a transformative effect, since they can modify or reorder an entire regime. Indeed, to the extent to which political practices are not only able to challenge an existing regime of practices but also link various forces and demands into a new regime of practices, they exercise an enormous transformative effect in the political landscape. Even more: political practices can be characterized as ‘more or less hegemonic depending on the degree to which the political demands articulating a grievance are formulated in terms that succeed in having more or less universal appeal’ (Glynos and Howarth 2007: 123). In this sense, a regime of political practices has a structuring function by ordering a system of practices against something else: the institution of a particular regime is always dependent on frontiers relating to what cannot be incorporated in the differential system of the regime. The establishment of these limits serves to exclude antagonistic otherness, represented by those elements that have nothing in common with the regime from which they are excluded. Quite obviously, defining a regime of practices in contrast to an antagonized regime shapes both of them. Labelling a drug addict as a criminal or defining her as a sick person leads to different practices on how to deal with her addiction – either by repressive and punitive measures or by prevention and clinical cure.

Furthermore, considering something as a threat, i.e. to ‘securitize’ an issue by designating it as an existential threat and request for extraordinary measures, is all but interest-free (Buzan, Wæver and de Wilde 1998: 23–6). It legitimizes the subject that securitizes to go beyond the limits of routine political behaviour and demand extraordinary measures and instruments. In most of these cases (since these types of demands are most frequently voiced by powerful stakeholders within a state), the measures serve to discipline the rest of society and reaffirm the rule of particular subjects over society. By invoking the extraordinary measures and practices to defend against the alleged threat, resistance to these practices becomes increasingly difficult. Moreover, resistance can easily be described as being subversive and playing into the hands of the threat.

To characterize practices and regimes, to account for their relationship, to explain how and why they change or resist transformations, we need to elaborate on the logics or modes of construction on which they are based. Most importantly, in order to address how and why specific regimes become hegemonic it is especially necessary to clarify what is understood by hegemony. This is the task of the next section.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.