Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The discourse of Western notions of security cooperation enables continued construction of identities that seeks to maintain power

Gunther Hellmann et. al, 2017; Benjamin Herborthb , Gabi Schlagc and Christian Weberd a Goethe University Frankfurt, Campus Westend - PEG-Geba¨ude, Hauspostfach 24, Gru¨neburgplatz 1, D-60323, Frankfurt am Main, Germany. University of Groningen, Faculty of Arts, Oude Kijk in ’t Jatstraat 26, 9712 EK Groningen, The Netherlands. Otto-von-Guericke University Magdeburg, Faculty of Human Sciences, Zschokkestr. 32 (G-40), 39104 Magdeburg, Germany. d Goethe-University Frankfurt, Faculty of Social Sciences, “The West: a securitizing community?” Journal of International Relations, Volume 20, Issue Number 2//ekc

How political relations among European and North American states have developed and how they have contributed to shaping global politics more broadly has been at the centre of IR debates for several decades. Taking issue with both realist and institutionalist scholarship on the origins and mechanisms of inter-state alliances, the literature on security communities (Adler and Barnett 1998) has highlighted the constructivist bedrock argument that political order can be conceived of only as the result of ongoing processes of social interaction. Hence, at least two reasons as to why the security community literature provides an instructive starting point come to mind. First, the security community approach originated as a perspective attempting to transcend the state-centric perspective of IR and, in particular, security studies. It thereby allows us, second, to conceive of ‘the West’ as a political space characterised by transnational processes of political association and integration. Political entities such as security communities are not perceived as just being ‘out there’, but are seen as the result of transformative processes such as the formation of collective identities through social learning. Hence, as we share these premises, choosing the security community literature as a foil to develop our own argument means to engage relatively close kin. We can thus not only deliberately refrain from restaging the arguments vis-a`-vis realist, liberal, and institutionalist accounts, we can also focus more specifically on the dynamics by means of which ‘the West’ is invoked, reproduced, and eventually transformed, for this is precisely where we beg to differ with the storyline conventionally presented by proponents of a security community approach. In a nutshell, we argue that the literature on security communities simply does not go far enough in stepping outside of the imaginative geographies characterized above.

The initial work on security communities that was conducted in the 1950s by Deutsch et al. (1957/1968) was driven by an interest in identifying the complex processes and mechanisms which enabled the permanent elimination of war between states, in particular in the ‘North Atlantic area’. They focused on ‘integration’ as a complex process by which security communities might come about. Most importantly they were interested in examining how a ‘sense of community’, central to their account of ‘integration’, could take shape in diverse and unique historical circumstances.

In discussing the issue of how one ought to distinguish between ‘integration’ and ‘non-integration’ Deutsch and his collaborators argued that the achievement of a security community would have to involve ‘something like the crossing of a threshold’. The problem was that [s]omewhat contrary to our expectation [y] some of our cases taught us that integration may involve a fairly broad zone of transition rather than a narrow threshold; that states may cross and recross this threshold or zone of transition several times in their relations with each other; and that they might spend decades or generations wavering uncertainly within it. (ibid.: 32–33)

Thus, not only did integration turn out to be a rather complex process involving at least a dozen ‘essential conditions’ (ibid.: 58), it was also evolving along unique historical trajectories in uneven ways. As a result, Deutsch and his colleagues concluded that a ‘sense of community’ should not be applied ‘as a matter of static agreement’ and that ‘more could be learned by viewing it as a matter of dynamic process’ (ibid.: 37).

This keen sense of the processual complexity and non-linearity of political integration got by and large lost in subsequent research on security communities in general and in research on the transatlantic security community in particular. Rather than taking Deutsch’s warning about the ‘uncertain wavering’ between integration and non-integration seriously, the research agenda on security communities was increasingly shaped by a premise ‘that community exists at the international level’ (Adler and Barnett 1998: 3, italics added). Moreover, rather than dwelling on the Deutschian twilight zone between integration and non-integration, Adler and Barnett suggested looking for various groups of states that seemed to have abandoned the use of force in their relations in order to determine whether they fit the definition of a pluralistic security community. In particular, researchers were advised to ‘look for communities where actors have shared identities, values, and meanings, many-sided relations, and long-term reciprocity’ (ibid.: 33). If these criteria were met, and the citizens of these states held ‘dependable expectations of peaceful change’, then we would have reason to speak of a security community.

Not only does such a perspective neglect Deutsch’s interest in open-ended transformative processes, it also embraces a strong methodological preference for detecting something, which is both theoretically proclaimed and normatively embraced. Researchers, then, may lose a thorough and systematic reconstruction of social dynamics and contingencies out of sight. Pointing to the 19th-century heritage of the term, Charles Tilly (1998: 397) offers a particularly clear-cut elaboration of the problem: A haze of Paradigm Lost still surrounds the word ‘community’ in popular parlance, the social sciences, philosophy, and history. Calling up idealized images of solidarity and coherent identity in compact settlements before the advent of today’s complexity, the term almost inevitably evokes a mixture of description, sentiment, and moral principle. Users of the term with respect to international relations are usually hoping to create or restore solidarity among nations. This volume [Adler and Barnett 1998], with its quest not merely to identify but also to promote security communities, manifests just such a hope.

