Satellite images can be used by presidents to define reality in a way that makes it impossible for the public to critique or question the notion of a threat --- causes threat construction and pre-emptive action
Avery Henry 16, Assistant Professor of Public Address/Debate in the Communication Studies department at Southeast Missouri State University, 1/1/2016, “Interactive Security: The Rhetorical Constitution Of Algorithmic Citizenship In War On Terror Discourse”, Wayne State University, https://www.proquest.com/docview/1817028942?parentSessionId=EG2phuaMWUV2mQ2oMs8guYJGp86fVzuaw1k9hbrV14A%3D&pq-origsite=primo&accountid=14667 /lg
Presidential definition. The last function or technique of presidential public address that I examine in this chapter is the use of definition. President Bush’s attempts to shape public memory highlights the fluidity of social reality. In a postmodern sense, social reality is fluid, pliable, and full of potential. It is not a given, natural, or predetermined state of affairs. Instead, it is chosen from a multiplicity of possibilities. Zarefsky (2004) contends that political actors contribute to the production of social reality and that people actively participate in shaping and giving meaning to the world around them. The primary way that people constitute their social reality is through naming the world around them. By naming a situation, people shape the context for understanding social reality and determine the parameters for engagement. Therefore, the ability to define and name is rhetorically very powerful. Defining is the power to identify, name, and bring forth or allow something new to emerge into a field of signification. In addition to allowing new meanings and signs to be constituted and emerge, definitions also frame how something should be understood. It dictates what something is, what value it has, and the meaning that it signifies.
Zarefsky (2004) argues that the office of the president has a sustainable ability to define political reality. The president has unique access and authority to communicate with a wide range of audiences. For instance, the president can address the nation through an electronic broadcast, communicate with the press and shape the context in which the public encounter specific events, and speak directly with policy-makers in Congress. By choosing to define political situations in specific ways with these audiences, the president is able to frame reality as if it were natural and uncontestable rather than selected and open to critique or discussion. Furthermore, through framing, the president can dictate what constitutes credible and worthy arguments, data, and proof (Zarefsky, 2004). Take for example, the evidence offered by the Bush administration to prove that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. The Administration provided satellite images of what it considered to be proof that Iraq possessed WMDs. However, the satellite data could only be analyzed and understood by technical experts. Consequently, Bush was able to define Iraq as a threat to U.S. national security by controlling what counted as sufficient evidence. This control of what constituted data prevented the public from challenging the presidential definition of WMD threat because it was incapable of analyzing the evidence that was being presented to them and contesting was it was ample proof. Therefore, the way that the American public understood the situation in Iraq was framed in terms of threat construction that foreclosed or discredited any discussion about whether or not Iraq posed an actual threat to national security.
Additionally, by defining Iraq as a terrorist and WMD threat, Bush was able to control the discussion about appropriate courses of actions in response to the risk. If Iraq has WMDs, then the U.S. was justified in taking pre-emptive action to eliminate WMD use. Furthermore, presidential definition invited moral judgments that concluded that Saddam Hussain and his regime was evil and oppressive and warranted elimination. This was done in two parts: first, Iraq was included in the “Axis of Evil” that was defined as the primary enemy facing the U.S.; second, Hussain’s regime was bad enough to justify one war against it and now there are claims of WMD possession. Such an evil and oppression regime necessarily had to be invaded through the definitional logic of the Bush administration.