Rhetoric of the “Chinese space threat” proves space threats are often constructed --- it was labeled “existential” but nothing happened
Cameron Hunter 18, PhD in philosophy from University of Bristol, 09/25/2018, “The Rise of China in Space: Technopolitical Threat Construction in American Public Policy Discourse”, University of Bristol, https://research-information.bris.ac.uk/en/studentTheses/the-rise-of-china-in-space / lg
Almost every American source that cares to mention China’s space program agrees that its recent surge to prominence constitutes a grave threat to the national security of the United States of America. A streak of technological determinism was a recurring feature of within these debates, particularly after 2000 (see Parts 2 and 3). Chinese space technologies were instrumentalised as tools for the destruction of the US, contextualised with wider representations of China as a reckless and aggressive space power (see Chapter 6). Coupled with the instrumentalisation of American space technology as essential, in an ontological sense, to the nation, the “Chinese space threat” narrative became existential in scope. According to many of the proponents of this discourse, China’s rising space power would inevitably entail a mix of fear, conflict and space (arms) racing. Yet the irrefutability of the “Chinese space threat” in US public policy discourse conceals a multitude of tensions and inconsistencies.
Asking “how” the threat came to be has revealed its uneven construction, and thus by extension demonstrated how misguided technologically determinist arguments about the “rise” have been. Part 1 showed both how the “threat” has varied over time, in some instances becoming side-lined in favour of cooperation in space. It also demonstrated how space has inconsistently appeared in broader American debates about China’s “rise” more generally, sometimes cited as evidence of the “rise,” elsewhere obscured by other foreign policy concerns. Part 2 showed how advocates of the “Chinese space threat” differed in which aspects of American identity, and which corresponding technologies, they valued and portrated as imperilled by China’s “rise” in space. Finally, Part 3 underlined the appearance of unevenness by inquiring after the policies and procurements which were undertaken in the name of the “Chinese space threat.” Beyond the maintenance of the ITAR restrictions already in place at the start of the century and the limitations on NASA-China interaction imposed in 2011, no new policies were sanctioned in line with what by any other measure was an incredibly dominant discourse. This disjuncture is the most pressing evidence for the uneven construction of China’s “rise” in space, and sets up a puzzle for future research to address. Despite this puzzle, the lack of a technological response is itself is best understood as a part of technopolitical contestation within American public policy discourse. Viewed in this light, the determinism of the “Chinese space threat” remained unmanifested. In other words, the “Chinese space threat” was a kind of “dog that didn’t bark” where the omission of response is itself evidence worthy of consideration.