Much like Tilly, we share the hope but remain troubled when it seems to impinge on the actual research process. In his work on the endurance of the transatlantic security community after 1990, Thomas Risse, for instance, similarly focused on postulating the existence of such a community as the key variable in explaining transatlantic cohesion. Instead of taking NATO as an institutional solution to deal with a multifaceted set of threats and risks (as realists would do), he argues that the alliance was the expression of an underlying community of shared values built on ‘mutual sympathy, trust, and consideration’ (Risse-Kappen 1996: 368). In this reading a ‘Western’ perception of a ‘Soviet threat’ certainly helped to foster a sense of common purpose within NATO, but according to Risse ‘it did not create the community in the first place’. Rather, ‘the collective identity led to the threat perception, not the other way around’ (Risse-Kappen 1995: 32). In this view the creation and persistence of the North Atlantic Alliance could be explained as the institutional expression of ‘the values and norms embedded in the political culture of liberal democracies’, which together constituted the ‘collective identity of a security community among democracies’ (Risse-Kappen 1996: 370; Schimmelfennig 1998: 213–4). As long as these values and norms are not seriously challenged by its members, ‘the West’ appears as an impressively stable security community in which conflicts are still resolved peacefully (Pouliot 2006; critically Cox 2005).

In contrast to Deutsch’s initial work, this type of research is not particularly interested in the complex processes that lead to the creation of security communities in the first place. Instead, it takes the existence of a transatlantic security community already for granted and appears to accept, at least implicitly, an essentialist conception of community. Once again, a ‘we-concept’ is taken to be based on a set of values and norms, which are always already there. To be sure, most scholarship on security communities acknowledges that security communities are constructed in social interaction. However, rather than focusing on such interactions and reconstructing the ensuing complex processes empirically, Deutsch’s successors often propose models with preestablished definitions of ‘conducive factors’ and ‘necessary conditions’ that supposedly foster the development or persistence of security communities. Adler and Barnett (1998: 37), for instance, concede that they do this in a ‘highly stylized manner’. Yet, they feel obliged to do so in order to overcome two drawbacks associated with Deutsch’s operationalization of security communities: (1) the concept was resistant to precise operationalization because it was fuzzy and ill-defined; and, (2) while Deutsch’s behavioral methodology was able to capture increased transboundary movements that suggested interdependence, it could not detect a greater sense of cohesion and community based on mutual responsiveness, value orientation, and identity. The current challenge is to devise indicators that overcome these shortcomings. (ibid.: 48–49, italics added)

In other words, where Deutsch’s processualism cautioned against a constricted fixation on abstract ‘indicators’, the approach adopted by Adler and Barnett narrowly circumscribes the problem of how inter-state communities emerge by formal definitions from the very beginning. The actual efforts are then directed at identifying already existing security communities and then to determine whether they qualify as ‘loosely coupled’ or ‘tightly coupled’. Hence, the second generation of security community researchers not only assumes that communities and shared values already exist, but also focuses methodologically on identifying indicators instead of analysing processes. However, while many of the substantive claims of the second generation sound quite plausible, it remains methodologically unclear how to decide, for example, whether groups of states do indeed have ‘shared identities’ or whether their relations are characterised by ‘long-term reciprocity’. Some critics have therefore objected that Adler and Barnett’s framework was ‘not backed by a compelling method of empirical investigation’ (Bially Mattern 2000: 303). Their discussion of questions of research design suggests that scholars could easily identify features of security communities that self-evidently exist, just waiting to be discovered. This understanding seems to rest on the belief that security communities were ‘out there’, independent of the concepts social scientists apply (Jackson 2008: 134–43).

Yet, to treat democratic values or human rights, for instance, as attributes that specific societies possess or acquire is to conceal the intersubjective construction of these concepts and to ignore their productive, even hegemonic power. This is the reason why Iver Neumann and Michael Williams have proposed that constructivist analyses of NATO’s enlargement should consider the alliance’s self-description as a ‘democratic security community’ not as an unproblematic fact but as a way of exercising symbolic power. Claiming a democratic identity can then be interpreted as a political practice that assigns legitimacy to NATO’s actions and at the same time structures the realm of possibilities for acceptable Russian self-conceptions. Hence, the ‘capacity to claim such identities, and to grant and deny them to others, is a source of social power’ (Williams and Neumann 2000: 364).

An approach that treats references to common Western values as evidence for an alleged reality — the existence of a transatlantic security community — risks committing an essentialist fallacy by taking the invocation of these depictions at face value. One problematic consequence of such an account is that it becomes methodologically impossible to distinguish between a political assertion of ‘shared values’ and its performative effects. Assuming an already existing transatlantic security community with certain ‘shared values’ and a ‘collective identity’ tends to reify prevalent notions of political discourse instead of interpreting them as an element in processes of social construction. In our view, claims to a democratic identity of NATO or public commitments to human rights constitute a valuable body of empirical material that social scientists ought to be interested in. However, instead of treating them as evidence for an alleged ‘Western’ identity, we suggest treating them as a distinct and powerful move in a political struggle (Jackson 2006b). Invocation of ‘Western values’ or a ‘democratic identity’ can then be interpreted with regard to their performative effects and institutional consequences.

Thus, instead of presupposing the existence of an Atlantic security community, we are interested in reconstructing processes of community formation, that is, processes that lead to the evolution, reproduction and transformation of an inter-state political space commonly described as ‘the West’ (e.g., Jackson 2003; Bially Mattern 2005). Just like Deutsch and his colleagues, we assume that political orders are integrated via the construction and reproduction of a sense of community in complex and non-linear dynamic processes. However, in contrast to the initial work on security communities, which focused on measuring the quantity and density of transactions, we propose that the emergence and the reproduction of a sense of community should be studied by focusing on the productive power of representations in contingent processes of signification. As these processes of community formation are open ended and nonlinear, they can be reconstructed from within by interpreting how contentious references to ‘the West’ operate in political discourse.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.