Turns the case---the logic of the US “lagging behind or “losing the race” is used to generate more threats – this serves to justify the expansion of the US war machine and results in serial policy failure
Nima Shirazi & Adam Johnson 20, Nima Shirazi is a co-creator & co-host of citation needed podcast and Board Member @ Proteus Fund, Adam Johnson is a co-host of citation needed, “Episode 117: The Always “Lagging” U.S. War Machine”, Citations Needed, 09/09/2020, https://citationsneeded.medium.com/episode-117-the-sl-lagging-u-s-war-machine-52b8960aedc3 \\pairie
We just can’t win. We’re perma-lagging. So this was written by Charles Beames. The bio in the op-ed says Beames, quote, “is executive chairman at York Space Systems” which is kind of buried, without mentioning that York Space Systems at the time was up for a major government contract that would have benefited greatly from the policies the piece was lobbying for. In Spring of 2020, Beames’s small firm was awarded a $450,000 contract for “SPACE VEHICLE MAINTENANCE, REPAIR, AND CHECKOUT SPECIALIZED EQUIPMENT V126 TRANSPORTATION/TRAVEL/RELOCATION- TRANSPORTATION: SPACE TRANSPORTATION/LAUNCH.” So that’s just one contract, they may have others. So here you have someone who’s, I mean, so much of these things, again, whether or not they’re laundered through think tanks are directly the corporate CEOs themselves or they are military brass whose careers are based on the acquisition of funds, they’re just marketing tools basically. This is just like any other, anyone who’s ever worked in marketing, getting an op-ed on CNN saying, ‘Man, we really need to buy all this stuff. Oh, incidentally, my firm happens to sell this’ would seem like a sort of conflict of interest you’d want to disclose but again, if you sort of keep it a half a degree removed, then it’s just normal journalism.
Nima: Right now I know we’ve mentioned the United States outspending every other country on the planet by a lot when it comes to military spending. It’s very similar in terms of the US outspending its supposedly adversaries like China and Russia when it comes to this space race. You wouldn’t know it from these articles — we’re always lagging behind — but according to account by the Massachusetts-based Union of Concerned Scientists, the US military and other government agencies, universities and private companies together operated over 1,300 satellites as of March 2020. China, in contrast, operates 363 satellites and Russia itself has 169 satellites. So the United States has exponentially more satellite capability. NASA’s 2020 budget was more than $22 billion, while the White House’s 2021 federal budget request allotted $15.4 billion to the newly formed Space Force. So yeah, the US leads the world in space spending. It’s not even close. Closest behind the US budget in this regard is China, which spends a mere $8 billion, according to the Space Foundation, a US nonprofit that tracks these things, and despite the impression that China wants to accelerate military combat in space, China is actually called the Space Force a, quote, “direct threat to outer space peace and security” end quote. Meanwhile, Russia’s own government run space agency has kind of pulled back on its own budget. In 2014 it was about $5 billion, six years later, this year, 2020, it is only $1.7 billion.
Adam: So one of the things I can’t do is I can’t tell you how many times in the stories the US has simultaneously said to be lagging behind, and then the very next section they say, the US’s dominance is being threatened.
Nima: (Laughs.) Right.
Adam: And I think what they mean by lagging behind, they mean if I’m the LA Lakers and I’m playing a high school basketball team, and we’re only up 20 points, they’d be like we’re lagging behind the expectations to be up 40 points. So of course no one’s really being lagged behind here but the average reader reads that and they think, ‘Oh my gosh, you know, we’re going to lose primacy to the evil Chicoms and Ruskies.’ This is also very common in cyber security and other technology. CNN in November of 2017, quote, “US risks losing artificial intelligence arms race to China and Russia,” reads the headline. Note the headline doesn’t even bother with “according to US officials” or “according to NATO” or “according to US military spokesman,” it’s just asserted as fact. The whole premise is propped up by statements from Deputy Defense Secretary Robert Work. Quote, “More than 60 years after a space race rivalry with the Soviet Union ushered in a new era of ballistic missile development, the US is facing another ‘Sputnik moment.’” A lot of these articles talk about the Sputnik moment. It’s sort of think-tankese for ‘Oh, we could be caught off guard by being inferior. We were beaten for 10 minutes in 1957.’
Nima: It’s the same way any article about Iran talks about the hostage crisis. It’s that kind of poke in the eye that will never be forgiven, and therefore the US foreign policy of vengeance will continue in perpetuity.
