Individual autonomy reproduces the securitization of structural dynamics that creates a cycle of Western dynamics
Lazell 16- (Lazell, Melita- political economist with diverse research interests traversing the fields of security, development and aid, and international relations, "Liberalism(s) and the critical securitization of development debate", 2016, University of Portsmouth, https://researchportal.port.ac.uk/en/publications/liberalisms-and-the-critical-securitization-of-development-debate)//mishelle
Through demarcating the multiple meanings of liberalism salient to the securitization of development debate, this article has proposed a number of additions and amendments to move the debate forward. Understanding liberalism as a coherent philosophy, as do a number of contributions to the debate, draws attention to the liberal political discourse of global governance. However, depicting global governance as unified through a liberal consensus endows a greater coherence to these discourses than they warrant. In doing so, internal contradiction, contestation and contingency is obscured. An approach to these related discourses which makes visible the ‘messy actualities’ (Larner, 2006) of global governance may reveal potential and spaces for specific emancipatory change. This would include acknowledging the different narratives linking security and development, which would engender a more robust understanding of this discourse. Utilising the idea of liberalism as a technology of governance gives insight into how development involves the production of freedom and entails limitations and coercion. It highlights liberal societal transformation as a key rationale of global governance and offers a salient theoretical tool for understanding ‘ownership’ and ‘participation’ within the global development agenda. However there is a need to establish greater clarity regarding the drivers of liberal societal transformation in the South and deeper engagement with the wider literature concerned with liberal societal transformation (Harrison, 2004) Applying neoliberalism as governmentality to the debate sheds light upon how the non-liberal practices of development intervention become acceptable to a global governance network that is essentially liberal. Finally, a theory of the securitization of development needs to pay greater attention to the structural dynamics of the global economy, including how these are linked to the production of discourse. The (important) focus on liberalism(s) as a coherent philosophy or technique of power, should not exclude an analysis of the underlying structures of global capital accumulation that perpetuate the very global inequalities that are currently framed as security issues by global governance networks. The security-development nexus reinforces the delinking of development assistance from the principle of solidarity and the redistribution of wealth. Instead, development interventions are understood as a tool of Western security. It is this that the securitization of development debate is seeking to critique. In delineating the three strands of liberalism this paper contributes to the debate by providing greater clarity and further tools through which to reveal the ‘underlying cartographies of power’ that inform the nexus. Furthermore, in demonstrating that complexity rather than coherence characterises networks of global governance, it also has implications for critical global governance studies that lean towards conceptualising global governance as a knowable, coherent unit.