Adam: Other sources of the article in fact, the only other sources included in the article, are a September report from the RAND Corporation, which of course is 90 percent funded by the Defense Department, State Department and, quote, “former Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel.” So again, it’s just the military saying the military needs more money. Not a surprise. I wish citations had more money. Marketplace.com, August of 2018, headline reads, “U.S. lagging behind in race for tech supremacy.” The article uncritically cites a report from the Atlantic Council, which was done in tandem with the company Qualcomm.
CNBC, the next year, the headline read, “The US is falling behind China in crucial race for AI dominance.” This was written by Frederick Kempe, President and CEO of the Atlantic Council who was the main source of the previous article we mentioned. The Atlantic Council, of course their major funders are, aside from oil companies and US and state governments are very much weapons contractors. Major donors include Lockheed Martin, Boeing, BAE Systems, Raytheon, Palantir, as well as direct financing from NATO itself.
So you’ll be surprised to learn that the Atlantic Council always thinks we’re behind. The Hill, July 2019, the headline reads, “US risks falling behind China on technology and innovation, if we don’t reset our priorities.” It’s potentially a paid op-ed. The Hill’s unusual in that it actually lets people pay you to write for them, which is not usually standard practice. It’s actually very frowned upon. But this is an op-ed by Robert Hormats, who’s VP of Kissinger Associates, a global consultancy firm with a ton of weapons contractor clients and government clients, sort of a who’s who of the deep state as it were.
Nima: Don’t let the name fool you, it actually does mean Henry Kissinger.
Adam: He is a former vice president of Goldman Sachs and is on the board of directors of, you guessed it, the Atlantic Council. So again, you have this idea that we’re always lagging being because that’s what they get paid to say. As one would expect the US budget exceeds that of the countries we’re allegedly falling behind. The US is legitimately lagging in some areas of technological development, we should be clear, and there are certain aspects like we have less naval ships than China, for example, but we also have far less naval ships than North Korea, because naval ships includes little tiny little boats, we also have far more aircraft carriers than China, which is really what matters. So people always sort of find it, you know, Mitt Romney did this line where he says the US’s Navy is smaller than it was during World War I and Obama replied, ‘Well, we also have less horses and buggies and bayonets.’ So like, you can always sort of twist anything and make it look like we’re behind but the one sort of objective reference point is how much money is allotted to it. That’s sort of a good way of looking at it and no matter how you look at it, the US out spends everyone on nukes, on ships, on AI capacity, on online disinformation, you name it, we spend more money. So either we’re spending the money badly, or we’re just pissing away money, or the US isn’t actually really lagging behind, it’s just a kind of permanent threat.
For example, the US cybersecurity budget in 2020 was $17.4 billion, almost $800 million increase over the previous year, whereas China’s government cybersecurity project was $7 billion. So again, we go back to the budget, we’re sort of not lagging behind. Before we talk to Jim, I want you to envision a headline, in cnn.com, you open your browser window and you see the headline, ‘US government officials: Actually we have all the money we need.’ Or imagine this headline in NPR, ‘NATO spokesman or the RAND Corporation New Report: US’s Military Supremacy in Pacific is Fully Funded and Totally Okay,’ you would never see that. God forbid you would even see this, which is, you know, a headline in NBC.com. ‘US General: We actually have more money than we need, we’d like to give this excess billion dollars to healthcare or to give to first responders of coronavirus healthcare,’ this would just not happen right? Because all they do all the time is say they don’t have enough money, because what the fuck else would you say? That’s what your job is, your job is like any other startup or any other business, which is you’re always fundraising, you’re always raising money and think tanks provide the foe academic veneer of an industry who’s like any other industry, especially ones that are totally parasitic, which they mostly are, which is to just keep fucking sucking the blood off of the public till.
Nima: And that’s why everything is always positioned as a race. There’s a space race, there’s an arms race, there’s an AI arms race, the cybersecurity arms race, the propaganda arms race, we don’t want to lose the race and so when you position things as a race, we’re always trying to catch up and overtake and win and when you position things like that, you can just continually make the argument that we need more power, more speed, more money. So to talk more about this, we are going to be joined by friend of the show Jim Naureckas of Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting, FAIR, where he has edited FAIR’s print publication Extra! since 1990. Jim will join us in just a moment. Stay with us.